Appliance Diffusion Model for Energy Efficiency Standards and Labeling Evaluation in the Capital of Lao Pdr

Hajime Sasaki, Ichiro Sakata, Weerin Wangjiraniran, Sengprasong PhrakonkhamJournal of Sustainable Development of Energy Water and Environment Systems 2015 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper develops an econometric model to understand appliance ownership in Vientiane City, Lao PDR, a developing nation looking to implement energy efficiency policies. By analyzing household survey data, the study identifies key drivers of appliance adoption, such as income and electricity consumption, to inform the design and prioritization of Energy Efficiency Standards and Labeling (EES&L) programs.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Developing countries are experiencing rapid economic growth, leading to a surge in energy demand. While Energy Efficiency Standards and Labeling (EES&L) is a proven policy tool for managing this demand in many nations, countries like Lao PDR are only beginning to consider its implementation. To effectively design and deploy EES&L policies, a deep understanding of how and why households acquire appliances is crucial. This paper addresses the lack of such demand-side data in Lao PDR by collecting and analyzing household appliance possession patterns in Vientiane City, aiming to provide a foundation for future EES&L policy development.

Methods

The study employs a logistic regression analysis to model the possession of various appliances as a binary dependent variable (i.e., whether a household owns an appliance or not). The independent variables considered include:

  • Income level: Categorized into several brackets.
  • Household size: Represented by the number of males and females.
  • Electricity consumption: Measured in kWh/month.
  • House type: Dummy variables for concrete, wooden, or mixed construction.
  • District: Dummy variables for different districts within Vientiane City.

This approach allows the researchers to identify which socio-economic and consumption factors significantly influence the likelihood of a household owning a particular appliance. The use of logistic regression is a standard technique for binary outcome prediction, but its application here to a specific developing country context with newly collected data is a key aspect of the study.

Datasets

The primary dataset for this study was collected through an interview survey of 600 households in Vientiane City, Lao PDR. Of these, 577 usable responses were obtained. This survey is highlighted as the first of its kind for collecting data on household appliance possession in Vientiane City. The paper also references external data for context, such as the World Telecommunication/ICT Indicators Database for mobile phone diffusion rates.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Income and electricity consumption are key drivers, but appliance-specific: The study reveals that while income and electricity consumption are generally important predictors of appliance ownership, their influence varies significantly depending on the appliance. This highlights the need for tailored EES&L strategies rather than a one-size-fits-all approach.
  • Refrigerators are ubiquitous: With a diffusion rate of 94%, refrigerators are almost universally owned in Vientiane City, making them less sensitive to socio-economic factors. This suggests that EES&L for refrigerators might have a broad impact, but the focus might need to be on ensuring compliance with existing (potentially forged) labels.
  • District-level variations matter for some appliances: The analysis found that the district of residence can be a significant predictor for the possession of certain appliances, such as split-wall air conditioners. This points to potential localized market dynamics or access differences that EES&L policies might need to consider.
  • High-consumption appliances are linked to electricity use, not just income: Appliances like vacuum machines and PCs, which are often high-consumption, are strongly correlated with electricity consumption but not necessarily with income. This suggests that even for lower-income households, the use of electricity is a more significant factor in acquiring these items than their initial purchase price.
  • The future of TVs is shifting: While CRT TVs are widely diffused, the study notes their declining market share, with LCD/LED TVs becoming more prevalent and strongly linked to higher income and electricity consumption, indicating a shift towards more energy-intensive, albeit potentially more efficient, technologies.

Key Results

  • Refrigerators: Possession is nearly universal (94% diffusion) and not significantly influenced by any of the independent variables tested.
  • Air Conditioners (Split Wall Type): Possession is significantly influenced by monthly income (P<0.001) and electricity consumption (P<0.001), and notably by the Sisatthanak district.
  • Air Conditioners (Split Floor Type): Possession is not significantly influenced by monthly income or electricity consumption, but is linked to the Saysettha district.
  • TVs (CRT): Possession is influenced by monthly income (P<0.1), number of females in the household (P<0.05), electric consumption (P<0.1), and the districts of Sikhotabong (P<0.01) and Sisatthanak (P<0.05).
  • TVs (LCD/LED): Possession is strongly influenced by monthly income (P<0.001), electric consumption (P<0.001), and the Sikhotabong district (P<0.01).
  • CFLs: Possession is influenced by monthly income (P<0.05) and the number of females in the household (P<0.05), and notably by the Saysettha district.
  • Vacuum Machines: Possession is strongly influenced by electric consumption (P<0.001) and the Hadsaifong district (P<0.05).
  • PCs: Possession is influenced by electric consumption (P<0.001).
  • Microwaves: Possession is influenced by monthly income (P<0.05) and electric consumption (P<0.001).

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations:

  • Data limitations: The study relies on a single survey in Vientiane City, and comprehensive public statistics for demand-side analysis are lacking in Lao PDR.
  • Focus on possession, not quantity: The analysis models the possession of an appliance (yes/no) rather than the number of units owned, which could provide a more nuanced understanding.
  • Potential for forged labels: The paper mentions that energy efficiency labels on refrigerators are reportedly forged, indicating a need for immediate corrective actions beyond just diffusion analysis.

Future work suggested by the authors includes:

  • Expanding the scope: Conducting similar surveys and analyses for the commercial sector, not just the residential sector, to get a comprehensive view of EES&L implementation across Lao PDR.
  • More specific analysis: Implementing more detailed analyses using the collected data and presenting findings to the government to inform policy.
  • Considering economic growth and population: Focusing on appliances with significant contribution from population growth and economic growth, respectively, for future policy prioritization.

Summary updated

Abstract

Because of the rapid growth of energy demand in developing countries, policies for energy efficiency are receiving increasing attention. Although energy efficiency standards and labeling (EES&amp;L) is a standard policy tool in many countries, some developing countries, such as Lao PDR, have not yet implemented them fully. In order to understand the potential impact of EES&amp;L, this paper aims at collecting data that contribute to EES&amp;L and at analysing appliance possessions in Vientiane City, Lao PDR. We conducted an interview survey on 600 households in Vientiane City and performed logistic regression analysis that set possession of appliances as the dependent variable. As a result of the analysis, we identified that the income level and the electricity consumption are the principal independent variables and the relationship of these variables with possession rates depends on appliances. Our model helps identify appliances that are expected to be in high demand associated with either economic growth or human population increase in Vientiane City.
BibTeX
@article{sasaki2015appliance,
  author = {Hajime Sasaki and Ichiro Sakata and Weerin Wangjiraniran and Sengprasong Phrakonkham},
  title = {{Appliance Diffusion Model for Energy Efficiency Standards and Labeling Evaluation in the Capital of Lao Pdr}},
  journal = {Journal of Sustainable Development of Energy Water and Environment Systems},
  year = {2015},
  doi = {10.13044/j.sdewes.2015.03.0021},
}
Figure