Apparent extracellular current density and extracellular space: basis for the current source density analysis in neural tissue

Hiroyoshi Miyakawa, Toru AonishiarXiv 2012 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract

This paper establishes a rigorous theoretical bridge between Maxwell’s equations and Current Source Density (CSD) analysis, a staple technique for interpreting brain signals like EEG and LFP. By introducing the concepts of "apparent extracellular space" and frequency-dependent permittivity and conductivity, the authors derive a generalized CSD equation. This framework accounts for the significant dielectric dispersion observed in biological tissues at low frequencies, providing a more accurate basis for relating macroscopic electrical signals to cellular-level electrophysiological processes.

The Theoretical Gap in CSD Analysis

In systems neuroscience, researchers utilize Current Source Density (CSD) analysis to locate where ions enter or leave neurons based on extracellular potential measurements. Despite its widespread use, a persistent theoretical "fuzziness" exists in its derivation. Many standard models treat the CSD equation as a simple analog to Poisson’s equation (which relates potential to static charge).

This paper argues that such an approach is a fundamental misunderstanding. CSD is fundamentally about the conservation of current within a complex, multi-compartment medium. Furthermore, most conventional CSD models assume brain tissue is purely "ohmic" (resistive), entirely ignoring capacitive components. Given that biological tissue exhibits enormous dielectric dispersion at low frequencies—the very frequencies where EEG and LFP signals reside—ignoring these effects can lead to inaccurate interpretations of neural activity.

Methods: From Maxwell to Coarse-Graining

The authors employ a first-principles theoretical approach to resolve these inconsistencies:

  1. Maxwell’s Equations: The derivation begins with the full set of Maxwell’s equations in material media, focusing on the conservation of total current (the sum of conduction and displacement currents).
  2. Coarse-Graining: Because brain tissue is a heterogeneous mix of intracellular fluid, membranes, and interstitial space, the authors apply a coarse-graining technique. They average microscopic current densities over a mesoscopic volume (e.g., a 10-micron cube) to define a continuous "apparent" medium.
  3. Gauss’s Theorem: By applying the divergence theorem to this coarse-grained volume, they relate the "apparent extracellular current" to the actual membrane currents ($I_m$) crossing cell boundaries.
  4. Fourier Analysis: To account for frequency-dependent properties, the equations are moved into the frequency domain, allowing for a complex-valued conductivity that incorporates both resistive ($\sigma$) and capacitive ($\epsilon$) terms.

Key Insights: The "Apparent" Space and Dielectric Dispersion

A central concept introduced is the "Apparent" Space. The extracellular space in CSD analysis is not merely the physical fluid between cells; it is an abstraction that incorporates the electrical influence of nearby cell membranes and intracellular volumes.

This distinction is vital because permittivity is not negligible. While many researchers assume capacitive current is too small to matter, the relative permittivity of brain tissue at 10 Hz can be as high as $10^8$. The authors demonstrate that the ratio of capacitive to resistive current can reach approximately 0.9 near 10 Hz, meaning the capacitive flow is nearly as significant as the resistive flow.

To explain this frequency dependence, the paper provides an intuitive "parallel cylinder" model. At low frequencies, current is forced to travel around cells, creating secondary current loops through neighboring cells. These loops act as a relaxation process, which manifests macroscopically as the observed dielectric dispersion.

The Generalized CSD Equation

The primary result of this theoretical work is the derivation of a Generalized CSD Equation:

$$\nabla \cdot [(\sigma'(\omega) + i\omega\epsilon'(\omega))(-\nabla \phi_{ext}(\omega))] = I_{CSD}(\omega)$$

Where:

  • $\sigma'$ and $\epsilon'$ are the apparent conductivity and permittivity.
  • $\phi_{ext}$ is the recorded extracellular potential.
  • $I_{CSD}$ is the volume current density of the sources.

The authors show that the "conventional" CSD equation ($\sigma \nabla^2 \phi = -I_m$) is merely a special case. It only holds true when the tissue is isotropic and homogeneous, and when the frequency is high enough (or permittivity low enough) that the capacitive term is negligible ($\omega\epsilon'/\sigma' \ll 1$).

Addressing the Monopole Controversy

The paper also addresses the controversial "current monopole" issue in neuroscience. The authors demonstrate that if one integrates over a large enough volume to include all parts of the relevant cells, current monopoles disappear. This confirms that the generalized CSD approach remains consistent with the fundamental physical law of the conservation of total current.

Limitations and Future Directions

While providing a rigorous foundation, the theory assumes quasi-static conditions, meaning it ignores effects from varying magnetic fields. This is appropriate for neural tissue below 1 MHz but limits application in ultra-high-frequency contexts. Additionally, the "intuitive account" of cellular geometry remains qualitative. Future work involving detailed numerical simulations of specific cellular geometries could help calculate exact values for the apparent parameters ($\sigma'$ and $\epsilon'$) based on microscopic structure. Finally, new experimental protocols are needed to validate that this generalized approach provides superior source localization compared to standard resistive models.

Summary updated

Abstract

This article provides a theoretical basis for relating macroscopic electrical signals recorded from biological tissue, such as electroencephalogram (EEG) and local field potential (LFP), to the electrophysiological processes at the cellular level in a manner consistent with Maxwell's equations. Concepts of the apparent extracellular current density and the apparent extracellular space with apparent permittivity and conductivity are introduced from the conservation of current and Gauss's theorem. A general equation for the current source density (CSD) analysis is derived for biological tissue with frequency-dependent apparent permittivity and conductivity. An intuitive account of the apparent extracellular space is given to relate the concept to the dielectric dispersion of biological tissue.
BibTeX
@misc{miyakawa2012apparent,
  author = {Hiroyoshi Miyakawa and Toru Aonishi},
  title = {{Apparent extracellular current density and extracellular space: basis for the current source density analysis in neural tissue}},
  year = {2012},
  eprint = {1209.4722},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/1209.4722},
}
Figure