Apaf-1 is an evolutionarily conserved DNA sensor that switches the cell fate between apoptosis and inflammation

Jie Ruan, Xuxia Wei, Sen Li, Zijian Ye, Linyi Hu, Ran Zhuang, Yange Cao, Shaozhou Wang, Shengpeng Wu, Dezhi Peng, Shangwu Chen, Shaochun Yuan, Anlong XuCell 2025 · DOI

Abstract

Apoptotic protease activating factor 1 (Apaf-1) has long been characterized as a scaffold protein essential for assembling the "apoptosome"—a caspase activation platform—following its interaction with cytochrome c. However, despite its structural similarity to animal NOD-like receptors (NLRs) and plant resistance (R) proteins, its role in innate immunity remained elusive. This study identifies Apaf-1 as an evolutionarily conserved DNA sensor across species, including lancelets, fruit flies, mice, and humans. Upon recognizing cytoplasmic DNA, mammalian Apaf-1 recruits receptor-interacting protein 2 (RIP2) via its WD40 repeat domain, initiating NF-κB-driven inflammation. Crucially, DNA binding competes with cytochrome c for Apaf-1, acting as a molecular checkpoint that determines whether a cell undergoes apoptosis or initiates an inflammatory response.

Bridging the Evolutionary Gap in DNA Sensing

The innate immune system relies on detecting misplaced molecules, such as viral DNA in the cytoplasm, to trigger defense mechanisms. While the cGAS-STING pathway is the primary DNA-sensing mechanism in mammals, its evolutionary precursors in many invertebrates lack DNA-binding capabilities. This research sought a more primordial, universal DNA sensor by examining the lancelet (Branchiostoma belcheri), an evolutionary bridge between invertebrates and vertebrates.

Methods and Discovery

To identify novel DNA-binding proteins, researchers performed proteomic screening by incubating cytosolic extracts from lancelet cells with biotinylated DNA-coated beads. This "fishing" expedition identified a lancelet Apaf-1 homolog (BbeApaf-J) as a primary DNA binder.

To validate these findings in mammals, the team employed:

  • Biochemical Characterization: Surface Plasmon Resonance (SPR) and Electrophoretic Mobility Shift Assays (EMSA) were used to measure the binding affinity between human/mouse Apaf-1 and double-stranded DNA (dsDNA).
  • Genetic Models: CRISPR-Cas9 was used to generate Apaf-1 knockout (KO) cell lines (HeLa, A549, MEFs) to test immune responses independently of the cGAS-STING pathway.
  • In Vivo Studies: Apaf-1 heterozygous knockout mice were challenged with DNA viruses (HSV-1 and Vaccinia virus) to assess physiological survival and systemic inflammation.
Biochemical and structural characterization of Apaf-1 as a DNA sensor across species, showing high-affinity binding and competitive interaction with cytochrome c.

Key Insights: The Dual Identity of Apaf-1

1. A Molecular Tug-of-War

Apaf-1 exhibits a "secret life" as a DNA sensor. Traditionally, it binds cytochrome c to trigger apoptosis. However, structural modeling and biochemical assays reveal that dsDNA and cytochrome c compete for the same general regulatory region on Apaf-1. If dsDNA binds first, it physically occludes cytochrome c, effectively blocking the apoptotic pathway and switching the cell's fate toward inflammation.

2. The RIP2 Signaling Axis

Unlike its apoptotic role, where it recruits Caspase-9, the inflammatory role of Apaf-1 involves the recruitment of the adaptor protein RIP2 (RIPK2). This recruitment occurs via the WD40 repeat domain of Apaf-1 and promotes RIP2 oligomerization, which subsequently activates the NF-κB pathway to produce inflammatory cytokines.

Key Results and Physiological Significance

  • High-Affinity DNA Binding: Human and mouse Apaf-1 bind dsDNA with high affinity, with dissociation constants ($K_d$) in the low nanomolar range (e.g., $1.71 \times 10^{-7}$ M for hApaf-1 + HSV60).
  • cGAS-Independent Inflammation: In A549 cells (which are cGAS-competent), the loss of Apaf-1 significantly impaired the induction of inflammatory markers like CXCL1 and IL-6 following viral infection, demonstrating that Apaf-1 is a critical, independent component of the DNA-sensing machinery.
Apaf-1 deficiency impairs the inflammatory response (CXCL1 expression) in A549 cells following Vaccinia virus (VACV) infection.
  • Survival in Vivo: The physiological importance was underscored in mouse models; Apaf-1 deficiency led to a dramatic decrease in survival following HSV-1 infection (20% survival vs. 80% in wild-type) due to uncontrolled viral replication and a blunted inflammatory response.

Conclusion and Therapeutic Potential

These findings redefine Apaf-1 as a primordial DNA sensor that predates its role in cytochrome c-mediated apoptosis. By acting as a checkpoint between two critical cellular fates, Apaf-1 represents a novel therapeutic target. Modulating the Apaf-1 DNA-binding interface could potentially be used to force tumor cells (often high in damaged DNA) back into apoptosis or to suppress runaway inflammation in autoimmune contexts.

Summary updated

Abstract

Apoptotic protease activating factor 1 (Apaf-1) was traditionally defined as a scaffold protein in mammalian cells for assembling a caspase activation platform known as the 'apoptosome' after its binding to cytochrome c. Although Apaf-1 structurally resembles animal NOD-like receptor (NLR) and plant resistance (R) proteins, whether it is directly involved in innate immunity is still largely unknown. Here, we found that Apaf-1-like molecules from lancelets, fruit flies, mice, and humans have conserved DNA sensing functionality. Mechanistically, mammalian Apaf-1 recruits receptor-interacting protein 2 (RIP2, also known as RIPK2) via its WD40 repeat domain and promotes RIP2 oligomerization to initiate NF-κB-driven inflammation upon cytoplasmic DNA recognition. Furthermore, DNA binding of Apaf-1 determines cell fate by switching the cellular processes between intrinsic stimuli-activated apoptosis and inflammation. These findings suggest that Apaf-1 is an evolutionarily conserved DNA sensor and may serve as a cell fate checkpoint, which determines whether cells initiate inflammation or undergo apoptosis by distinct ligand binding.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{ruan2025apaf,
  author = {Jie Ruan and Xuxia Wei and Sen Li and Zijian Ye and Linyi Hu and Ran Zhuang and Yange Cao and Shaozhou Wang and Shengpeng Wu and Dezhi Peng and Shangwu Chen and Shaochun Yuan and Anlong Xu},
  title = {{Apaf-1 is an evolutionarily conserved DNA sensor that switches the cell fate between apoptosis and inflammation}},
  booktitle = {Cell},
  year = {2025},
  doi = {10.1038/s41421-024-00750-4},
}
Figure