Anytime Coordination for Progressive Planning Agents

AAAI 1999

TL;DR

This paper introduces an "anytime coordination" strategy for autonomous agents that need to plan and coordinate their actions under strict time constraints and limited resources. By allowing agents to progressively build and coordinate their plans, the system can deliver a satisfactory solution even if the optimal plan cannot be completed before a deadline, making it suitable for dynamic, real-world scenarios.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Coordinating multiple autonomous agents to achieve a common goal is a complex challenge, especially when agents have limited computational resources and strict deadlines. Traditional approaches often involve agents constructing a complete plan first and then attempting to coordinate it with others. However, in dynamic environments where new agents can appear or resources can become scarce, this sequential approach can fail to produce a solution before the deadline. The paper addresses the need for a coordination mechanism that can adapt to these constraints, providing a timely, albeit potentially suboptimal, plan when a complete, optimal plan is not feasible. This is particularly relevant in applications like airport ground service scheduling or distributed database transaction management.

Methods

The core of the paper is the "progressive planning" and "anytime coordination" technique. Agents use progressive planning, where their local plans are structured as a hierarchy of partial plans, from mandatory to optional. This allows them to adapt the level of detail in their plans based on available resources and deadlines. The "anytime coordination" strategy involves iterative cycles of partial planning and negotiation. After each partial planning step, the agent attempts to coordinate its current partial plan with those of other agents. This iterative process allows the system to interrupt at any time and return a coordinated partial plan. Conflicts between agents' plans are categorized into four types (hard critical, hard non-critical, soft critical, soft non-critical), and specific resolution strategies are employed based on these categories, often leveraging a utility function that balances rewards and penalties.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The evaluation uses simulated problem instances with 10 agents.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Anytime Coordination is Crucial for Real-time Systems: The paper highlights that in time-sensitive environments, the ability to deliver any coordinated plan before a deadline is more valuable than striving for an optimal plan that might never be completed.
  • Progressive Planning Adapts to Uncertainty: Hierarchical partial plans allow agents to dynamically adjust their planning effort, focusing on essential tasks when resources or time are scarce.
  • Iterative Coordination Minimizes Overhead: By coordinating partial plans incrementally, the system avoids unnecessary detailed planning and coordination for parts of the goal that might ultimately be discarded or modified.
  • Conflict Categorization Enables Targeted Resolution: Differentiating conflict types allows for more efficient and appropriate resolution strategies, preventing the system from getting bogged down in complex negotiations for less critical issues.
  • Utility-Based Conflict Resolution: Using a utility function that considers both rewards and penalties provides a principled way to make trade-offs when resolving conflicts between agents' plans.

Key Results

The experimental evaluation compares the proposed approach to a "basic approach" (similar to PGP) that constructs a complete plan before coordination.

  • Critical Situations: The proposed anytime coordination approach significantly outperforms the basic approach in terms of time consumption in critical situations (where deadlines are tight).
  • Non-Critical Situations: In non-critical situations, the basic approach is faster, but the proposed method still achieves a substantial quality gain.
  • Utility Gain: The paper demonstrates that the anytime coordination approach leads to a significant quality gain (measured by cumulative utility of coordinated partial plans) over the basic approach, especially when deadlines are considered. This is attributed to the ability to immediately coordinate partial plans, avoiding wasted planning effort.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Scalability: While the analysis suggests the approach is more suitable for large societies (O(n) complexity), the paper notes that in small societies, the complexity can approach O(n²).
  • Centralized Conflict Resolution: The paper mentions that while conflict detection is decentralized, resolution is centralized, which can be costly and time-consuming.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest extending the approach to auctions and multi-robot domains. They also aim to further explore its application in resource allocation problems.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@inproceedings{1999anytime,
  title = {{Anytime Coordination for Progressive Planning Agents}},
  booktitle = {AAAI Conference on Artificial Intelligence},
  year = {1999},
}
Figure