Antihelium from dark matter

E. M. Carlson, Adam Coogan, Tim Linden, Stefano Profumo, Alejandro Ibarra, Sebastian WildPhysical 2014 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract

Cosmic-ray antinuclei provide a promising discovery channel for the indirect detection of particle dark matter. Hadron showers produced by the pair annihilation or decay of Galactic dark matter generate antinucleons which can in turn form light antinuclei. Previous studies have only focused on the spectrum and flux of low energy antideuterons which, although very rarely, are occasionally also produced by cosmic-ray spallation. Heavier elements ($A\ge3$) have instead entirely negligible astrophysical background and a primary yield from dark matter which could be detectable by future experiments. Using a Monte Carlo event generator and an event-by-event phase space analysis, we compute, for the first time, the production spectrum of $^{3}\overline{\mathrm{He}}$ and $^{3}\overline{\mathrm{H}}$ for dark matter annihilating or decaying to $b\overline{b}$ and ${W}^{+}{W}^{\ensuremath{-}}$ final states. We then employ a semianalytic model of interstellar and heliospheric propagation to calculate the $^{3}\overline{\mathrm{He}}$ flux as well as to provide tools to relate the antihelium spectrum corresponding to an arbitrary antideuteron spectrum. Finally, we discuss prospects for current and future experiments, including GAPS and AMS-02.

Introduction

Indirect dark matter (DM) detection seeks to identify the products of DM annihilation or decay within our galaxy. While traditional searches focus on antiprotons or positrons, these channels suffer from significant astrophysical backgrounds—"noise" generated by standard cosmic-ray interactions with interstellar gas. Antideuterons ($^2\overline{\text{H}}$) have long been proposed as a cleaner alternative, yet they still possess a non-negligible background at low energies.

This research identifies antihelium-3 ($^3\overline{\text{He}}$) as a nearly background-free "smoking gun" for dark matter. The production of a nucleus with mass number $A=3$ requires the simultaneous coalescence of three antinucleons, a process so rare in standard astrophysical spallation that even a single detection at low energies would signify physics beyond the Standard Model.

Theoretical Framework: The Coalescence Model

To model the formation of these rare nuclei, the authors utilize PYTHIA 8.156 to simulate hadron showers from DM annihilating into $b\bar{b}$ or $W^+W^-$ final states. The core of the analysis is the Minimum Bounding Sphere (MBS) coalescence model. Unlike older isotropic models, this event-by-event phase space analysis requires all three constituent antinucleons to be within a specific momentum sphere ($p_0$) to form a nucleus.

Contours of the ratio of antihelium-3 to antideuteron production for various dark matter annihilation channels and masses, highlighting the sensitivity to coalescence momentum parameters.

A critical finding is that the antihelium flux is extremely sensitive to the coalescence momentum, scaling with $p_0^6$. As shown in the figure above, small variations in the assumed $p_0$ values for $A=2$ and $A=3$ nuclei lead to orders-of-magnitude differences in predicted yields. The study also highlights that a significant portion of the antihelium signal originates from the production and subsequent decay of antitritium ($^3\overline{\text{H}}$).

Propagation and Results

Following production, the antinuclei must traverse the Galactic magnetic fields and the solar wind. The authors employ a semi-analytic two-zone diffusion model for interstellar transport and the Force Field Approximation for heliospheric modulation. A key insight is that DM-produced antihelium spectra peak at low energies (< 1 GeV/n), whereas astrophysical backgrounds peak much higher (> 5 GeV/n).

Predicted antihelium-3 flux at Earth for different dark matter masses and annihilation channels, compared with the sensitivity limits of current (AMS-02, GAPS LDB) and future (GAPS SAT) experiments.

The results indicate that for every 1,000 antideuterons produced, approximately 1 to 10 antihelium-3 nuclei are expected. As illustrated in the flux predictions, current experiments like AMS-02 and the GAPS Long Duration Balloon (LDB) flights may lack the sensitivity to detect this signal except in the most optimistic DM scenarios. However, a proposed future satellite mission (GAPS SAT) could reach the necessary sensitivity to definitively probe this discovery space.

Conclusion and Future Outlook

Antihelium-3 represents a high-discovery-potential channel for dark matter due to its negligible astrophysical background. The primary limitation remains the nuclear physics uncertainty surrounding the coalescence momentum $p_0$. Future experimental data from high-energy colliders, such as the ALICE experiment at the LHC, will be vital to refining these predictions. Additionally, more complex numerical propagation models will be needed to better account for tertiary contributions from non-annihilating collisions in the interstellar medium.

Summary updated

Abstract

Cosmic-ray antinuclei provide a promising discovery channel for the indirect detection of particle dark matter. Hadron showers produced by the pair annihilation or decay of Galactic dark matter generate antinucleons which can in turn form light antinuclei. Previous studies have only focused on the spectrum and flux of low energy antideuterons which, although very rarely, are occasionally also produced by cosmic-ray spallation. Heavier elements ($A\ensuremath{\ge}3$) have instead entirely negligible astrophysical background and a primary yield from dark matter which could be detectable by future experiments. Using a Monte Carlo event generator and an event-by-event phase space analysis, we compute, for the first time, the production spectrum of $^{3}\overline{\mathrm{He}}$ and $^{3}\overline{\mathrm{H}}$ for dark matter annihilating or decaying to $b\overline{b}$ and ${W}^{+}{W}^{\ensuremath{-}}$ final states. We then employ a semianalytic model of interstellar and heliospheric propagation to calculate the $^{3}\overline{\mathrm{He}}$ flux as well as to provide tools to relate the antihelium spectrum corresponding to an arbitrary antideuteron spectrum. Finally, we discuss prospects for current and future experiments, including GAPS and AMS-02.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{carlson2014antihelium,
  author = {E. M. Carlson and Adam Coogan and Tim Linden and Stefano Profumo and Alejandro Ibarra and Sebastian Wild},
  title = {{Antihelium from dark matter}},
  booktitle = {Physical},
  year = {2014},
  doi = {10.1103/physrevd.89.076005},
}
Figure