Antifreeze design for Muon Detector of LHAASO

Feng Shaohui, Gang Xiao, Cong Li, Xiong Zuo, Lingyu Wang, Ning Cheng, He Hui-hai, Yi ZhangProceedings of 35th International Cosmic Ray Conference — PoS(ICRC2017) 2017 · DOI

Abstract

In the Large High Altitude Air Shower Observatory (LHAASO) project, Muon detectors (MD) are constructed at 4,400 meters above sea level. As water Cherenkov detectors, each unit requires 44 tons of ultrapure water. In this extreme high-altitude environment, the freezing of internal water would lead to catastrophic structural failure. This paper presents a thermodynamic simulation of water temperature, validated against prototype data from Yangbajing, Tibet. By incorporating site-specific environmental parameters, a specialized antifreeze insulation system was designed and successfully tested over a two-year period.

Introduction

The LHAASO project aims to study high-energy cosmic rays using an array of detectors, including Muon Detectors consisting of concrete tanks lined with ultrapure water. Located at an altitude of 4,400 meters, the site experiences temperatures as low as $-27.6^\circ C$. If the water inside these 44-ton tanks freezes, the resulting expansion would crack the concrete and destroy the internal liners. Ensuring the water remains liquid and functional is critical to the observatory's mission.

Methodology and Modeling

Researchers identified conduction as the primary heat transfer mechanism for the buried and surface-mounted detectors. To model the thermal environment, a transient thermal analysis was established using finite element methods.

Finite Element Simulation

The team constructed a simulation to model the temperature field surrounding the MD. To maintain computational efficiency, the soil was treated as an isotropic homogeneous medium, and the tank's symmetry was utilized to model only half of the vertical axis.

Finite element mesh used to simulate the temperature field around the Muon Detector and its surrounding soil environment.

Environmental Inputs

The simulation utilized several key datasets:

  • Material Properties: Specific heat capacity, density, and thermal conductivity for water, soil, air, and reinforced concrete.
  • Weather Data: Eight years of historical air temperature data from Yangbajing and DaoCheng were used to define "extreme case" scenarios.
  • Input Fitting: Ambient air temperature was modeled as a periodic sine function to simulate seasonal swings over multiple years.

Results and Validation

The simulation model was verified using temperature readings from two MD prototypes built in Tibet between 2012 and 2014. The results showed that the difference between simulated and measured water temperatures remained within $1^\circ C$, confirming the model's robustness.

Validation of the thermal model, comparing measured temperature data with the periodic sine function used for simulation.

Key Insights

  • Convection Effects: A significant observation was the accelerated heat exchange occurring between $3.5^\circ C$ and $4^\circ C$. Because water reaches maximum density at $4^\circ C$, internal convection is triggered, which must be accounted for in the thermal design.
  • Depth-Dependent Strategies: Detectors were categorized by burial depth (Marsh, Shallow, and Deep). The soil acts as a thermal buffer for deeper units, requiring less aggressive insulation than surface-mounted "Marsh" types.

Final Design and Field Success

Based on the validated simulations, the following insulation prescriptions were implemented using polyurethane (thermal conductivity of $0.04 W/m \cdot K$):

  • Marsh Type: Requires a 15cm polyurethane layer to maintain a minimum water temperature of $2.23^\circ C$.
  • Shallow/Deep Types: Require a 10cm polyurethane layer, maintaining temperatures above $0.73^\circ C$ even in extreme cold.

Following two years of field testing at the DaoCheng site, the design was confirmed successful, with no freezing events recorded. This insulation strategy ensures the long-term stability of the LHAASO Muon Detector array.

Limitations

Future refinements could improve the model by accounting for soil moisture variability, groundwater flow (heat transport via water movement), and the long-term aging characteristics of the polyurethane insulation material over the project's multi-decade lifespan.

Summary updated

Abstract

In the Large High Altitude Air Shower Observatory project, Muon detectors will be built at 4400m above sea level. As water cerenkov detector, 44 tons of ultrapure water should be infused into the Muon detector. In this cold area, once the water inside the Muon detector freezes, consequence would be very serious. In this paper, a simulation of water temperature is built, the simulation data are consistent with the temperature data of Muon detector at yangbajing Tibet. Using the same simulation with air temperature, soil moisture and temperature of Dao cheng, an antifreeze solution was designed. Through two years of testing, the design is successful.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{shaohui2017antifreeze,
  author = {Feng Shaohui and Gang Xiao and Cong Li and Xiong Zuo and Lingyu Wang and Ning Cheng and HE Hui-hai and Yi Zhang},
  title = {{Antifreeze design for Muon Detector of LHAASO}},
  booktitle = {Proceedings of 35th International Cosmic Ray Conference — PoS(ICRC2017)},
  year = {2017},
  doi = {10.22323/1.301.0435},
}
Figure