Abstract
Recent studies have reported the existence of an epitaxially stabilized tetragonal-like ("T-like") monoclinic phase in BiFeO3 (BFO) thin films under high levels of compressive strain. While their structural and ferroelectric properties are well-documented, little information has existed regarding their magnetic properties. Here, we report on a detailed neutron scattering study of a nearly phase-pure film of T-like BFO. By tracking the temperature dependence of superstructure peaks, we confirm antiferromagnetism with largely G-type character and a Néel temperature ($T_N$) of 324 K, significantly below the structural phase transition at 375 K. We also report evidence for a secondary magnetic phase, possibly with C-type character, with $T_N = 260$ K. The suppression of $T_N$ compared to bulk BFO is explained through increased Fe-O-Fe bond distances.
Introduction
Bismuth ferrite (BiFeO3) is a superstar in materials science as one of the few materials that is both ferroelectric and magnetic at room temperature. While it typically adopts a rhombohedral ("R-like") structure, epitaxial strain on substrates like $LaAlO_3$ (LAO) can transform it into a T-like phase with a massive $c/a$ ratio. Previous studies suggested the magnetic transition might be locked to a structural phase transition around 375 K. This study aims to resolve this debate by determining the exact magnetic structure and transition temperatures of T-like BFO.
Decoupling of Structural and Magnetic Transitions
A key finding of this research is the decoupling of structural and magnetic transitions. By monitoring the lattice parameters $a_{film}$ and $c_{film}$ as a function of temperature, a clear structural transition is observed near 375-380 K, where the lattice parameters begin to shift significantly.
However, neutron scattering data reveals that the magnetic order disappears at a lower temperature, proving that magnetism and structure are not as tightly coupled in this phase as previously thought.
Magnetic Phase Identification and Coexistence
Using elastic neutron scattering at the High-Flux Isotope Reactor (HFIR), the team measured the intensity of specific reciprocal lattice points. The temperature dependence of the (1/2 1/2 1/2) superstructure peak confirms a G-type antiferromagnetic order (where spins are antiparallel to all nearest neighbors) with $T_N = 324 \pm 4$ K.
Interestingly, the film exhibits a "magnetic dual-personality." As shown in the inset of the figure above, the (1/2 1/2 0) peak intensity vanishes at approximately 260 K. This indicates a secondary transition, likely corresponding to a minority C-type magnetic phase (where spins are antiparallel in-plane but parallel out-of-plane). The coexistence of these two phases may arise from local strain variations within the 300nm film.
Discussion: The "2D" Effect and Bond Scaling
The T-like phase has a very long $c$-axis, which stretches the Fe-O-Fe bonds in the vertical direction. This elongation effectively weakens the magnetic coupling between layers, making the system behave more like a 2D magnet. This explains why its $T_N$ (324 K) is much lower than the bulk R-like value (643 K). Monte Carlo simulations support this, showing that the suppression of $T_N$ is consistent with the $r^{-14}$ scaling of exchange interactions based on the increased bond lengths.
Conclusion
This study clarifies the magnetic landscape of T-like BiFeO3, identifying two distinct magnetic transitions and demonstrating their separation from the structural transition. These insights into the role of epitaxial strain on magnetic ordering temperatures are vital for the development of future multiferroic device applications.
Summary updated