TL;DR
This paper investigates how varying ammonia (NH3) pressure during low-temperature plasma nitriding affects the corrosion resistance of AISI 904L stainless steel in hydrofluoric acid (HF). The study found that an optimal NH3 pressure of 100 Pa leads to a dense, saturated γN layer, significantly improving hardness and corrosion resistance, while both lower and higher pressures result in detrimental microstructures and increased corrosion.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
Austenitic stainless steels (ASSs) are widely used for their corrosion resistance, but their performance in hydrofluoric acid (HF) is less understood and can be problematic. HF is a highly corrosive acid used in various industries, and while non-metallic materials like PTFE are common, metals are sometimes irreplaceable. Conventional nitriding can sometimes degrade the corrosion resistance of ASSs by forming brittle chromium nitride (CrN) layers. This research aims to improve the surface hardness and corrosion resistance of AISI 904L stainless steel, a high-performance ASS, specifically for HF environments, by optimizing the low-temperature plasma nitriding (LTN) process. The key challenge is to achieve a nitrided layer that enhances properties without compromising corrosion resistance in this aggressive medium.
Methods
The researchers employed several characterization techniques to understand the nitriding process and its impact on corrosion resistance:
- Low-Temperature Plasma Nitriding (LTN): AISI 904L specimens were nitrided at 400 °C for 6 hours using a glow plasma setup. The crucial variable manipulated was the ammonia (NH3) pressure, tested at 75, 100, 125, and 150 Pa.
- Microstructural and Phase Analysis:
- Optical Microscopy (OM) and Scanning Electron Microscopy (SEM): Used to observe the surface morphology and microstructure of the nitrided layers.
- X-ray Diffraction (XRD): Employed to identify the crystalline phases present in the nitrided layers, particularly the formation of γN (expanded austenite) and other nitrides like Fe3N and CrN.
- Mechanical Property Measurement:
- Vickers Microhardness Testing: Quantified the hardness of the nitrided layers to assess the impact of nitriding on surface strength.
- Corrosion Performance Evaluation:
- Electrochemical Polarization Tests: Anodic potentiodynamic polarization curves were measured in a 1 mol/L HF solution to evaluate corrosion resistance by determining corrosion current densities and passivation behavior.
- Immersed Corrosion Test: Specimens were immersed in 1 mol/L HF solution for 72 hours, followed by SEM analysis of the corroded surfaces to observe the corrosion morphology.
- Scanning Kelvin Probe (SKP): Used to measure the electron work function and potential maps of the surfaces, providing insights into surface inertness and electrical properties.
- Cross-Sectional Analysis: SEM was used to examine the cross-section of corroded samples to understand the depth and nature of corrosion penetration and the compactness of the nitrided layer.
Datasets
Not discussed in the paper. The study relies on experimental data generated from the treated specimens.
Key Insights and Ideas
- NH3 Pressure is Critical: The study strongly emphasizes that the NH3 pressure during LTN is the dominant factor controlling the microstructure, hardness, and corrosion resistance of the nitrided layer.
- The "Sweet Spot" at 100 Pa: An optimal NH3 pressure of 100 Pa was identified, leading to the formation of a dense, highly saturated γN (expanded austenite) layer. This layer provided the best combination of high microhardness and excellent corrosion resistance in HF.
- Detrimental Effects of Extremes:
- Low Pressure (<100 Pa): Insufficient NH3 pressure resulted in a discontinuous nitriding layer with caking, leaving the underlying austenite vulnerable to preferential dissolution and localized corrosion.
- High Pressure (>100 Pa): Excessive NH3 pressure led to the formation of harmful nitrides (like CrN) and a porous structure. This was attributed to localized overheating caused by increased sputtering current density, which promoted the formation of brittle phases and compromised the protective nature of the layer.
- γN as the Protective Phase: The formation of the N-supersaturated expanded austenite (γN) phase is key to improved hardness and corrosion resistance. Its lattice expansion due to interstitial nitrogen is crucial.
- CrN Formation is Harmful: The presence of CrN, particularly at higher NH3 pressures, is detrimental. It suggests a depletion of Cr in the austenite matrix, hindering passive film formation and leading to increased corrosion.
Key Results
- Microhardness: The microhardness of the nitrided specimens significantly improved compared to the untreated 904L ASS. The highest microhardness (1409.09 HV) was achieved at 100 Pa, a substantial increase from the untreated value (around 300 HV).
- Corrosion Resistance (Electrochemical): Polarization curves showed that the 100 Pa nitrided specimen exhibited the lowest current density, indicating superior resistance to active dissolution in HF. Specimens treated at pressures above 100 Pa showed a large current peak before passivation, suggesting compromised corrosion resistance.
- Corrosion Morphology: SEM analysis revealed that the 100 Pa treated specimen had a highly compact nitriding layer with minimal defects after immersion. In contrast, the 75 Pa specimen showed pitting, and specimens treated at 125 and 150 Pa exhibited a grainy or porous structure with evidence of localized corrosion.
- SKP Results: The SKP potential of nitrided specimens was more positive than the untreated one, indicating increased inertness. The 100 Pa specimen showed the most positive potential, correlating with its superior microhardness and corrosion resistance.
Limitations and Future Work
- Mechanism of CrN Formation: While the study observed the formation of harmful nitrides (CrN) at higher NH3 pressures and attributed it to localized overheating, the precise mechanisms driving this specific nitride formation under these conditions require further investigation.
- HF Concentration and Temperature: The study focused on a specific HF concentration (1 mol/L) and temperature (30 °C). Further research could explore the performance across a wider range of HF concentrations and temperatures, which are relevant to various industrial applications.
- Long-Term Corrosion: The immersion test was conducted for 72 hours. Longer-term immersion tests would provide a more comprehensive understanding of the long-term durability of the nitrided layers.
- Tribocorrosion: The paper mentions that stainless steels are used in environments with particle wear. While hardness is improved, a detailed study on the tribocorrosion behavior of these nitrided layers in HF environments would be valuable.
Summary updated