Anticipatory solastalgia in the Antipodes: Evidence of future-oriented distress about environmental change in Australia and New Zealand

Samantha K. Stanley, Omid Ghasemi, Robert M. Ross, John R. Kerr, Mathew D. Marques, Niels G. Mede, Sebastian Berger, Mark Alfano, Neil Levy, Marinus Ferreira, Viktoria ColognaThe Journal of Climate Change and Health 2025 · DOI

TL;DR

This study validates a new scale, the Anticipatory Solastalgia Scale (ANSOS), to measure distress about future environmental changes in Australia and New Zealand. The findings show that this anticipatory distress is linked to negative climate emotions, expectations of worsening extreme weather, and support for climate policies, offering a valuable tool for understanding climate-related psychological impacts.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

While the concept of "solastalgia" – distress caused by environmental change – has been recognized, it traditionally focused on the lived experience of ongoing environmental degradation. However, awareness of accelerating climate change can evoke distress even before direct, severe impacts are felt. This "anticipatory solastalgia" represents a present-day emotional response to expected future environmental losses. The problem this paper addresses is the need for a reliable and validated measure to quantify this anticipatory distress, particularly in regions like Australia and New Zealand, which are already experiencing and anticipating significant climate-related impacts. Understanding this phenomenon is crucial for comprehending the broader psychological toll of climate change beyond immediate anxiety.

Methods

The researchers employed a quantitative, survey-based approach to validate the five-item Anticipatory Solastalgia Scale (ANSOS). They conducted confirmatory factor analyses (CFA) to assess the scale's fit to the data in two large samples from Australia (n=1450) and New Zealand (n=1022). Key statistical techniques included:

  • Confirmatory Factor Analysis (CFA): Used to test the hypothesized one-factor structure of the ANSOS and evaluate model fit using standard indices (CFI, TLI, RMSEA, SRMR).
  • Measurement Invariance Testing: Conducted to ensure the ANSOS functions similarly across the Australian and New Zealand samples, allowing for cross-cultural comparisons.
  • Correlation Analyses: Pearson's correlations (and Kendall's tau-b for policy support) were used to examine the associations between ANSOS scores and demographic variables (age, gender, region), political orientation, expectations of future extreme weather events, climate emotions, and support for climate policies.
  • Welch's t-tests: Used to compare mean scores between groups (e.g., men vs. women, urban vs. rural).

The study also preregistered its research questions and hypotheses, promoting transparency and rigor.

Datasets

The study utilized data from two large, general population samples:

  • Australia: 1450 participants.
  • New Zealand: 1022 participants.

These participants were part of the "Trust in Science and Science-Related Populism Many Labs" project. The data collected included responses to the ANSOS, measures of expected climate change impacts, climate emotions, policy support, and demographic/political orientation information. No new datasets were introduced; rather, existing data was used to validate the ANSOS.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The ANSOS is a robust measure: The scale demonstrates good psychometric properties, fitting the data well and showing internal consistency in both Australia and New Zealand. This provides a reliable tool for researchers and practitioners.
  • Anticipatory distress is widespread: Mean scores on the ANSOS were above the midpoint of the scale in both countries, indicating a tendency for participants to experience this future-oriented distress.
  • Younger individuals are more affected: Younger participants reported higher levels of anticipatory solastalgia, suggesting that the perceived future threat of climate change disproportionately impacts younger generations.
  • Climate anxiety is more than just anxiety: Anticipatory solastalgia captures a broader spectrum of negative emotions related to expected environmental decline, going beyond simple anxiety.
  • Expectations drive distress: The strongest correlate of anticipatory solastalgia was the expectation of increased severity of future extreme weather events, highlighting the power of future projections in shaping emotional responses.
  • Distress can fuel action: A significant finding is the positive association between anticipatory solastalgia and support for climate policies, suggesting that this distress can be a motivator for seeking solutions.

Key Results

  • The ANSOS showed good model fit in both Australia and New Zealand, with strong factor loadings for all items.
  • Cronbach's alpha for the ANSOS was high in both samples (.91 for Australia, .89 for New Zealand), indicating good internal consistency.
  • Measurement invariance tests confirmed the scale's suitability for cross-country comparisons.
  • Anticipatory solastalgia was negatively correlated with age in Australia (r = -0.17, p < .001) and showed no significant association in New Zealand (r = -0.03, p = .404).
  • Women in New Zealand reported significantly higher anticipatory solastalgia than men (p = .007), but no such difference was found in Australia.
  • A strong positive correlation was found between anticipatory solastalgia and the expectation of increased extreme weather events in both countries (Australia: r = 0.68, p < .001; New Zealand: r = 0.57, p < .001).
  • Anticipatory solastalgia was positively associated with various negative climate emotions (e.g., helpless, angry, depressed) in both countries, with correlations ranging from 0.37 to 0.54.
  • The scale showed a positive association with support for climate policies, such as raising fuel taxes and increasing sustainable energy use, in both countries.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations:

  • Cross-sectional data: The study relies on correlational data, preventing causal inferences about the relationships observed.
  • Survey limitations: The reliance on self-report measures and the omission of constructs like direct exposure to environmental shocks are noted.
  • Limited covariates: The survey included a limited set of covariates, potentially missing other important influencing factors.
  • Generalizability: The study was conducted in four relatively wealthy, English-speaking nations, limiting immediate cross-cultural generalizability.

Future research directions suggested include:

  • Longitudinal studies: To establish temporal relationships and causality.
  • Test-retest reliability: To assess the stability of ANSOS scores over time.
  • Nomological network expansion: Investigating the ANSOS's relationship with a wider range of psychological and behavioral constructs.
  • Intervention research: Testing interventions that might mitigate anticipatory solastalgia or leverage it to encourage climate action.
  • Cross-cultural research: Expanding studies to diverse cultural contexts, including Indigenous populations, to understand global variations in anticipatory solastalgia.
  • Exploring framing effects: Investigating how framing climate change impacts differently influences anticipatory solastalgia across political spectrums.

Summary updated

Abstract

The study adds further evidence for the validity of the anticipatory solastalgia scale; a measure that is designed to facilitate understanding of people's distress responses to the expectations of, and emotional engagement with, environmental threats as the climate changes.
BibTeX
@article{stanley2025anticipatory,
  author = {Samantha K. Stanley and Omid Ghasemi and Robert M. Ross and John R. Kerr and Mathew D. Marques and Niels G. Mede and Sebastian Berger and Mark Alfano and Neil Levy and Marinus Ferreira and Viktoria Cologna},
  title = {{Anticipatory solastalgia in the Antipodes: Evidence of future-oriented distress about environmental change in Australia and New Zealand}},
  journal = {The Journal of Climate Change and Health},
  year = {2025},
  doi = {10.1016/j.joclim.2025.100415},
}
Figure