Antibacterial Activity Prediction Model of Traditional Chinese Medicine Based on Combined Data-Driven Approach and Machine Learning Algorithm: Constructed and Validated

Jin-Tong Li, Ya-Wen Wei, Mengyu Wang, Chun-Xiao Yan, Xia Ren, Xianjun FuFrontiers in Microbiology 2021 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper tackles the challenge of efficiently screening Traditional Chinese Medicines (TCMs) for antibacterial activity by developing a machine learning model. By integrating data mining techniques with machine learning algorithms, they created predictive models for E. coli and S. aureus that achieved promising accuracy, paving the way for faster discovery of novel antibacterial agents.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The rise of antibiotic-resistant bacteria ("superbugs") poses a significant global health threat, outpacing the development of new antibacterial drugs. Traditional methods for identifying effective antibacterial agents from natural sources like Traditional Chinese Medicines (TCMs) are often time-consuming, costly, and involve blind screening. TCMs, with their complex multi-component and multi-target nature, offer a rich source of potential new drugs, but efficiently navigating this vast resource is a major hurdle. This paper aims to bridge this gap by creating a predictive model that can rapidly screen TCMs for antibacterial potential, thereby accelerating the discovery of novel therapeutic compounds.

Methods

The study employed a multi-faceted approach combining data mining and machine learning.

  1. Data Collection and Preprocessing: A comprehensive literature search was conducted on the China National Knowledge Infrastructure (CNKI) and Web of Science databases to gather data on antibacterial TCMs. This data, comprising information on TCM properties (nature, taste, meridian tropism, efficacy) and families, was standardized and compiled into a large dataset.
  2. Data Mining:
    • Frequency Analysis: Used to understand the distribution of antibacterial TCMs across different sources (plant, animal, fungi) and their properties.
  3. Association Rule Mining: Applied to identify correlations between TCM properties (nature, taste, efficacy, family) and their antibacterial activity against Gram-positive and Gram-negative bacteria.
  4. Phylogenetic Tree Construction: Used to visualize the evolutionary relationships of TCM species and identify aggregations of antibacterial TCMs.
  5. Machine Learning Model Development:
    • Feature Selection: Recursive Feature Elimination (RFE) was used to identify the most relevant features (TCM properties and families) for predicting antibacterial activity, reducing dimensionality and improving model performance.
  6. Algorithm Selection: Six machine learning algorithms (Random Forest, KNN, CART, SVM, NB, NN) were evaluated for their performance in predicting antibacterial activity against E. coli and S. aureus.
  7. Model Optimization: The parameters of the best-performing algorithms were further optimized to enhance predictive accuracy.
  8. Model Validation: The developed models were validated using in vitro antibacterial experiments.

Datasets

The study utilized a dataset derived from a comprehensive literature review of antibacterial TCMs.

  • Source Databases: China National Knowledge Infrastructure (CNKI) and Web of Science.
  • Data Scope: 28,786 pieces of data from 904 antibacterial TCMs were collected.
  • Data Features: Included TCM properties (four natures, five tastes, meridian tropism, efficacies, indications), families, and antibacterial effectiveness against specific bacterial strains.
  • Bacterial Strains: Escherichia coli (E. coli) and Staphylococcus aureus (S. aureus) were selected as representative Gram-negative and Gram-positive bacteria, respectively, for model construction and validation.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • TCMs are not randomly distributed: The study revealed that antibacterial TCMs exhibit specific aggregations within phylogenetic trees, particularly within the rosids, asterids, Liliopsida, and Ranunculales branches. This suggests evolutionary or ecological factors influencing their medicinal properties.
  • Properties matter: A strong correlation was found between certain TCM properties (cold nature, bitter and sour tastes, hemostatic, and purging fire efficacies) and antibacterial activity. This provides valuable clues for targeted screening.
  • Machine learning can predict efficacy: The development of predictive models using machine learning algorithms demonstrates that patterns in TCM properties and families can indeed predict antibacterial activity, offering a significant advantage over traditional empirical methods.
  • Novel antibacterial TCMs identified: The study successfully proposed four TCMs (Cirsii Japonici Herba Carbonisata, Changii Radix, Swertiae Herba, and Callicarpae Formosanae Folium) as potentially exhibiting antibacterial activity against E. coli and/or S. aureus, some for the first time.

Key Results

  • Data Volume: A substantial dataset of 28,786 data points from 904 antibacterial TCMs was compiled.
  • Phylogenetic Distribution: 92% of antibacterial TCMs originated from Tracheophyta, with 74% concentrated in rosids, asterids, Liliopsida, and Ranunculales.
  • Model Performance (AUC):
    • Anti-E. coli prediction model: AUC of 77.5% (NN algorithm after Bagged CART and LDA selection).
  • Anti-S. aureus prediction model: AUC of 80.0% (NN algorithm after LDA selection).
  • Experimental Validation Accuracy:
    • Anti-E. coli model: 75% prediction accuracy.
  • Anti-S. aureus model: 60% prediction accuracy.
  • Identified Active TCMs: Four TCMs were identified as potentially active against E. coli and/or S. aureus.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Prediction Accuracy Gap: While the models showed predictive ability, the accuracy in experimental validation (75% for E. coli, 60% for S. aureus) indicates room for improvement. The authors acknowledge that current characteristic information might not be comprehensive enough.
  • Future Directions: The authors suggest incorporating additional characteristics such as chemical composition and specific molecular targets into future models to enhance prediction accuracy. Further research into optimizing extraction processes for TCMs is also recommended to better reveal their drug potential.

Summary updated

Abstract

Traditional Chinese medicines (TCMs), as a unique natural medicine resource, were used to prevent and treat bacterial diseases in China with a long history. To provide a prediction model of screening antibacterial TCMs for the design and discovery of novel antibacterial agents, the literature about antibacterial TCMs in the China National Knowledge Infrastructure (CNKI) and Web of Science database was retrieved. The data were extracted and standardized. A total of 28,786 pieces of data from 904 antibacterial TCMs were collected. The data of plant medicine were the most numerous. The result of association rules mining showed a high correlation between antibacterial activity with cold nature, bitter and sour tastes, hemostatic, and purging fire efficacies. Moreover, TCMs with antibacterial activity showed a specific aggregation in the phylogenetic tree; 92% of them came from Tracheophyta, of which 74% were mainly concentrated in rosids, asterids, Liliopsida, and Ranunculales. The prediction models of anti-<i>Escherichia coli</i> and anti-<i>Staphylococcus aureus</i> activity, with AUC values (the area under the ROC curve) of 77.5 and 80.0%, respectively, were constructed by the Neural Networks (NN) algorithm after Bagged Classification and Regression Tree (Bagged CART) and Linear Discriminant Analysis (LDA) selection. The <i>in vitro</i> experimental results showed the prediction accuracy of these two models was 75 and 60%, respectively. Four TCMs (Cirsii Japonici Herba Carbonisata, Changii Radix, Swertiae Herba, Callicarpae Formosanae Folium) were proposed for the first time to show antibacterial activity against <i>E. coli</i> and/or <i>S. aureus</i>. The results implied that the prediction model of antibacterial activity of TCMs based on properties and families showed certain prediction ability, which was of great significance to the screening of antibacterial TCMs and can be used to discover novel antibacterial agents.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{li2021antibacterial,
  author = {Jin-Tong Li and Ya-Wen Wei and Mengyu Wang and Chun-Xiao Yan and Xia Ren and Xianjun Fu},
  title = {{Antibacterial Activity Prediction Model of Traditional Chinese Medicine Based on Combined Data-Driven Approach and Machine Learning Algorithm: Constructed and Validated}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Microbiology},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.3389/fmicb.2021.763498},
}
Figure