Anterior cervical discectomy and fusion without plate (ACDFWP) versus anterior cervical disc arthroplasty (ACDA) for cervical spondylosis: A meta-analysis and literature review

Jiajie Peng, Sihan Li, Xiangying Lin, Degui Zhong, Rong Zheng, Minghan Huang, Pengfei Li, Hongmei Song, Tetsuya AsakawaIntractable 2022 · DOI

Abstract

This meta-analysis compared the clinical outcomes between two alternative surgeries for patients with cervical spondylosis: anterior cervical discectomy and fusion (ACDF) without plate (ACDFWP) vs. anterior cervical disc arthroplasty (ACDA). We searched databases including PubMed, EMBASE, Cochrane Library, Google Scholar, and Web of Science. A standard meta-analysis was performed with eight included studies involving 640 patients. No significant difference was found in Neck Disability Index (NDI) scores, Visual Analog Scores (VAS), Japanese Orthopaedic Association (JOA) scores, operative time, blood loss, Swallowing Quality of Life Score (SWAL-QL), and complications. However, cervical alignment was significantly better in the ACDFWP group than in the ACDA group (MD = -0.67, P = 0.003). While ACDFWP showed a slight advantage in cervical alignment, current evidence remains limited, and further well-designed studies are warranted.

Introduction

Cervical spondylosis, characterized by the age-related degeneration of spinal discs in the neck, represents a significant public health challenge. The traditional "gold standard" treatment is Anterior Cervical Discectomy and Fusion (ACDF) utilizing an anterior metal plate for stabilization. Despite its success, the use of a plate is associated with specific complications, such as dysphagia (difficulty swallowing) and adjacent segment disease (ASD), where fusion accelerates wear on neighboring discs.

To address these drawbacks, two "plate-free" alternatives have gained prominence:

  1. ACDFWP: Fusing the vertebrae using a cage while omitting the bulky anterior plate.
  2. ACDA: Replacing the damaged disc with an artificial one to preserve natural motion.

While both have been compared to traditional ACDF, there is a lack of high-quality evidence directly comparing these two alternative techniques against each other. This meta-analysis aims to provide a direct comparison to guide clinical decision-making.

Schematic representation of cervical spine interventions: (A) Normal anatomy, (B) Traditional ACDF with plate, (C) ACDFWP (fusion without plate), and (D) ACDA (disc arthroplasty).

Methods and Study Selection

The authors conducted a systematic review following PRISMA guidelines. The search spanned major medical databases for studies comparing ACDFWP and ACDA published through 2021. Quality assessment was performed using the ROBINS-I tool for non-randomized controlled trials (nRCTs) and the Cochrane Risk of Bias (RoB) tool for randomized controlled trials (RCTs).

PRISMA flow diagram illustrating the systematic literature search and study selection process, resulting in 8 final records for analysis.

Data from 8 studies (3 RCTs and 5 nRCTs) involving 640 patients were synthesized using RevMan 5.3. Metrics evaluated included functional scores (NDI, JOA), pain (VAS), cervical alignment (Cobb angle), and surgical efficiency (operative time, blood loss).

Key Results and Insights

Clinical Equivalence in Function and Pain

For the majority of patient-reported outcomes, the study found no statistically significant difference between ACDFWP and ACDA. This includes:

  • Functional Scores: No significant difference in NDI (MD = 0.15, P = 0.40) or JOA scores (MD = 0.05, P = 0.80).
  • Pain (VAS): No significant difference (MD = -0.40, P = 0.07).
  • Swallowing Quality: SWAL-QL scores were comparable between groups (MD = 0.80, P = 0.09).

The Alignment Advantage

The most significant finding was that ACDFWP was superior to ACDA in maintaining cervical alignment (MD = -0.67, 95% CI [-1.11, -0.23], P = 0.003). Proper alignment is a critical factor for long-term spinal health and the prevention of chronic postoperative pain.

Complications and Surgical Efficiency

Despite the theoretical advantage of motion preservation in ACDA, the study found no significant difference in complication rates or the incidence of adjacent segment disease (ASD) within the follow-up periods. Furthermore, operative time and blood loss were similar, suggesting that neither procedure is inherently more resource-intensive.

Discussion and Limitations

While ACDFWP appears slightly superior regarding cervical alignment, several limitations must be considered:

  • Sample Size: The analysis is based on only eight studies, with a relatively small total patient population (n=640).
  • Study Quality: The inclusion of non-randomized trials introduces a higher risk of bias, particularly regarding confounding factors.
  • Follow-Up Duration: ASD often takes years to develop; many included studies lacked the long-term data (5+ years) required to definitively assess secondary surgery rates.

Conclusion

Both ACDFWP and ACDA are effective plate-free alternatives for treating cervical spondylosis, offering similar outcomes in pain relief and functional recovery. ACDFWP may offer a slight advantage in maintaining cervical alignment. However, larger, multi-center randomized controlled trials with extended follow-up are necessary to confirm these findings and evaluate long-term durability.

Summary updated

Abstract

This meta-analysis compared the clinical outcomes between two alternative surgeries for patients with cervical spondylosis, namely anterior cervical discectomy and fusion (ACDF) without plate (ACDFWP) vs. anterior cervical disc arthroplasty (ACDA). We searched databases, including PubMed, EMBASE, Cochrane Library, Google Scholar, and Web of Science (firstly available-2019). A standard meta-analysis was performed with the included studies. A Risk of Bias in Non-randomized Studies of Interventions (ROBINS-I) tool was used for the evaluation of the study quality of nonrandomized-controlled trials (nRCTs), while a Risk of Bias (RoB) battery was used for randomized controlled trials (RCTs). Eight studies involving 640 patients were included. No significant difference was found in the indices of Neck Disability Index (NDI) score, Visual Analog Score (VAS), Japanese Orthopaedic Association (JOA) score, operative time, blood loss, Swallowing Quality of Life Score (SWAL-QL), and complications. Cervical alignment was significantly better in the ACDFWP than in ACDA (mean difference (MD) = -0.67, 95% confidence interval (CI) [-1.11, -0.23], <i>P</i> = 0.003, <i>I</i> <sup>2</sup> = 20%). Although the alternative ACDFWP was slightly superior in terms of the index of cervical alignment, the limited research on this subject present insufficient evidence. Further well-designed studies are warranted in the future.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{peng2022anterior,
  author = {Jiajie Peng and Sihan Li and Xiangying Lin and Degui Zhong and Rong Zheng and Minghan Huang and Pengfei Li and Hongmei Song and Tetsuya Asakawa},
  title = {{Anterior cervical discectomy and fusion without plate (ACDFWP) versus anterior cervical disc arthroplasty (ACDA) for cervical spondylosis: A meta-analysis and literature review}},
  booktitle = {Intractable},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.5582/irdr.2022.01080},
}
Figure