Anomalous transverse distribution of pions as a signal for the production of disoriented chiral condensates

Fred Cooper, Yuval Kluger, Emil MottolaPhysical 1996 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract We provide evidence that the production of disoriented chiral condensates (DCCs) during a nonequilibrium phase transition can lead to an anomalous transverse distribution of secondary pions when compared to a more conventional boost-invariant hydrodynamic flow in local thermal equilibrium. Our results pertain to the linear $\sigma$ model, treated in leading order in large $N$, in a boost-invariant approximation. We also show that the interpolating number density of the field theory calculation plays the role of a classical relativistic phase space number distribution in determining the momentum distribution of pions in the center-of-mass frame.

Introduction

In high-energy particle collisions, such as those observed in cosmic rays or generated in heavy-ion accelerators, physicists seek to understand the phase transitions of nuclear matter. A particularly intriguing theoretical phenomenon is the formation of a Disoriented Chiral Condensate (DCC). A DCC represents a region of space where the vacuum "points" in a non-standard direction, breaking chiral symmetry in a way that leads to the coherent production of pions.

Detecting these states is notoriously difficult. Standard models of particle production typically assume that the "fireball" created in a collision expands in local thermal equilibrium, behaving like a cooling gas. This thermal expansion produces a predictable distribution of particles. However, if the system undergoes a rapid "quench"—a non-equilibrium phase transition—it may trigger instabilities that favor DCC formation. This paper explores the specific experimental signatures that would distinguish such a non-equilibrium event from standard thermal backgrounds.

Theoretical Framework and Methodology

The researchers utilized the linear $\sigma$ model, a foundational mathematical framework for describing pion physics. To solve the complex quantum field equations, they employed several key approximations and techniques:

  • Large-$N$ Approximation: By treating the number of particle species ($N$) as large, the researchers could solve the field equations exactly at the leading order, making the quantum dynamics tractable.
  • Boost-Invariant Kinematics: The study assumes the system expands in a "boost-invariant" manner (Bjorken flow). This means the expansion looks identical regardless of the observer's velocity along the beam axis, a standard simplification in high-energy physics.
  • Adiabatic Number Density: A critical contribution of this work is the mapping of abstract quantum field fluctuations to an "interpolating number density." The authors demonstrated that this quantum operator functions identically to a classical relativistic phase space distribution, allowing for the calculation of actual particle counts as the system relaxes.
  • Cooper-Frye Formula: To bridge the gap between theoretical field theory and experimental observation, the authors used the Cooper-Frye formula to translate their results into a transverse momentum ($k_\perp$) distribution.

The Mechanism: Negative Mass Instability

The core physical insight of the paper lies in the "negative mass instability." During a rapid expansion or quench, the "effective mass" of the pions can briefly become negative. In the language of potential energy, this acts like an inverted bowl; rather than settling into a stable state, the field "falls" outward, leading to the exponential growth of low-momentum modes. This growth is the engine that generates the DCC.

Key Results and Experimental Signatures

The study identifies a "smoking gun" signal for DCC production: an anomalous low-$k_\perp$ bump.

  1. The Low-Momentum Spike: When comparing the DCC model to standard hydrodynamic models, the DCC produces a massive, sharp peak at very low transverse momentum (typically below 1.0 $fm^{-1}$). In contrast, thermal models produce a much flatter, smoother distribution. This distortion is a structural change in the spectrum that cannot be explained by simply increasing the system's energy.
  2. Sensitivity to Initial Conditions: The formation of a DCC is highly sensitive to the initial state of the plasma. The researchers found that only a narrow range of initial fluctuations—specifically the rate of change of the sigma field ($\dot{\sigma}$)—will trigger the required instability. If the initial "kick" to the system is too weak or too strong, the DCC signal disappears, and the distribution reverts to a more standard form.
  3. Normalization: By normalizing different models to the same total center-of-mass energy, the authors confirmed that the low-momentum enhancement is a unique signature of the DCC's non-equilibrium dynamics, rather than a byproduct of total particle yield.

Conclusion and Implications

This work provides a concrete theoretical target for experimentalists. If anomalous events, such as the "Centauro" events observed in cosmic rays, do not exhibit this specific low-momentum pion enhancement, they are unlikely to be the result of disoriented chiral condensates. While the Large-$N$ and boost-invariant approximations simplify the 3D reality of particle collisions, they provide a robust baseline for identifying non-equilibrium phase transitions in the laboratory. Future experiments at facilities like the Relativistic Heavy Ion Collider (RHIC) can use these transverse momentum distributions to search for the elusive signatures of the DCC.

Summary updated

Abstract

We give evidence that the production of disoriented chiral condensates during a nonequilibrium phase transition can lead to an anomalous transverse distribution of secondary pions when compared to a more conventional boost invariant hydrodynamic flow in local thermal equilibrium. Our results pertain to the linear \ensuremath{\sigma} model, treated in leading order in large N, in a boost invariant approximation. We also show that the interpolating number density of the field theory calculation plays the role of a classical relativistic phase space number distribution in determining the momentum distribution of pions in the center of mass frame. \textcopyright{} 1996 The American Physical Society.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{cooper1996anomalous,
  author = {Fred Cooper and Yuval Kluger and Emil Mottola},
  title = {{Anomalous transverse distribution of pions as a signal for the production of disoriented chiral condensates}},
  booktitle = {Physical},
  year = {1996},
  doi = {10.1103/physrevc.54.3298},
}
Figure