Abstract
The Anomalous Hall Effect (AHE)—a transverse voltage generated without an external magnetic field—is a cornerstone of condensed matter physics. While traditionally restricted to ferromagnetic metals, the recent discovery of a large AHE in the chiral antiferromagnet $Mn_3Sn$ has challenged existing paradigms. This study investigates the mechanism behind this phenomenon by measuring its thermal analog, the Anomalous Thermal Hall Effect (ATHE). The results demonstrate that the ATHE scales with the anomalous Hall conductivity over a wide temperature range, proving that the effect in $Mn_3Sn$ is a dissipationless, intrinsic phenomenon driven by Berry curvature. Furthermore, the stabilization of this effect through Fermi level tuning suggests that magnetic Weyl fermions are the primary source of the material's topological transport properties.
Introduction
For decades, the Anomalous Hall Effect was thought to be proportional to a material's net magnetization, making it a signature of ferromagnetism. However, the chiral antiferromagnet $Mn_3Sn$ exhibits a massive AHE despite having a near-zero net magnetization. This discovery raised a fundamental question: is the effect "extrinsic," caused by electrons scattering off impurities, or "intrinsic," arising from the material's internal topology and Berry curvature?
Distinguishing between these mechanisms is notoriously difficult using electrical measurements alone. In this work, researchers utilize thermal transport measurements to probe the topological nature of $Mn_3Sn$, providing a clearer picture of how Berry curvature acts as a "fictitious" magnetic field within the crystal lattice.
Methodology
The researchers employed a "thermal analog" approach, measuring both the electrical AHE and the Anomalous Thermal Hall Effect (ATHE). The key diagnostic tool in this study is the Anomalous Lorenz number ($L_{ij}^{AH}$), defined as the ratio of thermal Hall conductivity to electrical Hall conductivity.
According to the Wiedemann-Franz law, if a transport mechanism is intrinsic and dissipationless, the Lorenz ratio should remain close to a universal constant ($L_0$). To test this, the team used high-quality single crystals of $Mn_{3+x}Sn_{1-x}$. By varying the Manganese (Mn) concentration, they were able to shift the Fermi level ($E_F$) toward predicted "magnetic Weyl points"—singularities in the electronic band structure where Berry curvature is maximized.
Key Insights: The Role of Berry Curvature
Topology Over Magnetization
The study confirms that $Mn_3Sn$ behaves as a "cluster octupole." In this state, the specific symmetry of the magnetic moments allows for the existence of large Berry curvature even in the absence of significant magnetization. This curvature exerts a transverse force on both charge and heat carriers, leading to the observed Hall signals.
Validation of the Wiedemann-Franz Law
For the doped samples, the Anomalous Lorenz number remained remarkably constant ($L_{ij}^{AH} \approx L_0$) at temperatures up to 150 K. This adherence to the Wiedemann-Franz law is a "smoking gun" for an intrinsic mechanism. It proves that the Hall signal is not a byproduct of electron scattering (which would cause the ratio to deviate) but is instead a fundamental topological property of the electronic bands.
The Two-Channel Scattering Model
To explain the coexistence of standard metallic behavior and topological transport, the authors propose a "magnetic Weyl metal" model involving two distinct types of carriers:
- Weyl bands: These host high-mobility electrons with very low scattering rates ($\hbar/\tau^{Weyl} \approx 14.4–21.4$ meV). These bands are responsible for the topological Hall signal.
- Metallic bands: These are standard carriers that dominate longitudinal conduction but do not contribute significantly to the AHE.
Interestingly, the study found that adding Mn impurities actually stabilized the dissipationless state by shifting the Fermi level closer to the Weyl points, counterintuitively making the topological signal more robust against scattering.
Results and Implications
The experimental data shows that the ATHE amplitude scales perfectly with the AHE conductivity across a broad temperature range. This scaling, combined with the proximity of the Fermi level to the Weyl points, confirms that the Berry curvature emerging from the magnetic Weyl fermion state is the engine behind the anomalous transport in $Mn_3Sn$.
These findings have significant implications for the field of topological spintronics and "caloritronics." Understanding how to manipulate dissipationless heat and charge currents in antiferromagnets opens the door to new classes of efficient thermoelectric devices and non-volatile memory components that are insensitive to external magnetic fields.
Limitations and Future Directions
While the two-channel model effectively explains the experimental data, the precise mechanism that suppresses scattering between the Weyl bands and the bulk metallic bands remains a subject for further theoretical investigation. Additionally, future work will likely focus on the Anomalous Nernst Effect to further explore the potential of $Mn_3Sn$ for high-efficiency thermoelectric generation.
Summary updated