Abstract
With the development of laser technology, pulse length enters the optical cycle regime and hence the interaction time between laser pulse and atoms becomes prominent. We investigate this problem in this Letter through the photoelectron spectrum of hydrogen atom in few-cycle xuv laser pulses. By solving one-dimensional time-dependent Schrödinger equation, we find that due to the insufficient interaction time, the electron can not gain enough energy from optical field when escaping the bind of the nuclear and then the abnormality appears in the photoelectron spectrum: the peak of photoelectron spectrum shows red shift compared with the well-known Einstein photo-electric effect formula. The shift becomes large as the pulse duration decreases.
Introduction
For over a century, Einstein’s photoelectric formula ($E = \hbar\omega - I_p$) has been a cornerstone of physics, predicting that an electron ejected from an atom will have a kinetic energy equal to the photon energy minus the atom's ionization potential. This formula assumes a "steady-state" interaction where the light field is present for a relatively long time.
However, modern laser technology has reached the "few-cycle" regime, producing pulses so short (attoseconds) that they consist of only a few oscillations of the electric field. This research investigates whether the finite interaction time in these ultra-short XUV (extreme ultraviolet) pulses causes the photoelectric effect to deviate from Einstein's prediction, specifically examining the "response time" of the atom—a factor often ignored in traditional quantum optics.
Methodology
The researchers employed a theoretical and computational approach by solving the one-dimensional Time-Dependent Schrödinger Equation (TDSE) to simulate the interaction between a hydrogen atom and a laser pulse. The interaction was modeled using the dipole approximation in atomic units, utilizing a screened soft-core potential to avoid numerical instabilities at the nucleus. The TDSE was integrated using the standard split-operator method. Simulations focused on XUV pulses with wavelengths ranging from 10 nm to 40 nm and intensities around $1.0 \times 10^{15} \text{ W/cm}^2$, with pulse lengths ($n$) varying from 4 to 20 optical cycles.
Key Insights: The "Insufficient Time" Hypothesis
The core finding is that an atom requires a finite amount of time to absorb a photon. According to Fourier analysis, a perfectly monochromatic photon (single frequency $\omega$) requires infinite time. When a pulse is extremely short, the interaction ends before the electron can gain the full energy equivalent of one photon. Because the electron gains less energy than $\hbar\omega$ before escaping the nucleus, the peak of the photoelectron spectrum (PS) shifts toward lower energies—a "red shift"—compared to Einstein's formula.
Results and Universality
As shown in the spectral analysis, the shorter the pulse, the larger the red shift. For a 1D hydrogen atom at a wavelength of 20 nm, the red shift is clearly visible. As the pulse length $n$ decreases, the intensity of the spectrum drops, the width of the peak broadens (consistent with the uncertainty principle), and the peak energy $E_p$ moves significantly below the expected value.
This phenomenon appears to be universal across different atomic species. The team observed similar red-shift tendencies in both hydrogen and helium models across multiple wavelengths. In the case of hydrogen at $\lambda = 10 \text{ nm}$ with a very short pulse ($n=4$), the red shift $\Delta$ can exceed 10 eV, representing a substantial deviation from classical expectations.
Interestingly, the researchers found that the Carrier Envelope Phase (CEP) has almost no effect on the photoelectron spectrum in this regime, suggesting the shift is purely a function of the interaction duration rather than the specific phase of the oscillation.
Conclusion
This study demonstrates that in the realm of attosecond physics, Einstein’s classic photoelectric effect formula begins to break down due to finite interaction times. While this 1D model captures the essential physics, future 3D simulations will be necessary to account for angular momentum and more complex electron trajectories. As attosecond pulse technology matures, experimental verification of this red shift will serve as a critical signature of the finite time required for light-matter interaction.
Summary updated