Anomalous Nernst effect induced terahertz emission in a single ferromagnetic film

Feng Zheng, Wei Tan, Zuanming Jin, Yijia Chen, Zhangfeng Zhong, Song Sun, Jin Tang, Yexing Jiang, Po-Hsun Wu, Jun Cheng, B. F. Miao, Haifeng Ding, Dacheng Wang, Yiming Zhu, Guohong Ma, Dazhi Hou, S. Y. Huang, Ma, Guohong, Hou, Dazhi, Huang, Ssu-YenarXiv 2023 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract

By developing a bidirectional-pump terahertz (THz) emission spectroscopy, we reveal an anomalous Nernst effect (ANE) induced THz emission in a single ferromagnetic film. Based on the distinctive symmetry of the THz signals, ANE is unequivocally distinguished from the previously attributed ultrafast demagnetization and anomalous Hall effect mechanisms. A quantitative method is established to separate the different contributions, demonstrating a significant ANE contribution that even overwhelms other competing mechanisms. Our work not only clarifies the origin of the ferromagnetic-based THz emission, but also offers a fertile platform for investigating the ultrafast magnetism and THz spintronics.

Introduction

Terahertz (THz) radiation, occupying the spectral gap between microwave and infrared frequencies, has become a cornerstone for advancements in high-speed communication, non-destructive medical imaging, and security screening. Among the various methods for generating THz waves, spintronic THz emitters—which utilize femtosecond laser pulses to trigger spin currents in magnetic heterostructures—have gained prominence due to their high efficiency and broadband nature.

While it has been established for nearly two decades that a single layer of ferromagnetic (FM) metal can emit THz waves, the underlying physical mechanism has remained a subject of intense debate. Historically, this emission was primarily attributed to ultrafast demagnetization (the rapid loss of magnetic order following laser excitation). More recently, the Anomalous Hall Effect (AHE) was proposed as a potential driver. However, because these mechanisms are often entangled and exhibit similar experimental signatures, standard measurement techniques have struggled to isolate the thermal contribution—the Anomalous Nernst Effect (ANE)—from non-thermal ones. This study addresses this long-standing ambiguity by introducing a novel spectroscopic approach to decouple these phenomena.

Methodology: Bidirectional-Pump Spectroscopy

To isolate the ANE contribution, the researchers developed two primary innovations in experimental design and analysis:

1. Bidirectional-Pump THz Emission Spectroscopy

Standard THz emission setups typically pump the sample from a single direction. In this study, the team constructed a system capable of pumping the sample from both the front (FM side) and the back (substrate side), while also allowing the sample itself to be flipped. This configuration creates four distinct experimental geometries, enabling a rigorous test of the symmetry of the resulting THz signals.

2. Symmetry Analysis and Quantitative Separation

The physical mechanisms responsible for THz emission respond differently to changes in pump direction and sample orientation:

  • Ultrafast Demagnetization: This effect is largely independent of the pump direction.
  • Anomalous Hall Effect (AHE): The signal reverses sign when the sample is flipped relative to the detector.
  • Anomalous Nernst Effect (ANE): Driven by a temperature gradient ($\nabla T$), ANE behaves differently based on film thickness. In "thick" films, $ abla T$ follows the laser's propagation direction. In "thin" films, the gradient is dominated by heat sinking into the substrate, causing $ abla T$ to point toward the interface regardless of the laser's direction.

By analyzing iron (Fe) films ranging from 4 nm to 100 nm on MgO substrates, the team used these symmetry rules to mathematically extract the individual contributions of demagnetization and ANE.

Key Insights

The Thermal "Smoking Gun"

The study reveals that laser excitation creates a massive, transient temperature gradient at the sub-picosecond scale. This gradient, in conjunction with the film's magnetization, drives a charge current via ANE ($J_c \propto M \times \nabla T$), which subsequently radiates THz waves. This thermal mechanism is a primary, rather than secondary, driver of emission.

Thickness-Dependent Symmetry

A critical discovery was the transition in ANE behavior between "thick" and "thin" regimes. In thick films (>90 nm), the THz signal flips sign when the laser pump direction is reversed—a unique fingerprint of ANE that distinguishes it from demagnetization. In thin films, the substrate interface dictates the gradient, masking this reversal but maintaining a strong ANE signature.

The Fe Sign-Flip Evidence

The researchers observed that for Fe films, the ANE coefficient changes sign between a thickness of 4 nm and 5 nm, whereas the AHE coefficient remains constant. Crucially, the THz emission also flipped sign at this exact thickness threshold. This correlation provides definitive evidence that ANE, rather than AHE, is the dominant mechanism in the thin-film regime.

Results and Discussion

The quantitative analysis demonstrates that in thin Fe films—the regime most commonly used for THz emitters—the ANE contribution is not only significant but can actually overwhelm ultrafast demagnetization. Ultrafast demagnetization only emerges as the dominant mechanism in very thick films (exceeding 90 nm).

This work successfully unifies previous, seemingly contradictory observations by showing how the dominant emission mechanism shifts as a function of film thickness and thermal gradients. It clarifies that the thermal response of the electron system is a vital component of spintronic THz generation.

Conclusion

By identifying the Anomalous Nernst Effect as a primary driver of THz emission in single ferromagnetic films, this research provides a new framework for understanding ultrafast spin-caloritronic processes. While challenges remain in completely separating AHE from interface-driven ANE across all material systems, these findings offer a clear path forward for engineering high-efficiency spintronic THz sources. Future work will focus on optimizing these thermal gradients and exploring different ferromagnetic materials to further enhance the performance of single-layer emitters.

Summary updated

Abstract

By developing a bidirectional-pump terahertz (THz) emission spectroscopy, we reveal an anomalous Nernst effect (ANE) induced THz emission in a single ferromagnetic film. Based on the distinctive symmetry of the THz signals, ANE is unequivocally distinguished from the previously attributed ultrafast demagnetization and anomalous Hall effect mechanisms. A quantitative method is established to separate the different contributions, demonstrating a significant ANE contribution that even overwhelms other competing mechanisms. Our work not only clarifies the origin of the ferromagnetic-based THz emission, but also offers a fertile platform for investigating the ultrafast magnetism and THz spintronics.
BibTeX
@misc{zheng2023anomalous,
  author = {Feng Zheng and Wei Tan and Zuanming Jin and Yijia Chen and Zhangfeng Zhong and Song Sun and Jin Tang and Yexing Jiang and Po-Hsun Wu and Jun Cheng and B. F. Miao and Haifeng Ding and Dacheng Wang and Yiming Zhu and Guohong Ma and Dazhi Hou and S. Y. Huang and Ma, Guohong and Hou, Dazhi and Huang, Ssu-Yen},
  title = {{Anomalous Nernst effect induced terahertz emission in a single ferromagnetic film}},
  year = {2023},
  eprint = {2302.11134},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2302.11134},
}

Loading related content...

Figure