Annealing glasses by cyclic shear deformation

Pallabi Das, Anshul D. S. Parmar, Srikanth SastryThe Journal of Chemical Physics 2018

TL;DR

This paper demonstrates that "shaking" a glass through cyclic shear deformation can help it reach lower energy states, a process known as annealing. To ensure these states represent true physical equilibrium, the authors developed a modified Hybrid Monte Carlo algorithm that accounts for the work done during shearing, providing a new tool for simulating the complex behavior of glasses at low temperatures.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Simulating glasses is a notorious "slow-motion" problem in physics. As a liquid cools toward a glass, its internal movements slow down exponentially. In a computer simulation, the system quickly gets stuck in high-energy, "un-annealed" configurations because it would take longer than the age of the universe to naturally relax into the low-energy states found in real-world, well-aged glasses.

Researchers need ways to "accelerate" this relaxation to study how glasses behave near the glass transition temperature. While some methods like "Swap Monte Carlo" are very effective, they only work for specific types of mixtures. This paper investigates whether mechanical agitation—specifically cyclic shear (repeatedly deforming the material back and forth)—can serve as a more general method to push glasses into deeper, more stable energy states.

Methods

The authors employed two primary computational strategies:

  1. Non-Equilibrium Molecular Dynamics (NEMD): They used the SLLOD algorithm to simulate a standard model glass (the Kob-Andersen 80:20 mixture) under oscillatory strain. They varied temperature, shear rate, and strain amplitude to see how the system's energy evolved.
  2. Modified Hybrid Monte Carlo (HMC): This is the paper's key theoretical contribution. Standard HMC uses energy-conserving dynamics to propose new states. However, cyclic shear is non-Hamiltonian and dissipates heat, which usually breaks the requirements for equilibrium sampling. The authors derived a modified acceptance probability that includes the work done ($\Delta W$) during the shear cycle. This correction allows the simulation to use "messy" mechanical driving while still strictly converging to a proper equilibrium ensemble.

Datasets

The study uses the Kob-Andersen (KA) 80:20 binary mixture, which is the "standard candle" of glass physics simulations.

  • System Sizes: Simulations were performed with $N = 500$ and $N = 4000$ particles.
  • Benchmarks: Results were compared against standard NVT (constant volume and temperature) Molecular Dynamics and previously established values for the Kauzmann temperature ($T_K$) and Mode Coupling Temperature ($T_{MCT}$) for this model.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The "Sweet Spot" for Shearing: There is an optimal strain amplitude ($\gamma_{max}$). If you shear too gently, the glass doesn't change; if you shear too violently, the glass "yields" and ends up in a higher-energy, less stable state. The best annealing happens just below the yielding point.
  • Overaging: At very low temperatures where standard simulations fail to move, cyclic shear successfully induces "overaging"—forcing the system into lower energy states faster than thermal fluctuations alone.
  • Equivalence of States: Surprisingly, the configurations produced by mechanical shearing are structurally and vibrationally indistinguishable from those produced by slow thermal cooling. This means "shaking" a glass is a valid way to reach the same physical states as "cooling" it.
  • The Work Correction: The most important "aha" moment is that you can turn a non-equilibrium process (shearing) into an equilibrium sampler (HMC) simply by tracking the heat dissipated during the move and using it to weight the acceptance of that move.

Key Results

  • Structural Identity: Radial distribution functions and vibrational density of states (DOS) for sheared configurations matched equilibrium MD results with high precision.
  • Efficiency Gain: In the modified HMC scheme at $T = 0.37$, the authors observed a 10x speedup in reaching asymptotic energy levels compared to cyclic shear without the Monte Carlo sampling.
  • Thermodynamic Consistency: The modified HMC algorithm successfully generated an equilibrium ensemble even when using dissipative, thermostatted dynamics that would normally be forbidden in standard Monte Carlo.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Scalability: A major limitation is that the "work done" during a shear cycle is an extensive property (it grows with the number of particles $N$). For very large systems, the probability of accepting a shear move becomes vanishingly small.
  • Proposed Fixes: The authors suggest two workarounds: shearing only small "subvolumes" of the glass at a time or using "adaptive strain amplitudes" that shrink as the system gets larger to keep acceptance rates reasonable.
  • Generalization: The authors suggest this framework could be extended to other types of driving, such as cyclic volume changes (bulk strain), to see if they offer even better acceleration for different classes of materials.

Summary updated

Abstract

A major challenge in simulating glassy systems is the ability to generate configurations that may be found in equilibrium at sufficiently low temperatures, in order to probe static and dynamic behavior close to the glass transition. A variety of approaches have recently explored ways of surmounting this obstacle. Here, we explore the possibility of employing mechanical agitation, in the form of cyclic shear deformation, to generate low energy configurations in a model glass former. We perform shear deformation simulations over a range of temperatures, shear rates, and strain amplitudes. We find that shear deformation induces faster relaxation toward low energy configurations, or overaging, in simulations at sufficiently low temperatures, consistently with previous results for athermal shear. However, for temperatures at which simulations can be run until a steady state is reached with or without shear deformation, we find that the inclusion of shear deformation does not result in any speed up of the relaxation toward low energy configurations. Although we find the configurations from shear simulations to have properties indistinguishable from an equilibrium ensemble, the cyclic shear procedure does not guarantee that we generate an equilibrium ensemble at a desired temperature. In order to ensure equilibrium sampling, we develop a hybrid Monte Carlo algorithm that employs cyclic shear as a trial generation step and has acceptance probabilities that depend not only on the change in internal energy but also on the heat dissipated (equivalently, work done). We show that such an algorithm, indeed, generates an equilibrium ensemble.
BibTeX
@article{das2018annealing,
  author = {Pallabi Das and Anshul D. S. Parmar and Srikanth Sastry},
  title = {{Annealing glasses by cyclic shear deformation}},
  journal = {The Journal of Chemical Physics},
  year = {2018},
}
Figure