Animal propagation and genomic survey of a genotype 1 isolate of Cryptosporidium parvum

Giovanni Widmer, Donna E. Akiyoshi, Michael A. Buckholt, Xu Feng, Stephen M. Rich, K.m Deary, Cheryl Bowman, Ping Xu, Yidong Wang, X Wang, Gregory A. Buck, Saul TziporiMolecular 2000 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper successfully adapted a human-specific genotype 1 Cryptosporidium parvum isolate (NEMC1) for serial propagation in gnotobiotic piglets, a crucial step for studying this prevalent human pathogen. The study also provided a preliminary genomic survey, revealing significant genetic divergence between genotype 1 and the more commonly studied genotype 2.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Cryptosporidium parvum is a significant cause of diarrheal illness in both immunocompetent and immunocompromised individuals. While two main genotypes, type 1 and type 2, are known, most laboratory research has focused on type 2 isolates, which readily infect laboratory animals like calves. Type 1, however, is the predominant genotype causing human infections, but it has been notoriously difficult to propagate in animal models. This lack of a suitable animal model for type 1 has hindered detailed phenotypic and genotypic characterization, leading to assumptions about type 1 based on type 2 data, which may be inaccurate. This paper aims to bridge this gap by establishing a reliable animal model for type 1 C. parvum and initiating its genomic characterization.

Methods

The researchers employed several key methods:

  • Animal Propagation: Gnotobiotic piglets were used for serial propagation of the NEMC1 isolate. This involved oral inoculation with oocysts and regular monitoring of fecal shedding. The adaptation process was tracked by observing the time to oocyst shedding onset and the quantity of oocysts shed.
  • Genotyping: Multiple techniques were used to confirm the genotype of the NEMC1 isolate:
  • Restriction Fragment Length Polymorphism (RFLP): Analysis of three genetic markers (COWP, TRAP-C1, and β-tubulin) was performed to distinguish between genotypes.
  • Genotype-Specific PCR: Novel PCR primers were designed based on sequence differences between type 1 and type 2 isolates to specifically detect type 1 DNA.
  • Direct Sequence Analysis: The SSU rRNA gene was sequenced to confirm species identification and assess phylogenetic relationships.
  • Oocyst Decay Assay: The stability of NEMC1 oocysts at room temperature was assessed to understand their environmental persistence, a known differentiator between genotypes.
  • Preliminary Genome Sequence Survey (GSS): A random sequencing approach was used to generate approximately 200 kb of sequence data from the NEMC1 genome. This data was then compared to existing genotype 2 sequences in public databases.

Datasets

  • NEMC1 Isolate: A genotype 1 C. parvum isolate (NEMC1) obtained from an HIV-positive patient with cryptosporidiosis.
  • Public Databases: GenBank, GenEMBL, SwissPlus, and PIR databases were used for comparative genomic analysis.
  • Previously Characterized Isolates: Data from other C. parvum isolates (both genotype 1 and 2) were used for comparative RFLP and phylogenetic analyses.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Successful Adaptation of Genotype 1: The most significant finding is the successful serial propagation of a genotype 1 isolate in gnotobiotic piglets. This overcomes a major hurdle in studying this prevalent human pathogen.
  • Genotypic Stability: The NEMC1 isolate maintained its genotype 1 profile throughout multiple pig passages, suggesting robust genetic integrity under these conditions. This is crucial for reliable experimental studies.
  • Phenotypic Adaptation: While genotypically stable, the isolate showed signs of adaptation to the pig host, with a progressively shortened incubation period and increased oocyst shedding over passages.
  • Significant Genotypic Divergence: The preliminary genome survey revealed substantial genetic differences between genotype 1 (NEMC1) and genotype 2 C. parvum, with an average similarity of ~95%. This highlights that genotype 2 data cannot be directly extrapolated to genotype 1.
  • Oocyst Stability Differences: NEMC1 exhibited fast oocyst decay at room temperature, characteristic of many genotype 1 isolates, contrasting with the slower decay of genotype 2 isolates.
  • Refractory to GKO Mice: NEMC1 oocysts were unable to infect interferon-gamma knockout (GKO) mice, a model highly susceptible to genotype 2 C. parvum. This points to significant differences in host-pathogen interactions between the genotypes.

Key Results

  • NEMC1 was successfully propagated through six serial passages in gnotobiotic piglets over seven months.
  • The latent period (time to oocyst shedding) decreased from 9 days in the first passage to 3-4 days in later passages.
  • RFLP, genotype-specific PCR, and SSU rRNA sequencing confirmed NEMC1 as a genotype 1 isolate.
  • Oocyst decay assays showed NEMC1 had a short half-life at room temperature (< 7 days), typical of genotype 1.
  • The preliminary genome survey (200 kb) indicated ~95% similarity to genotype 2 sequences, with ~24% of NEMC1 sequences showing homology to previously determined genotype 2 sequences.
  • NEMC1 oocysts did not infect GKO mice, whereas genotype 2 isolates are known to infect this model readily.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Limited Genome Coverage: The genome survey covered only ~2% of the C. parvum genome. Future work should aim for more comprehensive sequencing to fully understand the genetic differences between genotypes.
  • Potential for Mixed Populations: While the study argues against NEMC1 being a mixed population, the authors acknowledge that some RFLP profiles showed faint bands suggestive of genotype 2 DNA. Further investigation into the possibility of pre-existing genotypic heterogeneity in the original isolate is warranted.
  • Host-Specific Adaptation: The observed adaptation in piglets (shortened latent period, increased shedding) suggests selection for phenotypes that propagate more readily in this host. Future work could explore the genetic basis of this adaptation.
  • Further Phenotypic Characterization: The availability of a propagated type 1 isolate opens doors for detailed phenotypic studies, including comparisons of virulence, host range, and drug susceptibility with type 2 isolates.
  • Clinical Correlation: The study suggests that genotypic differences may correlate with clinical manifestations. Future research could investigate this link more thoroughly, especially given that human volunteer studies are no longer restricted to genotype 2.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@inproceedings{widmer2000animal,
  author = {Giovanni Widmer and Donna E. Akiyoshi and Michael A. Buckholt and Xu Feng and Stephen M. Rich and K.M Deary and Cheryl Bowman and Ping Xu and Yidong Wang and X Wang and Gregory A. Buck and Saul Tzipori},
  title = {{Animal propagation and genomic survey of a genotype 1 isolate of Cryptosporidium parvum}},
  booktitle = {Molecular},
  year = {2000},
  doi = {10.1016/s0166-6851(00)00211-5},
}
Figure