Animal complexity defines the functionality of synonymous mutations through mediating microRNA regulations

Chunmei Cui, X. Lin, Qinghua CuibioRxiv 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper investigates how synonymous mutations (SMs) affect gene function across different species, focusing on their role in regulating microRNA (miRNA) interactions. They found that the proportion of SMs impacting gene function through miRNA regulation increases with animal complexity, suggesting that more complex organisms have evolved more intricate regulatory networks where SMs can play a more significant role.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Synonymous mutations (SMs) are changes in DNA that don't alter the amino acid sequence of a protein. Traditionally, they were considered neutral and functionally irrelevant. However, recent studies have sparked debate, with some suggesting SMs in yeast are deleterious, while others find no evidence of this. This paper builds on previous work showing that SMs can affect gene function by altering miRNA binding sites, particularly in humans. The core problem addressed is understanding how the functional impact of SMs varies across species, especially in light of differing complexities in miRNA regulatory systems. The authors hypothesize that as animal complexity (and thus miRNA regulation complexity) increases, so does the potential for SMs to influence gene function.

Methods

The researchers employed a computational approach to identify synonymous mutations (SMs) that could alter miRNA-mediated gene regulation. They utilized two popular miRNA target prediction tools, TargetScan and miRanda, to predict miRNA binding sites. For each SM, they generated two sequences: one with the reference allele and one with the alternative allele at the mutation site. These sequences were then analyzed by both tools to detect changes in predicted miRNA binding sites. The intersection of results from TargetScan and miRanda was used to identify SMs likely to affect miRNA regulation.

Datasets

The study utilized publicly available datasets:

  • SNP data: Collected from the dbSNP repository for human, mouse, and Drosophila. For humans, only common SNPs were included. For C. elegans, SNP data was obtained from WormBase.
  • Genome annotation and gene sequences: Downloaded from NCBI and WormBase.
  • miRNA sequences: Obtained from miRBase.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Animal complexity matters: The study strongly supports the hypothesis that the functional impact of synonymous mutations is directly correlated with the complexity of the animal species.
  • miRNA regulation is key: The primary mechanism by which SMs exert function, according to this study, is through altering miRNA binding sites.
  • Yeast as a baseline: The absence of miRNAs in yeast provides a clear baseline, showing virtually no functional impact from SMs via this mechanism.
  • A gradient of functionality: There's a clear trend of increasing SM functionality with increasing animal complexity, from yeast (0%) to C. elegans (14.11%), Drosophila (15.73%), mouse (50.67%), and human (60.06%).

Key Results

The study found the following proportions of synonymous mutations (SMs) affecting gene functionality through altering miRNA regulations:

  • Yeast: 0%
  • C. elegans: 14.11%
  • Drosophila: 15.73%
  • Mouse: 50.67%
  • Human: 60.06%

These results indicate a significant increase in the functional impact of SMs as species become more complex, particularly in mammals. The study also found no evidence to support the claim that most SMs in yeast genes are deleterious.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Limitations: The study acknowledges that the absence of miRNAs in yeast means that any functional impact of SMs in yeast must occur through mechanisms other than miRNA regulation. The analysis is also based on computational predictions of miRNA binding sites, which may not perfectly reflect in vivo interactions.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest that further research could explore other mechanisms by which SMs might affect gene function, especially in simpler organisms like yeast. Investigating the specific biological consequences of these miRNA-altering SMs in higher animals would also be a valuable next step.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract Most recently, Shen et al. revealed that most synonymous mutations (SMs) in yeast genes are strongly non-neutral, however, which was soon challenged by Kruglyak et al. who find no evidence for deleterious effect on fitness of SMs in yeast genes. We previously revealed that SMs in numerous human genes show functionality through changing miRNA regulations. Given that higher animals show higher complexity of miRNA regulations, here we present a hypothesis that SMs in lower animal genes show less functionality and vice versa. To confirm this, we comprehensively investigated the SMs changing miRNA regulations in yeast, C.elegans, Drosophila , mouse, and human. As expected, the result showed that the proportion of SMs affecting gene functionality through altering miRNA regulations is about 0%, 14%, 16%, 51%, and 60% in yeast, C. elegans, Drosophila , mouse, and human, respectively, suggesting that the complexity of animals indeed determines the functionality of SMs through mediating miRNA regulations. Finally, this study supports no evidence that most SMs in yeast genes are deleterious.
BibTeX
@misc{cui2022animal,
  author = {Chunmei Cui and X. Lin and Qinghua Cui},
  title = {{Animal complexity defines the functionality of synonymous mutations through mediating microRNA regulations}},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.1101/2022.08.30.505799},
  howpublished = {bioRxiv},
}
Figure