TL;DR
This paper presents the first detailed measurements of angular distributions in the rare $B \to K^* l^+ l^-$ decay from the BABAR experiment. By analyzing the angles of the leptons and the $K^*$ meson, the researchers provide crucial data that can constrain the Standard Model and probe for new physics beyond it.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
The Standard Model (SM) of particle physics describes fundamental particles and their interactions. However, there are phenomena, like the rare decay of a B meson into a $K^*$ meson and a lepton-lepton pair ($B \to K^* l^+ l^-$), that are highly suppressed in the SM. These "rare" decays are particularly interesting because even tiny deviations from SM predictions could signal the presence of new, undiscovered particles or forces.
Specifically, the $B \to K^* l^+ l^-$ decay is sensitive to contributions from both electroweak penguins (mediated by photons or Z bosons) and W boson box diagrams. The relative strengths and phases of these contributions determine the decay's angular distributions. Measuring these distributions allows physicists to probe the underlying physics. The key quantities to measure are the lepton forward-backward asymmetry ($A_{FB}$), which indicates a preference for leptons to be emitted in the forward or backward direction relative to the B meson's motion, and the $K^*$ longitudinal polarization fraction ($F_L$), which describes how the $K^*$ meson is oriented. These measurements are challenging due to the low branching ratios of these decays and the need to distinguish them from backgrounds.
Methods
The BABAR experiment collected a large dataset of $B\overline{B}$ events. To study the $B \to K^* l^+ l^-$ decay, the researchers employed a sophisticated analysis pipeline:
- Event Reconstruction: They identified signal events by reconstructing the $K^*$ meson as a $K\pi$ pair and the lepton-lepton pair ($e^+e^-$ or $\mu^+\mu^-$). They also reconstructed control samples to validate their methods.
- Background Suppression: A significant challenge is distinguishing signal events from various backgrounds, including semileptonic B decays and continuum $e^+e^- \to q\overline{q}$ events. The researchers used neural networks (NNs) trained on various event variables (like thrust, energy deposits, and vertex information) to effectively suppress these backgrounds.
- Angular Distribution Fits: After event selection, the core of the analysis involved fitting the observed angular distributions. They performed sequential unbinned maximum likelihood fits to:
- The dilepton invariant mass ($m_{ll}$) to determine the number of signal and background events.
- The angle $\theta_K$ (between the $K$ and $B$ directions in the $K^*$ rest frame) to determine the $K^*$ longitudinal polarization fraction ($F_L$).
- The angle $\theta_l$ (between the lepton and $B$ directions in the $l^+l^-$ rest frame) to determine the lepton forward-backward asymmetry ($A_{FB}$).
- Systematic Error Evaluation: Extensive studies were performed to estimate systematic uncertainties, including variations in background modeling, signal modeling, and detector acceptance.
Datasets
The analysis utilized a dataset of 384 million $B\overline{B}$ events collected by the BABAR detector at the PEP-II asymmetric-energy $e^+e^-$ collider. This dataset is crucial for achieving the statistical precision required for this rare decay study.
Key Insights and Ideas
- Sensitivity to New Physics: The angular distributions in $B \to K^* l^+ l^-$ decays are highly sensitive to physics beyond the Standard Model. Deviations from SM predictions in $A_{FB}$ and $F_L$ can point to new particles or interactions.
- Complementarity of $A_{FB}$ and $F_L$: Measuring both $A_{FB}$ and $F_L$ is essential. $F_L$ provides a model-independent way to constrain the underlying physics, which then allows for a more robust interpretation of $A_{FB}$.
- q² Dependence is Crucial: The behavior of $A_{FB}$ and $F_L$ changes significantly with the dilepton invariant mass squared ($q^2$). Studying these distributions in different $q^2$ bins (low and high) provides a more detailed picture and allows for comparisons with different theoretical predictions.
- Validation with Control Samples: The use of control samples, such as $B \to J/\psi K^*$ and $B \to K l^+ l^-$, was critical for validating the analysis techniques and ensuring the reliability of the results.
Key Results
The paper reports measurements of $A_{FB}$ and $F_L$ in two dilepton invariant mass regions:
- Low $q^2$ region ($m_{ll} < 2.5$ GeV/$c^2$):
- Lepton forward-backward asymmetry: $A_{FB} = 0.24^{+0.18}_{-0.23} \pm 0.05$
- $K^*$ longitudinal polarization: $F_L = 0.35 \pm 0.16 \pm 0.04$
- High $q^2$ region ($m_{ll} > 3.2$ GeV/$c^2$):
- Lepton forward-backward asymmetry: $A_{FB} = 0.76^{+0.52}_{-0.32} \pm 0.07$
- $K^*$ longitudinal polarization: $F_L = 0.71^{+0.20}_{-0.22} \pm 0.04$
These results are compared to SM predictions, which suggest a small, negative $A_{FB}$ at low $q^2$ and a positive $A_{FB}$ at high $q^2$, with specific values for $F_L$. The measured values show some tension with the SM predictions, particularly for $A_{FB}$ in the low $q^2$ region.
Limitations and Future Work
- Statistical Uncertainties: Despite the large dataset, statistical uncertainties remain significant, especially for $A_{FB}$ in both regions and for $F_L$ in the low $q^2$ region.
- Systematic Uncertainties: While efforts were made to control systematic errors, they still contribute to the overall uncertainty, particularly in the modeling of signal and background shapes.
- Future Work: The authors suggest that future analyses with larger datasets or improved analysis techniques could further refine these measurements. The current results provide valuable input for theoretical models aiming to explain electroweak interactions and search for new physics. The observed deviations from SM predictions, if confirmed with higher precision, could be a strong indication of physics beyond the Standard Model.
Summary updated