Abstract
This paper analyzes the implications on employment, taxation, and wildfire fuel reduction costs when using mobile pellet mills to remove biomass and reduce wildfire fuels. Wildfire suppression costs in British Columbia have exceeded the set budget in 9 of the last 10 years and the province has only reduced the fuel load on a fraction of the high-risk hectares. Using a novel high-moisture mobile pellet mill allows the production of 89,000 tonnes of wood pellets each year for a price of $293. Each tonne produced also provides $546 in additional benefits from employment, taxation, and reductions in the cost to perform fuel treatments. The presented research found that 11 employees are needed to operate a mobile pellet mill, with total employment of 242 for 22 systems across BC. The assessed system can also avoid $5.5 million in employment insurance payments. The 22 systems also provide $323,000 in taxable profits and $524,000 from income taxes from employees. Fuel treatment with the researched systems costs $1112. A cost-benefit analysis shows that the system provides $2.97 in benefits for every dollar invested.
Introduction
British Columbia (BC) is currently trapped in a destructive wildfire cycle. Suppression costs have consistently outpaced provincial budgets, yet the high expense of fuel treatment—removing the residues that fuel catastrophic crown fires—prevents large-scale mitigation. Simultaneously, the forestry sector faces a fiber shortage as centralized mills struggle with the high cost of transporting low-density, high-moisture residues from remote sites. This study investigates whether mobile pellet mills can bridge this gap by processing waste into transportable fuel at the forest edge.
Methodology
The researchers conducted a comprehensive cost-benefit analysis (CBA) comparing two scenarios designed to produce approximately 90,000 tonnes of pellets annually: a single centralized traditional mill versus a fleet of 22 mobile pellet mills. To account for operational volatility in diesel prices, labor, and moisture content, the study utilized a Monte Carlo simulation with 600 trials, employing Beta distributions to propagate uncertainty. The model tracked primary economic outputs alongside ancillary impacts such as avoided Employment Insurance (EI) payments and tax revenues.
Economic and Societal Impacts
A primary advantage of the mobile system is its contribution to rural economic resilience. While traditional mills provide centralized employment, the mobile fleet generates approximately 286 jobs (compared to 64 in the centralized model) distributed across rural communities. This decentralized approach provides a buffer against the boom-bust cycles of large-scale milling.
As shown in the baseline data for traditional mills, the total benefits per tonne are significantly lower than the $546 in societal benefits estimated for the mobile system. The mobile system is projected to avoid $6.25 million in annual EI payments and generate substantially higher income tax revenue due to its larger workforce.
Wildfire Mitigation and Cost Efficiency
The mobile pellet system effectively turns fuel treatment from a pure expense into a value-generating activity. By treating harvest residue as a feedstock rather than a waste product to be burned in slash piles, the system reduces fuel treatment costs from roughly $3,400/ha to approximately $583/ha—an 82% reduction.
This efficiency allows for a much larger treatment footprint; a 22-mill system could treat over 14,000 hectares annually, providing a tangible reduction in provincial wildfire risk.
Conclusion
The study concludes that mobile pelletization offers a superior cost-benefit ratio (CBR) of 1.80 ± 0.25, compared to 1.17 ± 0.13 for traditional mills. Although mobile pellets are more expensive to produce at $293/tonne, the total societal return—factoring in employment, taxation, and wildfire mitigation—reaches $2.97 for every dollar invested. These findings suggest that strategic government support to bridge the gap between production costs and market prices could yield significant long-term fiscal and environmental dividends for the province.
Summary updated