Ancient west Eurasian ancestry in southern and eastern Africa

Joseph K. Pickrell, Nick Patterson, Po‐Ru Loh, Mark Lipson, Bonnie Berger, Mark Stoneking, Brigitte Pakendorf, David ReichProceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 2014 · DOI

TL;DR

This study uses advanced genetic analysis to reveal ancient gene flow from West Eurasia into Southern and Eastern Africa. The findings suggest that West Eurasian ancestry entered Southern Africa indirectly through Eastern Africa, with distinct admixture events dating back thousands of years.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Understanding the deep history of human populations in Africa, particularly the origins of genetic diversity and admixture events, is challenging due to the scarcity of written records. Previous genetic studies have identified admixture in Southern African Khoisan populations but have reached different conclusions about the sources and timing of these events. This paper aims to clarify the historical scenarios by thoroughly examining genome-wide genetic data to pinpoint the sources and dates of West Eurasian ancestry in both Southern and Eastern Africa.

Methods

The researchers employed sophisticated population genetic techniques, primarily focusing on linkage disequilibrium (LD). They utilized a method called ALDER (Admixture Linkage Disequilibrium) to infer admixture times and identify ancestral populations. A key innovation was the development of a method to estimate multiple admixture events by modeling LD decay as a mixture of exponentials, allowing for a more nuanced reconstruction of population histories. They also used f4 statistics to estimate ancestry proportions.

Datasets

The study utilized publicly available genome-wide genetic data from various human populations worldwide. Specifically, they combined data from the Affymetrix Human Origins Array and Illumina genotyping arrays. These datasets included samples from Southern African Khoisan populations, other African groups (Niger-Congo speakers, Eastern Africans), and West Eurasian populations (Europeans, Middle Easterners).

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Indirect West Eurasian Entry into Southern Africa: The most compelling insight is that West Eurasian ancestry likely arrived in Southern Africa not through direct contact, but via an already admixed population from Eastern Africa.
  • Multiple Admixture Waves: The analysis revealed that many Southern and Eastern African populations have experienced multiple distinct admixture events over time, not just a single influx of foreign ancestry.
  • Dating Ancient Migrations: The study provides precise estimates for these ancient admixture events, pushing back the timeline of West Eurasian gene flow into Africa to several thousand years ago.
  • Reconstructing Ancestral Populations: The researchers were able to reconstruct the likely genetic profile of the West Eurasian population that admixed into Eastern Africa, demonstrating it was a better proxy for Southern African ancestry than modern West Eurasian populations.

Key Results

  • West Eurasian ancestry was detected in all studied Khoisan populations, with varying proportions.
  • The earliest West Eurasian admixture event in Eastern Africa was dated to approximately 2,700-3,300 years ago.
  • In Southern Africa, the most significant West Eurasian admixture event was dated to approximately 900-1,800 years ago.
  • Khoisan populations speaking Khoe-Kwadi languages showed the largest impact of this later West Eurasian admixture.
  • The reconstructed ancestral West Eurasian population in Eastern Africa was a better proxy for Southern African ancestry than modern Europeans or Middle Easterners.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Distinguishing Recent vs. Ancient Admixture: In some populations, particularly the Nama, it was challenging to definitively distinguish between recent (post-colonial) European admixture and older West Eurasian ancestry.
  • Alternative Scenarios: While the indirect gene flow model is presented as the most parsimonious, the authors acknowledge that direct contact with an unsampled West Eurasian population cannot be entirely excluded, though it lacks supporting evidence.
  • Future Directions: The authors suggest that advances in ancient DNA technology could directly test their proposed model by analyzing ancient samples from relevant time periods and regions. Further research could also explore the specific Eastern African populations that served as intermediaries.

Summary updated

Abstract

The history of southern Africa involved interactions between indigenous hunter-gatherers and a range of populations that moved into the region. Here we use genome-wide genetic data to show that there are at least two admixture events in the history of Khoisan populations (southern African hunter-gatherers and pastoralists who speak non-Bantu languages with click consonants). One involved populations related to Niger-Congo-speaking African populations, and the other introduced ancestry most closely related to west Eurasian (European or Middle Eastern) populations. We date this latter admixture event to ∼900-1,800 y ago and show that it had the largest demographic impact in Khoisan populations that speak Khoe-Kwadi languages. A similar signal of west Eurasian ancestry is present throughout eastern Africa. In particular, we also find evidence for two admixture events in the history of Kenyan, Tanzanian, and Ethiopian populations, the earlier of which involved populations related to west Eurasians and which we date to ∼2,700-3,300 y ago. We reconstruct the allele frequencies of the putative west Eurasian population in eastern Africa and show that this population is a good proxy for the west Eurasian ancestry in southern Africa. The most parsimonious explanation for these findings is that west Eurasian ancestry entered southern Africa indirectly through eastern Africa.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{pickrell2014ancient,
  author = {Joseph K. Pickrell and Nick Patterson and Po‐Ru Loh and Mark Lipson and Bonnie Berger and Mark Stoneking and Brigitte Pakendorf and David Reich},
  title = {{Ancient west Eurasian ancestry in southern and eastern Africa}},
  booktitle = {Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences},
  year = {2014},
  doi = {10.1073/pnas.1313787111},
}
Figure