Anatomical factors influencing temporomandibular joint clicking in young adults: temporomandibular joint structure disorder or lateral pterygoid muscle dysfunction?

Dan Luo, Hua Yang, Mujie Yuan, Dashan Wang, Cheng Qiu, Ruizhi Zhou, Yudong Gao, Ruijie Xu, Jianjun Yang, Zexian XuFrontiers in Bioengineering and Biotechnology 2024 · DOI

TL;DR

Is that annoying "click" in your jaw a sign of a structural joint defect or just a muscle misfiring? This study suggests that in young adults, TMJ clicking is rarely about the physical shape or position of the joint itself; instead, it's strongly linked to dysfunction and inflammation of the lateral pterygoid muscle (LPM).

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Temporomandibular disorders (TMDs) are incredibly common, especially among young adults, with joint clicking being one of the most frequent symptoms. For decades, the prevailing theory was that clicking was caused by "anterior disc displacement"—the cartilage disc in the jaw joint slipping out of place.

However, clinicians often see patients who have perfectly positioned discs but still experience clicking, or vice versa. This suggests that structural "disorder" isn't the whole story. The researchers sought to determine if the culprit might actually be the masticatory muscles—specifically the lateral pterygoid muscle (LPM), which controls jaw movement—rather than the bones and ligaments of the joint.

Methods

The researchers conducted a comparative study involving 249 young adults (ages 18–24), categorized into four groups: a healthy control (HC) and three "clicking" groups (opening, closing, or both).

The study utilized a dual-pronged approach:

  1. Clinical Palpation: Specialists manually checked for tenderness in the jaw muscles to assess functional state.
  2. Advanced MRI Texture Analysis (TA): Beyond just looking at the "shape" of the joint, the team used MRI sequences (like PDW-FSE) and software (ImageJ) to perform a mathematical analysis of the muscle tissue's texture. They used Gray-Level Co-occurrence Matrices (GLCM) to calculate parameters like "entropy" (randomness) and "angular second moment" (uniformity). This allows researchers to detect subtle tissue changes, like edema or inflammation, that are invisible to the naked eye on a standard scan.

Datasets

The study utilized a primary cohort of 249 participants:

  • Healthy Controls: 93 freshmen from Qingdao University with no history of TMDs.
  • Patient Groups: 156 patients from the Affiliated Hospital of Qingdao University who experienced TMJ clicking but no other severe TMD symptoms (like lockjaw or bone destruction).

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Structure is Not Destiny: Surprisingly, there were no significant differences in the shape of the joint (condylar morphology) or the position of the disc between healthy people and those with clicking jaws. This challenges the traditional "mechanical" view of TMJ clicking.
  • The LPM is the "Prime Suspect": In patients with clicking, the lateral pterygoid muscle showed tenderness in 77.78% to 100% of cases. It was the most consistently dysfunctional muscle across all subgroups.
  • Texture as a Biomarker: The MRI texture analysis revealed that the LPM in clicking patients was "less defined" and "more uniform in gray scale." This mathematical signature suggests the presence of inflammatory exudates or muscle fiber changes that disrupt the normal "sharp" texture of healthy muscle.
  • Functional vs. Anatomical: The study shifts the focus from anatomy (how it's built) to function (how it moves). Clicking appears to be a symptom of a muscle that is inflamed or failing to coordinate properly, leading to irregular joint movement.

Key Results

  • Structural Findings: P-values for differences in disc position and condylar morphology between groups were non-significant ($p > 0.05$).
  • Muscle Tenderness: Masticatory muscle dysfunction was significantly higher on the clicking side versus the non-clicking side ($p < 0.0001$).
  • Texture Significance: The difference in LPM texture between the healthy and clicking groups was highly significant ($p < 0.0001$). Specifically, the "Entropy" (complexity of information) was higher in clicking groups, indicating more irregular tissue states.
  • Conclusion: TMJ clicking in this demographic is unrelated to joint structure but highly related to LPM dysfunction.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations:

  1. Sample Size: While sufficient for statistical significance, the sample is relatively small and limited to a specific age range (18–24).
  2. Causality: Because this is a cross-sectional study, it’s hard to say if LPM dysfunction causes the clicking or if the clicking eventually causes the muscle to become tender and inflamed.
  3. Lack of Molecular Data: The "texture" changes seen on MRI are proxies for inflammation. Future work should include cellular or molecular experiments to confirm exactly what is happening inside the muscle tissue.
  4. Follow-up: The study does not track these patients over time to see if muscle-focused therapy (like physical therapy or Botox) actually stops the clicking.

Summary updated

Abstract

<b>Objective:</b> This study aimed to investigate the selected anatomical factors that can potentially influence temporomandibular joint (TMJ) clicking in young adults by assessing TMJ structures and lateral pterygoid muscle (LPM) function using magnetic resonance imaging (MRI). <b>Methods:</b> The patients were divided into four groups: the healthy control group; the clicking on mouth opening group; the clicking on mouth closing group; and the clicking on mouth opening and closing group. Additionally, we used clinical palpation to evaluate the masticatory muscles' functional state and employed MRI using the OCOR-T1WI-FSE-CLOSED, OSAG-PDW-FSE-CLOSED, and OSAG-PDW-FSE-OPEN sequences to analyze the texture of the lateral pterygoid muscle (LPM). <b>Results:</b> The proportion of any articular disc or condylar morphology class did not differ significantly between the TMJ clicking and HC groups. The articular disc position did not differ significantly between the TMJ clicking and HC groups. In the TMJ clicking group, the presence of masticatory muscle dysfunction differed significantly between the clicking and non-clicking sides. Moreover, the LPM accounted for the highest proportion among masticatory muscles with tenderness in all TMJ clicking subgroups (77.78%-100%). Therefore, in the TMJ clicking group, the LPM texture was less defined, more uniform in gray scale, and more similar to local texture (<i>p</i> < 0.0001). <b>Conclusion:</b> The occurrence of TMJ clicking in young adults is unrelated to the TMJ structure but related to the function of masticatory muscles, particularly the LPM.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{luo2024anatomical,
  author = {Dan Luo and Hua Yang and Mujie Yuan and Dashan Wang and Cheng Qiu and Ruizhi Zhou and Yudong Gao and Ruijie Xu and Jianjun Yang and Zexian Xu},
  title = {{Anatomical factors influencing temporomandibular joint clicking in young adults: temporomandibular joint structure disorder or lateral pterygoid muscle dysfunction?}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Bioengineering and Biotechnology},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.3389/fbioe.2024.1337267},
}
Figure