Analyzing Spatio-Temporal Change in Ecosystem Quality and Its Driving Mechanism in Henan Province, China, from 2010 to 2020

Xiaoyun Ren, Ming-Kong Zhang, Juncheng Qian, Shuangquan Li, Jingxu Wang, Jun DuSustainability 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This study analyzes the changes in ecosystem quality in Henan Province, China, from 2010 to 2020, revealing an overall improvement driven primarily by socioeconomic factors like GDP and population density. The research highlights the complex interplay of natural, socioeconomic, and policy drivers, emphasizing the need for tailored land-use and industrial policies across different natural domains to ensure sustainable development.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The rapid economic development and industrialization in China have often come at the cost of environmental degradation, creating a critical challenge for sustainable development. Henan Province, a key ecological barrier in the Yellow River Basin, faces this dilemma acutely. Understanding the spatio-temporal dynamics of its ecosystem quality and the underlying driving mechanisms is crucial for balancing economic growth with ecological conservation. Previous research has often focused on specific aspects or used less sophisticated methods, leaving a gap in comprehensively analyzing the multifaceted drivers of ecosystem quality change in a large, diverse region like Henan.

Methods

The researchers employed a multi-pronged approach:

  • Ecosystem Quality Index (EQI) Calculation: They developed an EQI based on remote sensing data (vegetation coverage, leaf area index, gross primary productivity) and classified it into five grades (very low to very high).
  • Gravity Center Analysis: This method was used to track the spatial movement of the ecosystem quality's center of gravity over time, indicating shifts in areas of improvement or decline.
  • Geo-detector Model: This powerful spatial statistical tool was utilized to:
  • Factor Detection: Quantify the individual explanatory power of various driving factors (physical, socioeconomic, policy) on ecosystem quality.
  • Interaction Detection: Analyze how pairs of factors interact, determining if they enhance or weaken each other's impact on ecosystem quality.

Datasets

The study utilized a range of data for county-level analysis in Henan Province for the years 2010, 2015, and 2020:

  • Physical Elements:
    • Relief amplitude (from Digital Elevation Model - DEM)
    • Land-use diversity (Shannon-Wiener index)
    • Average annual rainfall (meteorological station data)
    • Average annual temperature (meteorological station data)
  • Socioeconomic Elements:
    • Population density (from statistical yearbooks)
    • GDP per square kilometer (from statistical yearbooks)
  • Policy Adjustments:
    • Forestry engineering data (number of projects like "turning farmland into forests," "natural forest protection," and "shelter forest projects" from official government websites)
  • Remote Sensing Data: Fractional vegetation cover, leaf area index, and gross primary productivity (from the Institute of Remote Sensing, Chinese Academy of Sciences).

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Socioeconomic Dominance: The study strongly suggests that socioeconomic factors, particularly GDP per square kilometer and population density, are the most significant drivers of ecosystem quality changes in Henan. This highlights the profound impact of human activity and economic development on the environment.
  • Non-Linear Interactions: Driving factors don't act in isolation. The research found that interactions between factors are predominantly non-linear enhancements, meaning pairs of factors amplify each other's effects on ecosystem quality, often more than their individual impacts combined.
  • Regional Heterogeneity Matters: The impact of drivers varies significantly across different natural domains within Henan. For instance, land-use diversity has a stronger effect in hilly regions than in plains, indicating that different policy interventions are needed for different landscapes.
  • Forestry's Positive but Limited Role: While forestry projects show a positive influence on ecosystem quality, their impact is generally weaker compared to socioeconomic factors. This suggests that while conservation efforts are beneficial, they may not fully counteract the pressures from rapid economic development without complementary policies.

Key Results

  • Overall Improvement: Henan Province's ecosystem quality improved by approximately 27.7% from 2010 to 2020.
  • Spatial Shift: The center of gravity of ecosystem quality has consistently moved northwest, indicating improvements in that region.
  • Regional Quality Disparities: Southern mountainous and hilly areas (Western Henan, Tongbai, Nanyang) generally exhibit better ecosystem quality than the northern Loess Platform Hilly Area and the Yellow River Plain.
  • Dominant Drivers: GDP per square kilometer and population density were identified as the most influential factors affecting ecosystem quality.
  • Interaction Patterns: Interactions between socioeconomic and natural environmental factors were the most dominant, leading to non-linear enhancements in their impact.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge that data limitations meant a comprehensive consideration of all potential socioeconomic factors and land-use policies was not possible. Future research could incorporate factors like traffic network density, nighttime light data, and land-use morphological changes. They also suggest that the dynamic nature of ecological evolution requires continuous improvement of the driving factor index system and ongoing trend analysis to better guide policy. The study's findings underscore the need for targeted industrial and land-use policies tailored to the specific natural domains within Henan Province and for strengthening forestry protection policies to enhance ecosystem resilience.

Summary updated

Abstract

Henan Province is an important ecological barrier in the middle and lower reaches of the Yellow River. It is of great significance to study its ecosystem quality and the driving mechanisms behind this in order to realize ecological conservation and high-quality development in the Yellow River Basin. In this study, from the perspective of physical elements, socioeconomic elements, and policy adjustments, multi-source data on land use, population density, forestry engineering, and other indicators were selected to construct an index system of the driving factors of ecosystem quality in Henan Province. The characteristics of spatio-temporal change and the formation mechanism of ecosystem quality in Henan Province from 2010 to 2020 were analyzed by comprehensively using the gravity center analysis method and a geo-detector tool. The results showed the following: (1) The ecosystem quality of Henan Province in 2020 has increased by 27.7% compared with that in 2010, and the center of gravity of ecosystem quality continued to move to the northwest of Henan Province. The quality of ecosystems in the hilly region of Western Henan, Tongbai, and Nanyang was better than that in the northern Loess Platform Hilly Area and the Yellow River Plain, and it presented a spatial pattern in which the quality of the south was higher than that of the north, while the east and west were equal; (2) From 2010 to 2020, the average GDP and population density in Henan Province were the most important factors affecting the quality of its ecosystem. The effect of land-use diversity on ecosystem quality in the hilly region of Henan Province was stronger than that in the central and eastern plains; and (3) The interactions among the driving factors were mainly nonlinear enhancement and double factor enhancement, in which the interaction between socio-economic elements and natural environmental elements was the dominant interaction mode and could enhance the impact on the quality of the regional ecological environment. The results of this study indicate that attention should be paid to generating targeted industrial economy layout and land use policies in different natural domains. Moreover, forestry protection engineering policies should be further strengthened to improve the resilience of ecosystem quality to human activities.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{ren2022analyzing,
  author = {Xiaoyun Ren and Ming-Kong Zhang and Juncheng Qian and Shuangquan Li and Jingxu Wang and Jun Du},
  title = {{Analyzing Spatio-Temporal Change in Ecosystem Quality and Its Driving Mechanism in Henan Province, China, from 2010 to 2020}},
  booktitle = {Sustainability},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.3390/su141811742},
}
Figure