Analytical optimal solutions of impulsive out-of-plane rendezvous around elliptic orbits

Romain Serra, Denis Arzelier, Aude Rondepierre, Calvet, Jean-LouisHAL 2014

TL;DR

This paper presents a comprehensive analytical solution for the challenging problem of minimizing fuel consumption for spacecraft rendezvous maneuvers in elliptical orbits, specifically addressing out-of-plane movements. By developing a detailed primer vector theory, the authors provide a framework that can be directly implemented for autonomous spacecraft operations.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Achieving autonomous rendezvous between spacecraft is crucial for future space missions, especially for complex maneuvers like those involving highly elliptical orbits. Traditional methods often rely on approximations or numerical simulations, which can be computationally intensive and less suitable for onboard implementation. This paper tackles the specific challenge of time-fixed, minimum-fuel, impulsive, out-of-plane rendezvous around elliptical orbits. The "out-of-plane" aspect adds significant complexity compared to in-plane maneuvers, and the "elliptic" nature of the orbits means the relative motion is not as straightforward as in circular orbits. The goal is to find an analytical solution that is both optimal in terms of fuel usage and simple enough for real-time spacecraft control.

Methods

The core of the paper's methodology lies in the primer vector theory. This theory, rooted in optimal control, uses a "primer vector" to determine the optimal timing and direction of impulsive thrusts (instantaneous velocity changes) to achieve a rendezvous with minimal fuel.

Here's a breakdown of their approach:

  • Linearized Dynamics: The complex non-linear dynamics of orbital mechanics are linearized around the reference orbit. This simplification allows for a more tractable mathematical analysis.
  • Impulsive Maneuvers: The paper assumes that thrust is applied instantaneously, meaning the spacecraft's position doesn't change during a burn, only its velocity. This is a common and useful approximation for many rendezvous scenarios.
  • Primer Vector Analysis: The authors derive and analyze the dynamics of the primer vector. This involves finding its local extrema and understanding how its behavior relates to the optimality conditions.
  • Lagrange Multipliers: A Lagrange multiplier rule is applied to formulate the optimization problem, leading to a set of necessary and sufficient conditions for optimality.
  • Case-by-Case Solution: Due to the complexity of the problem, the authors systematically break down the solution into various cases based on the duration of the rendezvous, initial and final orbital positions, and the target displacement vector. Each case leads to specific conditions for the number of impulses, their locations, and their magnitudes.
  • Analytical Derivations: The paper emphasizes deriving closed-form analytical solutions for each scenario, avoiding purely numerical approaches.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The paper focuses on theoretical derivations and presents a numerical example based on the PROBA-3 mission parameters.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Analytical Tractability of Out-of-Plane Elliptic Rendezvous: The paper demonstrates that, despite its complexity, the out-of-plane Keplerian relative dynamics in an elliptic orbit can indeed yield analytical solutions for optimal impulsive rendezvous. This is a significant theoretical advancement.
  • Primer Vector as the Key: The primer vector is shown to be the central element for determining optimal impulsive maneuvers. Its properties directly dictate the optimal thrust strategies.
  • Richness of Optimal Solutions: The problem exhibits a wide variety of optimal solutions depending on the rendezvous parameters. This includes scenarios with one, two, or even multiple impulses, highlighting the nuanced nature of optimal trajectory design.
  • Importance of Rendezvous Duration and Initial/Final Conditions: The paper clearly shows how the duration of the rendezvous (de), and the initial (θ₀) and final (θf) true anomalies, along with the target relative position (zf), critically influence the optimal strategy.
  • Foundation for Autonomy: By providing analytical solutions, the paper lays the groundwork for developing autonomous guidance systems that can compute optimal rendezvous maneuvers onboard spacecraft without relying on extensive ground-based computation.

Key Results

The paper provides a comprehensive set of analytical solutions for the time-fixed, minimum-fuel, impulsive, out-of-plane rendezvous problem around elliptic orbits. These solutions are categorized based on various conditions, specifying:

  • Number of Impulses: Solutions can involve 1, 2, or potentially more impulses.
  • Impulse Locations and Magnitudes: Explicit formulas are given for the optimal timing (θᵢ) and velocity changes (ΔVᵢ) of these impulses.
  • Optimal Lagrange Multipliers and Primer Vector: The paper defines the associated Lagrange multipliers and the primer vector for each optimal solution.
  • Numerical Example (PROBA-3 Mission): A realistic example based on the PROBA-3 mission demonstrates the application of the derived solutions. For this example, a 3-impulse solution was found to be optimal, with a total fuel cost of 0.8624 m/s. The paper also visualizes the optimal trajectory and primer vector for this case.

Limitations and Future Work

Limitations:

  • Linearized Dynamics: The analysis is based on linearized dynamics. While this is a standard and effective approximation for close-proximity rendezvous, it may become less accurate for larger separation distances or highly non-Keplerian dynamics.
  • Impulsive Thrust Assumption: The paper assumes impulsive thrusts, which are instantaneous. Real thrusters have finite burn times, and this simplification might not capture all nuances of continuous thrust maneuvers.
  • Out-of-Plane Focus: While the paper addresses out-of-plane maneuvers, it primarily focuses on the linearized dynamics. Extending this to non-linear out-of-plane dynamics could be a future direction.

Future Work:

  • Continuous Thrust: Extending the analytical framework to handle continuous thrust maneuvers would be a valuable next step, providing more realistic solutions.
  • Non-linear Dynamics: Investigating the problem under full non-linear orbital dynamics would enhance the applicability of the solutions.
  • Onboard Implementation: The authors suggest that the analytical solutions pave the way for onboard implementation, implying future work on developing and testing these algorithms in real-time control systems.
  • Other Orbit Types: While focused on elliptic orbits, exploring similar analytical solutions for other complex orbital regimes could be beneficial.

Summary updated

Abstract

International audience
BibTeX
@inproceedings{serra2014analytical,
  author = {Romain Serra and Denis Arzelier and Aude Rondepierre and Calvet, Jean-Louis},
  title = {{Analytical optimal solutions of impulsive out-of-plane rendezvous around elliptic orbits}},
  booktitle = {HAL},
  year = {2014},
}
Figure