Analysis on the Tourism Competitiveness of Five Central Asian Countries Based on Diamond Model

Jie XuProceedings of the 3rd International Seminar on Education Innovation and Economic Management (SEIEM 2018) 2019 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper analyzes the tourism competitiveness of five Central Asian countries using Porter's Diamond Model, revealing significant potential hindered by underdeveloped infrastructure and insufficient foreign investment. The authors propose strategies for enhancing cultural tourism, improving infrastructure, and fostering regional cooperation to build a unified "Silk Road" tourism brand.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Central Asian countries possess rich natural and cultural heritage, yet their tourism industries lag significantly in global competitiveness. This paper addresses the question of why this is the case and how these countries can improve their tourism sector's standing. The authors highlight that despite the region's potential for complementary tourism offerings and its strategic location along the historical Silk Road, its tourism industry is not performing as well as it could. The paper aims to identify the specific factors limiting this competitiveness and suggest actionable solutions.

Methods

The core methodology employed is Porter's Diamond Model. This framework analyzes the international competitiveness of an industry within a country by examining four interconnected determinants:

  1. Factor Conditions: The availability and quality of production factors (natural resources, labor, capital, infrastructure).
  2. Demand Conditions: The nature of domestic demand for the industry's products and services.
  3. Related and Supporting Industries: The presence and strength of supplier industries and related sectors.
  4. Firm Strategy, Structure, and Rivalry: The way companies are created, organized, and managed, and the nature of domestic competition.

In addition to these four, the model also considers two external factors:

  1. Government: The role of government policies and support.
  2. Opportunity: Uncontrollable external factors like global trends and economic conditions.

The authors apply this model to analyze the tourism competitiveness of Kazakhstan, Kyrgyzstan, Tajikistan, Turkmenistan, and Uzbekistan, drawing on existing reports and data.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The analysis relies on existing reports (e.g., World Economic Forum's Tourism Competitiveness Report) and general economic and geographical information about the five Central Asian countries.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Untapped Potential: The five Central Asian countries possess a unique blend of natural landscapes (deserts, mountains, steppes) and rich historical/cultural heritage, offering significant complementary tourism potential.
  • Infrastructure Gap: A major bottleneck is the underdeveloped infrastructure across all five countries, including transportation (air, ground, port), tourist services, and ICT readiness. Even the most competitive country, Kazakhstan, faces high transportation costs.
  • Limited Human Capital: There's a shortage of skilled tourism industry employees and high-quality personnel, exacerbated by relatively weak domestic educational support for the sector.
  • Demand Fluctuations: While domestic tourism demand has seen growth due to economic development, it's closely tied to economic stability, which has been challenged by inflation and slowing growth in recent years.
  • Regional Disparities: There's a significant difference in tourism competitiveness among the five countries, with Kazakhstan leading and others like Uzbekistan and Turkmenistan not even appearing on global rankings.
  • "Silk Road" Opportunity: The "Belt and Road Initiative" and similar global plans present a significant opportunity for these countries to collaborate and develop a unified tourism brand.
  • Need for Unified Strategy: Currently, each country has its own tourism focus, but there's a lack of integrated planning and development of scenic spots and routes across the region.

Key Results

  • Low Global Rankings: Table I shows that among the five countries, Kazakhstan consistently ranks highest (around 80-90), while Kyrgyzstan and Tajikistan are much lower (around 100-120), with Uzbekistan and Turkmenistan not appearing on the World Economic Forum's Tourism Competitiveness Report.
  • Resource Ranking: Table II indicates that while natural resources are generally strong (Kazakhstan: 92, Kyrgyzstan: 104, Tajikistan: 80), cultural resources and business travel infrastructure are weaker.
  • Infrastructure Challenges: Table III highlights low rankings in tourism-related industries, particularly air transport infrastructure (Kazakhstan: 71, Kyrgyzstan: 115, Tajikistan: 92) and tourist service infrastructure (Kazakhstan: 97, Kyrgyzstan: 128, Tajikistan: 130).
  • Economic Impact: The paper notes that despite periods of rapid economic growth (over 8%), recent years have seen slower growth and economic challenges, impacting domestic tourism demand.

Limitations and Future Work

Limitations: * The paper relies on existing reports and general data, lacking in-depth primary research or specific quantitative data for all indicators across all five countries. * The analysis of "Demand Conditions" is somewhat generalized, especially regarding the impact of recent economic slowdowns. * The paper acknowledges that the "Diamond Model" is a static snapshot and doesn't fully capture the dynamic evolution of competitiveness.

Future Work: * The authors strongly advocate for enhanced cultural attraction of tourism products, suggesting reconstruction of high-quality, mutually beneficial routes. * They propose building a unified "Silk Road" tourism brand through mutual trust and cooperation, emphasizing internal integration and complementary advantages. * Specific recommendations include improving the business environment, formulating comprehensive tourism development plans, and abolishing local protectionist policies. * Externally, they suggest establishing cooperation and coordination mechanisms for interest distribution, heritage protection, cross-regional development, and currency circulation. * The paper also points to the need for introducing more foreign investment by offering preferential measures in visas, taxes, and trade to improve the tourism industry chain. * The implementation of a unified visa zone (starting with Kazakhstan and Uzbekistan) is seen as a crucial step towards regional integration.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@inproceedings{xu2019analysis,
  author = {Jie Xu},
  title = {{Analysis on the Tourism Competitiveness of Five Central Asian Countries Based on Diamond Model}},
  booktitle = {Proceedings of the 3rd International Seminar on Education Innovation and Economic Management (SEIEM 2018)},
  year = {2019},
  doi = {10.2991/seiem-18.2019.147},
}
Figure