Abstract
The environmental pollution caused by the production and operation of enterprises has gained significant attention in recent years, necessitating a balance between economic development and environmental protection. This paper explores the connotation of environmental performance evaluation (EPE) through the lens of ecological ethics, focusing on listed companies in Jilin Province. By analyzing the environmental disclosures of 20 heavy-pollution enterprises from 2013 to 2015, we identify critical gaps in transparency and standardization. The study concludes with targeted suggestions for government and enterprise stakeholders to promote sustainable economic and social development.
Introduction: The Economic Moral Man
As industrial production scales, the friction between economic development and environmental preservation intensifies. In both academic and corporate spheres, there is a growing shift toward viewing the environment as a "stakeholder." This shift gives rise to the concept of the "economic moral man"—an enterprise that balances profit-seeking with ecological duty. However, evaluating how well a company actually performs environmentally remains a significant challenge due to the lack of standardized evaluation systems.
Theoretical Framework: Ecological Ethics and EPE
Environmental Performance Evaluation (EPE) is not merely a technical exercise but a moral one. Grounded in ecological ethics, EPE assesses an organization's management of its environmental aspects. We break down EPE into four key dimensions:
- Clean Production: Analyzing the life cycle of production, from raw material procurement to energy efficiency.
- Green Management: Evaluating the integration of environmental protection into corporate strategy and marketing.
- Saving Resources: Monitoring the consumption and recycling rates of raw materials.
- Protecting the Environment: Measuring direct investment in environmental training, equipment, and pollution treatment.
Methodology and Data
This study focuses on a specific subset of the 40 listed companies in Jilin Province as of March 2017. We identified 20 companies operating in "heavy pollution" industries—including biological medicine, metallurgy, and electricity—based on the Environmental Information Disclosure Guide for Listed Companies. Notable entities analyzed include Faw Car, Jilin Chemical Fiber, Tonghua Dongbao, and Jien Nickel Industry. The research audited corporate filings, annual reports, and Social Responsibility Reports (SRRs) spanning the 2013–2015 period.
Key Findings in Environmental Performance
Our analysis revealed a significant disparity in how companies approach environmental responsibility and disclosure.
The Transparency Gap
A critical observation is the "selecting tendency" in corporate reporting. Companies often exhibit a bias toward disclosing positive environmental news while omitting or glossing over negative impacts. This leads to a subjective and incomplete picture of performance. Furthermore, only 5 out of the 20 heavy-pollution companies (25%) released dedicated Social Responsibility Reports. The remaining 15 buried environmental data within general annual reports, complicating stakeholder analysis.
Case-Specific Performance
- Faw Car: Emerged as a relatively strong performer in terms of infrastructure, treating over 1.4 million tons of sewage in 2013 and meeting national secondary discharge standards.
- Tonghua Dongbao: Demonstrated a commitment to transparency by reporting specific costs for pollution discharge (approx. 200,000 yuan) and environmental protection (245,000 yuan) in 2013.
- Yatai Company: Showed significant fluctuations in pollution discharge expenditures, which peaked at 16.57 million yuan in 2014 before dropping sharply to 1.48 million yuan in 2015, suggesting inconsistent management or reporting practices.
Challenges and Limitations
The primary hurdle to effective EPE is the lack of a regulated, mandatory "environment accountancy" system. Without standardized criteria, the data provided by companies (e.g., tons of sewage treated) is often not directly comparable, rendering regional benchmarking nearly impossible. Additionally, because current reports are largely self-reported and lack third-party verification, they remain highly susceptible to corporate bias.
Recommendations and Conclusion
To bridge the gap between economic growth and ecological health, coordinated action is required:
- Government Action: The Ministry of Finance and environmental departments must collaborate to create a unified theoretical and regulatory framework for environment accountancy. Mandatory disclosure standards would reduce subjectivity and improve data comparability.
- Enterprise Innovation: Companies must shift their culture from "profit-first" to "ecological-benefit-first." This involves technological innovation to reduce the costs of environmental governance while achieving social profits.
Until environmental performance is treated with the same legal and accounting rigor as financial performance, the goal of sustainable development will remain elusive. This study underscores the need for a fundamental change in how corporate success is measured and reported in Jilin Province and beyond.
Summary updated