Analysis on Spatial Pattern and Driving Factors of Carbon Emission in Urban–Rural Fringe Mixed-Use Communities: Cases Study in East Asia

Xiaoqing Zhu, Tiancheng Zhang, Weijun Gao, Danying MeiSustainability 2020 · DOI

TL;DR

This study analyzes the spatial patterns and drivers of carbon emissions in urban-rural fringe mixed-use communities across East Asia. It reveals that industrial communities are the biggest emitters, driven primarily by material and energy consumption, and offers planning recommendations for reducing these emissions.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Urban areas are major contributors to greenhouse gas emissions, but the rapidly developing urban-rural fringe areas, often characterized by mixed-use communities, are also significant emitters, sometimes even exceeding urban centers. These fringe areas are experiencing rapid urbanization and industrialization, leading to complex patterns of land use and economic activity. Understanding the specific spatial distribution and underlying causes of carbon emissions in these unique mixed-use environments is crucial for developing effective low-carbon development strategies. The paper aims to fill this gap by analyzing these emissions and their driving factors in East Asian urban-rural fringe communities.

Methods

The study employs a multi-faceted approach:

  • Emission Factor (EF) Method: Carbon emissions are calculated using the IPCC's emission factor method, accounting for production, ecology, and space-related emissions.
  • Statistical Information Grid (STING) Method: This method is used to divide the study area into comparable spatial units for data collection and analysis, enabling a detailed examination of spatial patterns.
  • Geographic Information Systems (GIS): GIS is utilized for spatial analysis, visualizing emission patterns, and understanding their distribution across the landscape.
  • Partial Least Squares (PLS) Regression: This statistical technique is employed to explore the relationships between various driving factors (established space, industrial economy, material consumption, and social behavior) and carbon emission distribution. PLS is chosen for its ability to handle multiple independent variables and multicollinearity.

Datasets

The study utilizes data from 20 mixed-use communities across East Asia, specifically in China (including Taiwan), Japan, and Korea. These communities are categorized into four types based on their leading industries: industrial, commercial, tourism, and rental-apartment. The data used for analysis includes statistical information from yearbooks, field surveys, and estimated data, as well as geographic and spatial data processed through GIS and RS technologies.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Urban-rural fringes are emission hotspots: These areas face significant pressure to reduce emissions, with emissions in later stages of urbanization being lower than in earlier stages, suggesting some progress in mitigation efforts.
  • Industrial communities are the biggest polluters: These communities, along with rental-apartment communities, contribute the most to carbon emissions compared to commercial and tourism-focused ones.
  • Material and energy consumption are key drivers: The study highlights that fuel consumption per unit of land is the most significant factor influencing carbon emission spatial distribution, underscoring the importance of resource efficiency.
  • Spatial planning matters: The spatial distribution of emissions is strongly influenced by planning decisions, including road networks, infrastructure placement, and industrial linkages, indicating that thoughtful urban design can mitigate emissions.
  • Regional sinks are crucial: A significant portion of carbon emissions can be absorbed within the region, primarily by green spaces, emphasizing the role of ecological infrastructure in carbon management.

Key Results

  • The average carbon emission for the studied mixed-use communities is 25,511.51 tons/year, with individual units varying significantly.
  • Carbon emissions per capita are 3.8 tons/year, with developed regions showing higher emissions than mature ones, suggesting an environmental Kuznets curve effect.
  • PLS regression analysis identified several key driving factors for carbon emissions. The most influential factors (VIP > 1) include fuel energy consumption per unit of land, electricity consumption per unit of land, built-up density, floor area ratio, and employment-to-living ratio.
  • Industrial communities exhibit high carbon emissions and strong linkages, often with spatially concentrated emission patterns, while innovative communities may show more dispersed patterns.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge that the study is limited by the data processing, which may lead to some deviations in the analysis results. The focus was primarily on the spatial dimension of carbon emissions, and they suggest that future work should further explore the temporal dimension to provide a more comprehensive understanding. Additionally, the reliance on processed data means that the carbon emission values might not be perfectly consistent with the actual situation.

Summary updated

Abstract

Urban-intensive areas are responsible for an estimated 80% of greenhouse gas emissions, particularly carbon dioxide. The urban–rural fringe areas emit more greenhouse gases than urban centers. The purpose of this study is to analyze the spatial pattern and driving factors of carbon emissions in urban–rural fringe mixed-use communities, and to develop planning methods to reduce carbon emissions in communities. This study identifies mixed-use communities in East Asian urban–rural fringe areas as industrial, commercial, tourism, and rental-apartment communities, subsequently using the emission factor method to calculate carbon emissions. The statistical information grid analysis and geographic information systems spatial analysis method are employed to analyze the spatial pattern of carbon emission and explore the relationship between established space, industrial economy, material consumption, social behavior, and carbon emission distribution characteristics by partial least squares regression, ultimately summing up the spatial pattern of carbon emission in the urban–rural fringe areas of East Asia. Results show that (1) mixed-use communities in the East Asian urban–rural fringe areas face tremendous pressure to reduce emissions. Mixed-use community carbon emissions in the late urbanization period are lower than those the early urbanization. (2) Mixed-use community carbon emission is featured by characteristics, such as planning structure decisiveness, road directionality, infrastructure directionality, and industrial linkage. (3) Industrial communities produce the highest carbon emissions, followed by rental-apartment communities, business communities, and tourism communities. (4) The driving factor that most affects the spatial distribution of carbon emissions is the material energy consumption. The fuel consumption per unit of land is the largest driver of carbon emissions. Using the obtained spatial pattern and its driving factors of carbon emissions, this study provides suggestions for planning and construction, industrial development, material consumption, and convenient life guidance.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{zhu2020analysis,
  author = {Xiaoqing Zhu and Tiancheng Zhang and Weijun Gao and Danying Mei},
  title = {{Analysis on Spatial Pattern and Driving Factors of Carbon Emission in Urban–Rural Fringe Mixed-Use Communities: Cases Study in East Asia}},
  booktitle = {Sustainability},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.3390/su12083101},
}
Figure