Analysis on Practical Photon Counting Receiver in Optical Scattering Communication

Difan Zou, Chen Gong, Zhengyuan XuarXiv 2017 · OpenReview

Abstract

We characterize the practical photon-counting receiver in optical scattering communication with finite sampling rate and electrical noise. In the receiver side, the detected signal can be characterized as a series of pulses generated by photon-multiplier (PMT) detector and held by the pulse-holding circuits, which are then sampled by the analog-to-digit convertor (ADC) with finite sampling rate and counted by a rising-edge pulse detector. However, the finite small pulse width incurs the dead time effect that may lead to sub-Poisson distribution on the recorded pulses. We analyze first-order and second-order moments on the number of recorded pulses with finite sampling rate at the receiver side under two cases where the sampling period is shorter than or equal to the pulse width as well as longer than the pulse width. Moreover, we adopt the maximum likelihood (ML) detection. In order to simplify the analysis, we adopt binomial distribution approximation on the number of recorded pulses in each slot. A tractable holding time and decision threshold selection rule is provided aiming to maximize the minimal Kullback-Leibler (KL) distance between the two distributions. The performance of proposed sub-Poisson distribution and the binomial approximation are verified by the experimental results. The equivalent arrival rate and holding time predicted by the of sub-Poisson model and the associated proposed binomial distribution on finite sampling rate and the electrical noise are validated by the simulation results. The proposed the holding time and decision threshold selection rule performs close to the optimal one.

Introduction

In optical scattering communication, particularly in non-line-of-sight (NLOS) ultraviolet links, signals are often extremely weak, requiring receivers to count individual photons. Traditional information theory typically models these arrivals using an ideal Poisson distribution. However, real-world hardware introduces significant distortions. Physical constraints such as finite sampling rates in Analog-to-Digital Converters (ADCs) and electrical noise (shot and thermal) create a "dead time effect." This effect causes pulses to merge, leading to counting losses and a shift from a Poisson to a sub-Poisson distribution, where the variance is lower than the mean. This paper addresses the lack of practical models that account for these hardware-induced distortions to optimize communication performance.

Practical Receiver Architecture

The receiver chain consists of several critical stages that transform incoming photons into a digital count. As shown in Figure 1, the process begins with a Photomultiplier Tube (PMT) detector, which is susceptible to shot and thermal noise. The resulting electrical pulses are processed by pulse-holding circuits, which stretch the pulse width to a specific "holding time."

Block diagram of a practical photon-counting receiver illustrating the hardware chain and associated noise/constraints.

Following the holding circuit, the signal is sampled by an ADC with a finite sampling rate. Finally, a rising-edge detector applies a 0-1 decision threshold to distinguish valid pulses from noise, outputting the final photon count. The interaction between the pulse width (holding time) and the ADC sampling period is a primary driver of the dead time effect.

Statistical Modeling and Approximation

To characterize this system, the authors performed a moment analysis, deriving the mean and variance of recorded pulse counts. They considered two scenarios: when the sampling period $T$ is shorter than or equal to the pulse width $ au$, and when it is longer.

A key finding is that finite sampling rates effectively "stretch" the system's dead time. For instance, if $T < \tau$, the effective dead time increases from $ au$ to approximately $ au + T/2$. To make signal detection mathematically tractable for Maximum Likelihood (ML) detection, the authors proposed a binomial distribution approximation. This model serves as a superior proxy to the standard Poisson model because it naturally accounts for the physical upper limit on the number of pulses detectable within a given time window due to dead time.

Parameter Optimization and Results

The study provides a tractable selection rule for hardware parameters, specifically the holding time and the decision threshold. The goal is to maximize the Kullback-Leibler (KL) distance between the distributions for "0" and "1" bits, thereby minimizing the Bit Error Rate (BER).

Key insights from the experimental and simulation results include:

  • The $\tau = T$ Rule: Setting the circuit holding time equal to the sampling period is shown to be a near-optimal strategy, simplifying hardware design.
  • Threshold Robustness: BER performance remains stable over a relatively wide range of voltage thresholds, indicating system robustness.
  • Model Validation: The proposed sub-Poisson and binomial models showed an excellent fit with experimental data from a 100MHz ADC testbed, whereas the standard Poisson model failed at higher photon intensities.

Conclusion

This research bridges the gap between theoretical photon-counting models and practical hardware implementation. By accounting for finite sampling and electrical noise, the proposed binomial approximation and optimization rules offer a robust framework for improving NLOS optical communication. Future work may extend these characterizations to higher-order modulation schemes like Pulse Position Modulation (PPM) and explore performance in high-background radiation environments.

Summary updated

Abstract

We characterize the practical photon-counting receiver in optical scattering communication with finite sampling rate and electrical noise. In the receiver side, the detected signal can be characterized as a series of pulses generated by photon-multiplier (PMT) detector and held by the pulse-holding circuits, which are then sampled by the analog-to-digit convertor (ADC) with finite sampling rate and counted by a rising-edge pulse detector. However, the finite small pulse width incurs the dead time effect that may lead to sub-Poisson distribution on the recorded pulses. We analyze first-order and second-order moments on the number of recorded pulses with finite sampling rate at the receiver side under two cases where the sampling period is shorter than or equal to the pulse width as well as longer than the pulse width. Moreover, we adopt the maximum likelihood (ML) detection. In order to simplify the analysis, we adopt binomial distribution approximation on the number of recorded pulses in each slot. A tractable holding time and decision threshold selection rule is provided aiming to maximize the minimal Kullback-Leibler (KL) distance between the two distributions. The performance of proposed sub-Poisson distribution and the binomial approximation are verified by the experimental results. The equivalent arrival rate and holding time predicted by the of sub-Poisson model and the associated proposed binomial distribution on finite sampling rate and the electrical noise are validated by the simulation results. The proposed the holding time and decision threshold selection rule performs close to the optimal one.
BibTeX
@misc{zou2017analysis,
  author = {Difan Zou and Chen Gong and Zhengyuan Xu},
  title = {{Analysis on Practical Photon Counting Receiver in Optical Scattering Communication}},
  year = {2017},
  eprint = {1702.06633},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/1702.06633},
}
Figure