Analysis of Vibration Characteristics of Viscoelastic Slurry Pipe Considering Fluid–Structure Interaction Effects

Wenjing Hu, Jianyong Hu, Huijie Zhang, Xiujun Hu, Rui Kong, Kai Peng, DeLei Yu, Junlai MaoWater 2025 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper investigates the vibration characteristics of viscoelastic slurry pipes, focusing on the crucial impact of fluid-structure interaction (FSI). Using a 3D finite element model, the study reveals that FSI significantly reduces natural frequencies, disrupts vibration mode symmetry, and is a dominant factor compared to simple water-attached effects. The findings offer valuable insights for designing safer and more efficient slurry transport systems.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Slurry pipes, often made of viscoelastic materials like polyethylene, are essential for hydraulic excavation and material transport. During operation, these pipes are subjected to dynamic forces from slurry flow, pump startup/shutdown, and potential water hammer events. These forces can induce vibrations, which, if they resonate with the pipe's natural frequencies, can lead to amplified vibrations, increased wear, and even structural damage. A key challenge is understanding how the interaction between the flowing slurry (fluid) and the pipe wall (structure) affects these natural frequencies. While previous research has explored FSI in various pipe systems, there's a need for a detailed analysis specifically for viscoelastic slurry pipes, considering factors like pipe length and wall thickness, which are critical for practical engineering design.

Methods

The researchers employed a three-dimensional finite element method (FEM) to construct a comprehensive FSI model of a viscoelastic slurry pipe. This model allowed them to systematically analyze the vibration characteristics under different conditions.

  • FSI Modeling: The core of the methodology involved coupling the fluid dynamics (governed by Navier-Stokes equations with a realizable k-ε turbulence model) and the structural dynamics of the pipe. The fluid-structure interface was handled by ensuring conservation of stress and displacement.
  • Modal Analysis: To determine the natural vibration characteristics, a modal analysis was performed. This involved solving the equation of motion for free vibrations, considering both the "dry" modal analysis (pipe only) and "wet" modal analysis (incorporating fluid effects).
  • Parametric Studies: The study systematically varied key parameters to understand their influence:
  • Fluid Effects: Comparing the empty pipe, pipe with water-attached effects, pipe with FSI, and pipe with both FSI and water-attached effects.
  • Pipe Length: Analyzing pipes of 1 m, 2 m, and 3 m.
  • Wall Thickness: Investigating pipes with wall thicknesses of 5 mm, 7 mm, 9 mm, and 11 mm.
  • Model Validation: The FEM model's accuracy was validated by comparing its results for an empty pipe with those obtained from the Timoshenko beam theory, showing good agreement with small relative errors.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study relies on numerical simulations using established physical parameters for slurry and polyethylene pipes.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • FSI is the Dominant Factor: Fluid-structure interaction (FSI) has a far more significant impact on reducing natural frequencies than simply considering the "water-attached" effect (i.e., the added mass of the fluid without dynamic interaction). FSI can reduce frequencies by up to 54%.
  • Symmetry Disruption: FSI effectively breaks the frequency degeneracy observed in empty pipes. This phenomenon, where different vibration modes share the same frequency due to geometric symmetry, is eliminated by the fluid's dynamic influence, altering the mass distribution and vibration modes.
  • Odd vs. Even Mode Differences: The "water-attached" effect shows a distinct behavior between odd and even vibration orders. Odd orders experience a greater frequency reduction (45-55%) compared to even orders (37-39%). This is attributed to the antagonistic fluid inertia forces in the symmetric bending modes of even orders, which partially offset each other.
  • Non-Linear Superposition: When both FSI and water-attached effects are considered together, the combined frequency reduction is not a simple sum of individual effects. The coupling between these phenomena leads to a non-linear interaction, where the actual reduction is less than the theoretical superposition, suggesting a partial cancellation of the added mass effect.
  • Length's Diminishing Returns: As pipe length increases, the rate of natural frequency growth slows down significantly. Longer pipes exhibit a more drastic reduction in natural frequency, particularly for lower-order modes, due to a decrease in the stiffness-to-mass ratio.
  • Thickness's Gradual Impact: Increasing wall thickness consistently raises natural frequencies. However, the rate of frequency improvement diminishes with greater thickness, indicating that the stiffness enhancement effect becomes less pronounced. While absolute frequency increases are substantial for higher orders, the relative growth pattern remains similar across orders.

Key Results

  • Frequency Reduction: FSI reduced natural frequencies by approximately 54% across orders, while water-attached effects reduced them by 37-55% (varying with odd/even orders).
  • Pipe Length Impact: For a 1m pipe, the frequency difference between the first and sixth orders was 119.51 Hz. For a 3m pipe, this difference was reduced to 31.69 Hz, a 26.52% growth rate compared to the shorter pipe.
  • Wall Thickness Impact: For the first-order natural frequency, the growth rate decreased from 15.43% (5mm to 7mm) to 7.44% (9mm to 11mm). The absolute increase in the sixth-order frequency from 5mm to 11mm was 12.48 Hz, significantly more than the 1.97 Hz increase for the first order.
  • Amplitude Behavior: Lower-order natural frequencies tend to exhibit larger deformation amplitudes, indicating that the fluid is more likely to induce significant vibrations at these frequencies.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Limitations:
    • The study focuses on a specific type of viscoelastic pipe (PE) and a single slurry density.
  • The analysis is based on a numerical model; experimental validation for all scenarios would strengthen the findings.
  • The paper does not explicitly discuss the impact of external excitation frequencies, though it mentions this as a potential control parameter.
  • Future Work:
    • The authors suggest that in practical engineering, if external excitation frequencies can be adjusted, resonance can be avoided without modifying the pipe.
  • If excitation frequencies cannot be adjusted (e.g., with fixed-speed pumps), optimizing pipe structural design (stiffness or mass) to alter natural frequencies is recommended.
  • The research lays a foundation for developing more efficient and stable mud transportation technologies. Further work could explore a wider range of slurry properties, pipe materials, and operational conditions.

Summary updated

Abstract

To study the vibration characteristics of viscoelastic slurry pipe structures under fluid–structure interaction (FSI), we constructed a three-dimensional FSI pipe model based on the finite element method to systematically investigate the effects of fluid effects, pipe length, and wall thickness on the vibrational characteristics of viscoelastic slurry pipes. A modal analysis demonstrated that fluid effects not only significantly reduced the natural frequency of the pipe but also disrupted the symmetry of the vibration modes and eliminated the phenomenon of frequency degeneracy. The frequency reduction caused by FSI reached 54%, which was dominant compared with the water-attached effects, and its impact intensified with the increasing vibration order. The water-attached effect exhibited differences between odd and even orders, attributed to the influence of vibration modes on the distribution of fluid inertial forces, with a contribution of 45.07% to 55.24% in the odd orders and of only 37.69% to 38.93% in the even orders. When the FSI and water-attached effects acted together, the frequency reduction was further aggravated, but the reduction ratio did not follow a simple linear superposition. The parametric analysis of the pipe showed that when the pipe length increased from 1 m to 3 m, the growth rate of its natural frequency was only 26.52% that of the shorter pipe, indicating that the longer the pipes, the slower the growth rate of frequency. When the wall thickness increased from 5 mm to 11 mm, the growth rate of the first-order natural frequency decreased from 15.43% to 7.44%, suggesting that the frequency improvement effect caused by the stiffness augmentation diminished with the increase in wall thickness. The research results hold significant guiding significance for the structural design of slurry pipe systems in practical engineering and the safe operation of pipe systems.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{hu2025analysis,
  author = {Wenjing Hu and Jianyong Hu and Huijie Zhang and Xiujun Hu and Rui Kong and Kai Peng and DeLei Yu and Junlai Mao},
  title = {{Analysis of Vibration Characteristics of Viscoelastic Slurry Pipe Considering Fluid–Structure Interaction Effects}},
  booktitle = {Water},
  year = {2025},
  doi = {10.3390/w17172554},
}
Figure