TL;DR
This study analyzes how the COVID-19 pandemic reshaped the tourism market structure and its driving factors in two Chinese small cities, Dengfeng and Kaifeng, using digital footprint data from online travel diaries. It reveals shifts in temporal and spatial tourist distribution and identifies key factors influencing these changes, offering insights for post-pandemic tourism recovery strategies.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
The COVID-19 pandemic has profoundly impacted the global tourism industry, forcing a re-evaluation of tourism markets and recovery strategies. While much research has focused on large, well-known cities, the unique characteristics of smaller cities—such as simpler tourism offerings, resource homogeneity, and smaller market scales—mean that recovery strategies for larger cities may not be directly applicable. This paper addresses this gap by specifically examining the impact of the pandemic on the tourist market structure and its driving factors in two Chinese small cities, Dengfeng and Kaifeng. The goal is to understand how the pandemic altered tourist behavior and to propose targeted measures for their tourism recovery.
Methods
The research employed a multi-faceted approach to analyze tourist market structure and driving factors:
- Data Collection: Digital footprint data was gathered from online travel diaries sourced from platforms like Qunar, Ctrip, and Mafengwo.
- Spatio-Temporal Database Construction: Collected data was cleaned to remove errors and logical inconsistencies, forming a database for analysis.
- Time Characteristics Analysis:
- Time Concentration Index: This metric was used to quantify the temporal distribution concentration of tourist flow within each month, indicating the degree of seasonality and the difference between peak and off-peak seasons.
- Time Series Graphs: Visualized the temporal fluctuations of tourist flow over time to identify trends and seasonality.
- Spatial Characteristics Analysis:
- Geographic Concentration Index: Measured the spatial distribution concentration of tourist flow across different regions.
- Natural Breakpoint Method: Used to classify tourist market structures into different levels (core, sub-core, middle, marginal) based on tourist flow intensity.
- Driving Factors Analysis: Employed the "push-pull" theory to identify factors influencing tourist market structure.
- Temporal Heterogeneity: Analyzed the influence of leisure time and climate comfort (using the moisture-temperature index).
- Spatial Heterogeneity: Analyzed the influence of region traffic (actual and perceived distance) and residents' income level.
Datasets
The study utilized a dataset of 557 valid online travel diaries collected from January 2015 to December 2021. This data was sourced from major Chinese travel websites: Qunar, Ctrip, and Mafengwo. The data represents a digital footprint of tourist activities, capturing travel time and trajectories. No new benchmarks were introduced; rather, existing online travel diary data was leveraged.
Key Insights and Ideas
- Pandemic's Dual Impact on Seasonality: While the pandemic generally increased the concentration of tourist flow in both cities (suggesting a tendency towards more focused travel periods), it also widened the gap between peak and off-peak seasons. This implies that while travel might be more concentrated, the traditional off-season challenges remain or are exacerbated.
- Divergent Spatial Concentration Trends: Interestingly, Dengfeng saw a decrease in spatial concentration of its tourist market after the pandemic, while Kaifeng experienced an increase. This suggests different recovery patterns, possibly linked to their distinct tourism offerings (Dengfeng's strong cultural heritage vs. Kaifeng's humanistic landscape).
- Weakening of Traditional Drivers: The study found that the influence of leisure time, climate comfort, and residents' income level on tourist flow weakened post-pandemic. This is a significant shift, indicating that other factors (like safety concerns, travel restrictions, or the rise of self-driving tours) became more dominant.
- Resilience of Region Traffic: Despite the weakening of other factors, region traffic (distance and travel time) remained a significant driver, highlighting the continued importance of accessibility and convenience, especially for shorter, more localized trips.
- Shift Towards Self-Driving and Indoor Tourism: The paper suggests that increased sensitivity to personal space and a desire for safety likely contributed to the rise of self-driving tours and the need for special indoor tourism projects, especially for leisure and sightseeing.
Key Results
- Temporal Concentration: The time concentration index increased in both Dengfeng and Kaifeng after COVID-19, indicating a more concentrated temporal distribution of tourists.
- Spatial Concentration: Dengfeng's geographic concentration index decreased post-pandemic, while Kaifeng's increased.
- Driving Factors:
- Before COVID-19: Climate comfort and residents' income level showed significant positive correlations with tourist flow in both cities. Region traffic (actual and perceived distance) showed significant negative correlations.
- After COVID-19: The correlations for climate comfort and residents' income level weakened considerably in both cities. Region traffic remained a significant negative driver. Leisure time's influence also weakened.
- Main Tourist Markets: Henan Province remained the core tourist market for both Dengfeng and Kaifeng. Post-pandemic, the sub-core markets saw some shifts, with Shandong and Jiangsu becoming more prominent for Dengfeng, and Guangdong emerging for Kaifeng.
Limitations and Future Work
- Data Source Limitation: The authors acknowledge that relying solely on online travel diary data might lead to conclusions that are not entirely objective.
- Future Work: To overcome this limitation, future research should integrate online travel diary data with other sources such as geo-tagged photos, cell phone positioning data, Weibo check-in data, or official survey data to provide a more comprehensive understanding of regional tourist markets. The paper also suggests that future recovery policies should be made by comprehensively considering the driving factors, especially in light of the ongoing nature of the pandemic and its potential for unforeseen changes.
Summary updated