Analysis of the structure and metabolic function of microbial community in cigar tobacco leaves in agricultural processing stage

Qianying Zhang, Tianfei Zheng, Zhen Yang, Shuang-Hong Yang, Wen Cai, Pinhe Li, Yang Huang, Juan Zhang, Dongliang LiFrontiers in Microbiology 2023 · DOI

This study, published in Frontiers in Microbiology, maps the microbial "changing of the guard" during the air-curing and agricultural fermentation of cigar tobacco leaves (CTLs). By identifying how specific bacteria and fungi drive metabolic processes like nicotine degradation and aroma formation, the researchers provide a roadmap for bio-optimizing tobacco quality and consistency.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The journey from a green tobacco leaf in the field to a premium cigar involves two critical agricultural stages: air-curing (drying the leaf and degrading macromolecules like starch) and agricultural fermentation (developing complex aromas).

Historically, these stages have been treated more as an art than a science, with farmers relying on traditional experience. This often leads to inconsistent quality between batches. While we know microbes play a massive role in these transformations, the specific succession of microbial communities—and more importantly, what they are doing metabolically at each stage—has remained a "black box." This paper aims to open that box using high-throughput sequencing and functional prediction.

Methods

The researchers sampled "Dexue" cigar tobacco leaves from Shifang, Sichuan, at three distinct stages: freshly harvested, air-cured, and agriculturally fermented.

To profile the microbial communities, they used:

  • 16S rRNA Sequencing: To identify bacterial populations.
  • ITS Gene Sequencing: To identify fungal populations.
  • Functional Prediction: They employed PICRUSt2 (for bacteria) and FUNGuild (for fungi) to predict the metabolic functions of these communities based on their taxonomic profiles.
  • Statistical Modeling: They used Partial Least Squares (PLS) regression to create a correlation network, linking specific microbial genera to predicted functional genes. This allowed them to see which "players" were likely responsible for specific "tasks" like nicotine degradation or sugar metabolism.

Datasets

The study utilized a primary dataset of 1,741,054 bacterial reads and 2,095,371 fungal reads obtained from the sampled CTLs. Taxonomic identification was performed using the SILVA version 132 database (for bacteria) with a 97% similarity threshold for Operational Taxonomic Units (OTUs).

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Recruitment, Not Just Inheritance: Interestingly, microbial richness increased as fermentation progressed. This suggests that the microbes essential for a good cigar aren't just "inherited" from the soil; they are actively recruited from the surrounding environment during the processing stages.
  • Functional Succession: The microbial community is not static. Enterobacteriaceae and Chloroplast dominate the early air-curing stage, focusing on sugar and polysaccharide degradation. As the process shifts to fermentation, genera like Pseudomonas, Staphylococcus, and Aspergillus take over, pivoting the metabolic focus toward nicotine degradation and the production of organic acids and amino acids.
  • The "Designer" Community Potential: The authors suggest that because specific functions are tied to specific microbial successions, we don't have to leave quality to chance. If a natural microbial community is underperforming, it could be "optimized" or "designed" by inoculating the leaves with specific functional genera to achieve a desired flavor profile.

Key Results

  • Diversity Shifts: The Chao1 index (richness) was significantly higher in fermented and air-cured leaves compared to freshly harvested ones.
  • Dominant Players:
    • Air-cured CTLs: Dominated by Enterobacteriaceae, Chloroplast, and the fungus Alternaria.
  • Fermented CTLs: Dominated by Aquabacterium, Burkholderiaceae, Caulobacter, and the fungus Aspergillus.
  • Metabolic Heavy Hitters: Bacteria were found to be primarily involved in amino acid and fatty acid biosynthesis. Fungi played a larger role in respiration and lipid degradation.
  • Nicotine & Aroma: Genera like Pseudomonas and Acinetobacter were strongly correlated with nicotine degradation, while Aspergillus was linked to the production of flavoring substances, though the authors warn it can also cause mildew if not managed.

Limitations and Future Work

The primary limitation is that the metabolic functions are predicted based on DNA sequences (metagenomic prediction), not directly measured. While PICRUSt2 is a robust tool, it cannot account for actual gene expression (metatranscriptomics) or the actual presence of metabolites (metabolomics).

Additionally, the study focused on a single variety in a single region. Future work should involve:

  1. Multi-omics approaches: Combining sequencing with actual chemical analysis of the leaves.
  2. Inoculation trials: Testing whether adding the "dominant" genera identified here actually improves the quality of sub-par tobacco batches in a controlled environment.

Summary updated

Abstract

The agricultural fermentation processing of cigar tobacco leaves (CTLs), including air-curing and agricultural fermentation, carried out by tobacco farmers has rarely been studied. In this study, we have investigated the microbial community in the CTLs during air-curing and agricultural fermentation by 16S rRNA and ITS gene high-throughput sequencing. The results showed that the richness of microbial communities gradually increased with the development of agricultural fermentation, which means that not all microorganisms in CTLs come from the fields where tobacco grows, but gradually accumulate into CTLs during the fermentation process. <i>Enterobacteriaceae</i>, <i>Chloroplast</i>, and <i>Alternaria</i> were the dominant genera in the air-cured CTLs. <i>Aquabacterium</i>, unclassified <i>Burkholderiaceae</i>, <i>Caulobacter</i>, <i>Brevundimonas</i>, and <i>Aspergillus</i> were the dominant genera in the agriculturally fermented CTLs. <i>Acinetobacter</i>, <i>Methylobacterium</i>, <i>Sampaiozyma</i>, and <i>Plectosphaerella</i> first significantly increased, and then significantly decreased during agricultural processing. The changes in microbial communities are mainly related to their different functions during fermentation. This means that when the fermentation effect of the original microbial community in cigar tobacco leaves is not ideal, we can optimize or design the microbial community based on the fermentation function that the microbial community needs to achieve. These results may help adjust and optimize the agricultural fermentation process of CTLs, and help develop the quality of CTLs and increase the income of tobacco farmers.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{zhang2023analysis,
  author = {Qianying Zhang and Tianfei Zheng and Zhen Yang and Shuang-Hong Yang and Wen Cai and Pinhe Li and Yang Huang and Juan Zhang and Dongliang Li},
  title = {{Analysis of the structure and metabolic function of microbial community in cigar tobacco leaves in agricultural processing stage}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Microbiology},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.3389/fmicb.2023.1230547},
}
Figure