Analysis of the Risk Factors for PCCP Damage via Cloud Theory

Liwei Han, Yifan Zhang, Te Wang, Ruibin GuoBuildings 2025 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel risk analysis model for prestressed concrete cylinder pipes (PCCPs) by integrating cloud theory and the Monte Carlo method. This approach effectively quantifies uncertainties in material properties and manufacturing processes, leading to a more accurate assessment of pipeline failure probability and a reliability index of 4.49 for a specific pipeline section.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Prestressed concrete cylinder pipes (PCCPs) are widely used in water supply systems due to their strength and durability. However, pipeline failures can lead to significant financial losses, service disruptions, and safety hazards. While research has focused on failure mechanisms and repair methods, a comprehensive understanding and quantification of the damage risks associated with PCCPs, particularly considering the inherent uncertainties in their production and material properties, remained a gap. This paper aims to address this by developing a robust risk analysis framework that can better capture these uncertainties.

Methods

The core of this research lies in the integration of two key methodologies:

  • Cloud Theory: This is a novel artificial intelligence model that fuses fuzzy mathematics and probability theory to convert qualitative data into quantitative measures. It uses three numerical properties – Expectation (Ex), Entropy (En), and Hyperentropy (He) – to describe the characteristics of data. The paper employs an inverse cloud generator to derive these parameters from experimental data and a forward cloud model to generate cloud droplets, representing the uncertainty in the data.
  • Monte Carlo Method: This is a well-established statistical technique that uses random sampling to simulate complex systems and estimate probabilities. By combining it with cloud theory, the researchers can generate random samples that follow the cloud distribution, providing a more accurate representation of the uncertainties in the PCCP's load-bearing capacity.

The process involves:

  1. Collecting experimental data on concrete compressive strength and prestressing steel wire force.
  2. Using an inverse cloud generator to obtain Ex, En, and He for these parameters.
  3. Employing a forward cloud generator to create cloud droplets representing the data distributions.
  4. Integrating these cloud distributions into the Monte Carlo method to establish a risk analysis model for PCCP pipelines.
  5. Calculating the failure probability and reliability index for a specific pipeline section using internal water pressure monitoring data.

Datasets

The study utilizes experimental data collected from:

  • Concrete Compressive Strength Tests: Samples of C55 concrete were tested using a YAW-5000 microcomputer-controlled electrohydraulic servo pressure testing machine.
  • Prestressing Steel Wire Stress Tests: The actual prestressing force of steel wires in PCCP pipelines was measured using a DH3816N Static Stress Tester.
  • Internal Water Pressure Monitoring Data: Data from the Qiliqiao Reservoir to the Xiayi Water Supply Line in the South-to-North Water Diversion Project was used for the final risk assessment.

The paper presents a dataset of 25 reference samples for the ultimate bearing capacity of PCCP pipes, including compressive strength of concrete core and measured prestressing force of steel wire.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Cloud Theory for Uncertainty: The paper convincingly demonstrates that cloud theory is a powerful tool for handling the inherent fuzziness, randomness, and multi-factor coupling features present in engineering practice, offering a more nuanced approach than traditional probabilistic methods.
  • PCCP Load-Bearing Capacity: The research highlights that the compressive strength of the concrete pipe core has a greater impact on the pipe's ultimate bearing capacity than the prestressing steel wire, despite the latter's crucial role.
  • Integrated Risk Assessment: Combining cloud theory with the Monte Carlo method provides a more accurate and flexible way to assess pipeline failure risks, especially when dealing with limited sample data and complex variable distributions.
  • Data Distribution Insights: The study confirms that both concrete compressive strength and prestressing force data adhere to a normal distribution, which is then effectively modeled using cloud distributions for risk analysis.

Key Results

  • The compressive strength of the concrete in the tested PCCP pipes ranged from 59.09 MPa to 68.93 MPa, with an average of 64.34 MPa.
  • The measured prestressing force of steel wires varied from 1399.54 MPa to 1865.33 MPa, with an average of 1597.44 MPa.
  • The developed risk analysis model, using cloud theory and Monte Carlo simulation, calculated the failure probability for a specific pipeline section under 0.6 MPa loading to be very low.
  • The reliability index for this pipeline section was found to be 4.49, indicating a high level of dependability.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations and suggest avenues for future research:

  • External Loads: The current risk analysis does not account for the influence of external loads on the pipeline. Future work should integrate these factors for a more comprehensive assessment.
  • Unforeseen Causes: The study focuses on predictable loads. However, unforeseen factors like hydrogen embrittlement can also impact pipeline integrity. Future research should investigate the impact of such phenomena on PCCP damage risk.
  • Data Repository: The study mentions constraints in knowledge repositories and data investigation conditions, suggesting that more extensive data collection and analysis would be beneficial.

Summary updated

Abstract

Research on prestressed concrete cylinder pipes (PCCPs) has focused primarily on their failure mechanisms, monitoring methods, and the effectiveness of repairs. However, gaps in the study of damage risks associated with PCCPs remain. Based on existing relevant research, this study focused on analysing the uncertainties in the material production and manufacturing processes of PCCPs to assess their damage risk. The research employs onsite test data about the compressive strength of C55 concrete and the real prestressing force exerted on prestressed steel wires, utilising the measured compressive strength of the concrete core in PCCPs alongside the actual prestressing force applied to the steel wires. An inverse cloud generator was employed to obtain the expected value Ex, entropy En, and hyperentropy He of the characteristic numbers. These values are then combined with the forward cloud model in cloud theory to train random parameters. By combining cloud theory with the Monte Carlo method, a risk analysis model for PCCP pipelines was established. Using internal water pressure monitoring data from the Qiliqiao Reservoir to the Xiayi Water Supply Line in the South-to-North Water Diversion Project, along with relevant PCCP pipeline data, the failure probability of the PCCP pipeline was calculated. The reliability index of this pipeline section under 0.6 MPa loading was found to be 4.49, demonstrating the reliability of the PCCP pipeline in this section of the water supply line.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{han2025analysis,
  author = {Liwei Han and Yifan Zhang and Te Wang and Ruibin Guo},
  title = {{Analysis of the Risk Factors for PCCP Damage via Cloud Theory}},
  booktitle = {Buildings},
  year = {2025},
  doi = {10.3390/buildings15183363},
}
Figure