Analysis of the potential of near-ground measurements of CO 2 and CH 4 in London, UK, for the monitoring of city-scale emissions using an atmospheric transport model

Alex Boon, Grégoire Broquet, Deborah J. Clifford, Frédéric Chevallier, D M Butterfield, Isabelle Pison, Michel Ramonet, Jean-Daniel Paris, Philippe CiaisAtmospheric 2016 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigates the potential of near-ground CO2 and CH4 measurements in London for monitoring city-scale emissions. By comparing measurements with a high-resolution atmospheric transport model, the researchers found that local emission sources significantly impact readings. They developed methods, particularly focusing on gradients between urban and rural sites, to isolate the urban emission signal, significantly improving model-data agreement for CO2.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Cities are major emitters of greenhouse gases (GHGs) like CO2 and CH4, yet accurately quantifying these emissions at the city scale is challenging. Current methods rely on emission inventories, which have substantial uncertainties, especially at finer resolutions. Atmospheric inversion, using GHG measurements and transport models, offers a promising alternative for monitoring and verifying these emissions. However, a key challenge is the influence of local emission sources (e.g., traffic, small industrial sites) on near-ground measurements, which are often too small to be explicitly represented in kilometer-scale models. This can lead to large discrepancies between model simulations and actual observations, hindering the effective use of these measurements for inversion. This paper aims to assess the potential of near-ground urban measurements for city-scale GHG emission monitoring by identifying and mitigating sources of model-data discrepancies.

Methods

The researchers employed a mesoscale atmospheric transport model (CHIMERE) with a 2 km horizontal resolution, driven by ECMWF meteorological data and a 1 km resolution emission inventory (UK National Atmospheric Emission Inventory). They collected continuous CO2 and CH4 measurements from four near-ground sites in and around London during the summer of 2012. To address the impact of local sources and other uncertainties, they implemented several analytical strategies:

  • Focusing on Afternoon Data: To mitigate issues with modeling the nocturnal and morning atmospheric boundary layer, analyses were restricted to the afternoon period.
  • Gradient Analysis: Instead of comparing absolute concentrations at individual sites, the study analyzed concentration differences (gradients) between urban sites and suburban/rural reference sites. This approach helps to cancel out large-scale influences from model boundary conditions and remote fluxes.
  • Wind Direction Filtering: Gradients were further analyzed by selecting periods where the reference site was upwind of the urban site, aiming to isolate the signal of emissions transported from the city.
  • CO-based Fossil Fuel CO2 Estimation: To better isolate the fossil fuel component of CO2 emissions, they used a theoretical ratio of CO to CO2 gradients, leveraging the fact that CO and CO2 are co-emitted from fossil fuel combustion.

Datasets

  • GHG Measurements: Continuous CO2 and CH4 mole fraction data collected from four near-ground sites in London (Hackney, Poplar, Teddington, Detling) between June and September 2012.
  • Atmospheric Transport Model: CHIMERE model with a 2 km horizontal resolution for the south of England.
  • Emission Inventory: UK National Atmospheric Emissions Inventory (NAEI) for CO2 and CH4 at 1 km resolution.
  • Meteorological Data: European Centre for Medium-Range Weather Forecasts (ECMWF) meteorological forcing data.
  • Meteorological Observations: Wind speed and direction data from Heathrow Airport and East Malling meteorological sites.
  • Mixing Layer Height Data: Lidar measurements from North Kensington.
  • Boundary Conditions: MACC-II forecasts for CO2 boundary conditions.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Local Sources Dominate Near-Ground Urban Measurements: The study strongly suggests that small-scale emission sources, not resolved by the 2 km model grid, significantly impact near-ground measurements in urban areas, leading to large model-data discrepancies.
  • Gradient Analysis is Crucial for Urban Inversions: Analyzing concentration differences between urban and reference sites, rather than absolute values, effectively reduces the influence of large-scale uncertainties (boundary conditions, remote fluxes), improving the focus on urban emissions.
  • Wind Direction Matters for Gradient Interpretation: Selecting gradient data when the reference site is upwind of the urban site further enhances the isolation of the urban emission signal and improves model-data agreement.
  • CH4 Emissions are More Diffuse in London: Unlike CO2, CH4 measurements showed less distinct local source signatures, suggesting a more diffuse distribution of CH4 emissions in London, making it harder to pinpoint specific local sources.
  • CO as a Tracer for Fossil Fuel CO2: Using the CO-to-CO2 ratio proved useful for estimating the fossil fuel component of CO2 emissions, providing an observation-based proxy to compare with model simulations.

Key Results

  • High Initial Discrepancies: Raw model-data discrepancies for CO2 and CH4 at individual urban sites were substantial, with RMS values of 8-12 ppm for CO2 and 30-55 ppb for CH4.
  • Improved Agreement with Gradients: Analyzing gradients between urban and reference sites significantly reduced model-data RMS discrepancies to 3-7 ppm for CO2 and 29-38 ppb for CH4.
  • Wind Filtering Further Improves CH4: Selecting gradients based on wind direction further improved CH4 statistics, halving the RMS discrepancies.
  • CO2 Fossil Fuel Component Shows Promise: The CO-based estimation of fossil fuel CO2 gradients showed improved consistency with model simulations, particularly for the Hackney-Teddington pair.
  • Persistent Biases: Despite improvements, significant biases remained, especially for CO2 gradients, suggesting that local emission sources, even when filtered by wind direction, still influence the measurements and pose a challenge for inversion.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Model Resolution Limitations: The 2 km resolution of the CHIMERE model is insufficient to capture the impact of very local emission sources, leading to persistent biases.
  • Urban Heat Island Effect: The model's meteorological forcing did not account for the urban heat island effect, potentially contributing to model-data discrepancies, especially during nighttime.
  • CH4 Boundary Conditions: The use of constant CH4 boundary conditions in the model is a simplification that may not accurately reflect real-world variations.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest several avenues for future research:
  • Developing more sophisticated inversion methodologies to better filter out large-scale influences and isolate urban signals.
  • Exploring networks with a denser sampling of urban measurements or measurements at higher altitudes to reduce the impact of local sources.
  • Investigating the joint assimilation of CO and CO2 data to improve the partitioning of natural and anthropogenic signals.
  • Considering alternative approaches like local-scale inversions for specific point sources (e.g., landfills, wastewater treatment plants) for CH4.
  • Improving the representation of urban meteorology and local emission sources in transport models.

Summary updated

Abstract

Carbon dioxide (CO2) and methane (CH4) mole fractions were measured at four near-ground sites located in and around London during the summer of 2012 with a view to investigating the potential of assimilating such measurements in an atmospheric inversion system for the monitoring of the CO2 and CH4 emissions in the London area. These data were analysed and compared with simulations using a modelling framework suited to building an inversion system: a 2 km horizontal resolution south of England configuration of the transport model CHIMERE driven by European Centre for Medium-Range Weather Forecasts (ECMWF) meteorological forcing, coupled to a 1 km horizontal resolution emission inventory (the UK National Atmospheric Emission Inventory). First comparisons reveal that local sources, which cannot be represented in the model at a 2 km resolution, have a large impact on measurements. We evaluate methods to filter out the impact of some of the other critical sources of discrepancies between the measurements and the model simulation except that of the errors in the emission inventory, which we attempt to isolate. Such a separation of the impact of errors in the emission inventory should make it easier to identify the corrections that should be applied to the inventory. Analysis is supported by observations from meteorological sites around the city and a 3-week period of atmospheric mixing layer height estimations from lidar measurements. The difficulties of modelling the mixing layer depth and thus CO2 and CH4 concentrations during the night, morning and late afternoon lead to focusing on the afternoon period for all further analyses. The discrepancies between observations and model simulations are high for both CO2 and CH4 (i.e. their root mean square (RMS) is between 8 and 12 parts per million (ppm) for CO2 and between 30 and 55 parts per billion (ppb) for CH4 at a given site). By analysing the gradients between the urban sites and a suburban or rural reference site, we are able to decrease the impact of uncertainties in the fluxes and transport outside the London area and in the model domain boundary conditions. We are thus able to better focus attention on the signature of London urban CO2 and CH4 emissions in the atmospheric CO2 and CH4 concentrations. This considerably improves the statistical agreement between the model and observations for CO2 (with model–data RMS discrepancies that are between 3 and 7 ppm) and to a lesser degree for CH4 (with model–data RMS discrepancies that are between 29 and 38 ppb). Between one of the urban sites and either the rural or suburban reference site, selecting the gradients during periods wherein the reference site is upwind of the urban site further decreases the statistics of the discrepancies in general, though not systematically. In a further attempt to focus on the signature of the city anthropogenic emission in the mole fraction measurements, we use a theoretical ratio of gradients of carbon monoxide (CO) to gradients of CO2 from fossil fuel emissions in the London area to diagnose observation-based fossil fuel CO2 gradients, and compare them with the fossil fuel CO2 gradients simulated with CHIMERE. This estimate increases the consistency between the model and the measurements when considering only one of the two urban sites, even though the two sites are relatively close to each other within the city. While this study evaluates and highlights the merit of different approaches for increasing the consistency between the mesoscale model and the near-ground data, and while it manages to decrease the random component of the analysed model–data discrepancies to an extent that should not be prohibitive to extracting the signal from the London urban emissions, large biases, the sign of which depends on the measurement sites, remain in the final model–data discrepancies. Such biases are likely related to local emissions to which the urban near-ground sites are highly sensitive. This questions our current ability to exploit urban near-ground data for the atmospheric inversion of city emissions based on models at spatial resolution coarser than 2 km. Several measurement and modelling concepts are discussed to overcome this challenge.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{boon2016analysis,
  author = {Alex Boon and Grégoire Broquet and Deborah J. Clifford and Frédéric Chevallier and D M Butterfield and Isabelle Pison and Michel Ramonet and Jean-Daniel Paris and Philippe Ciais},
  title = {{Analysis of the potential of near-ground measurements of CO <sub>2</sub> and CH <sub>4</sub> in London, UK, for the monitoring of city-scale emissions using an atmospheric transport model}},
  booktitle = {Atmospheric},
  year = {2016},
  doi = {10.5194/acp-16-6735-2016},
}
Figure