Analysis of the ARTIC version 3 and version 4 SARS-CoV-2 primers and their impact on the detection of the G142D amino acid substitution in the spike protein

James J. Davis, S. Wesley Long, Paul A. Christensen, Randall J. Olsen, Robert Olson, Maulik Shukla, Sishir Subedi, Rick Stevens, James M. MusserbioRxiv 2021 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper highlights how crucial primer design is for accurate SARS-CoV-2 genomic sequencing. By comparing two versions of the ARTIC Network primers (V3 and V4), the researchers found that the newer V4 primers significantly improve sequencing quality and are essential for correctly identifying key mutations like G142D in the spike protein, which was previously underrepresented due to limitations in the V3 primers.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The SARS-CoV-2 pandemic necessitated rapid and widespread genomic sequencing to track viral evolution, identify new variants, and inform public health responses. The ARTIC Network provides widely used primer sets for amplifying the SARS-CoV-2 genome for sequencing. However, as new variants emerged with mutations that altered primer binding sites, older primer versions (like V3) began to show "amplicon dropout" and poor sequence coverage in critical regions. This led to potential underdetection of important genetic variations. This paper addresses the need to evaluate the performance of the updated ARTIC V4 primer set against the widely used V3 set, specifically focusing on its ability to accurately detect a significant mutation (G142D) in the spike protein, which is crucial for understanding viral behavior and evolution.

Methods

The researchers compared the performance of ARTIC V3 and V4 primer sets using a matched set of 663 SARS-CoV-2 clinical samples. These samples were amplified using both primer sets and then sequenced on an Illumina NovaSeq 6000 instrument. The resulting sequencing reads were processed using a standardized bioinformatics pipeline that included quality trimming (seqtk), read alignment (minimap2), sequence manipulation (samtools), and primer trimming/SNP calling (iVar). Lineage assignment was performed using Pangolin. The study focused on comparing sequencing depth, quality, and the accurate detection of specific single nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs) that lead to amino acid substitutions, particularly the G142D substitution in the spike protein.

Datasets

The study utilized a dataset of 663 SARS-CoV-2 clinical samples collected between July 2-18, 2021. These samples were amplified with both ARTIC V3 and V4 primer sets. The sequencing reads from these samples are publicly available in the Sequence Read Archive (SRA) under bioproject PRJNA767338. Additionally, the study references data from public repositories like GISAID for comparative analysis of variant prevalence.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Primer Design is Paramount: This study powerfully demonstrates that the choice of primer set is not a trivial detail but a critical factor that can directly impact the accuracy and completeness of genomic surveillance data.
  • V4 Solves V3's Blind Spots: The ARTIC V4 primers effectively address the shortcomings of V3, particularly in regions prone to amplicon dropout, leading to more robust and complete genome assemblies.
  • Underestimation of Key Mutations: The widespread use of V3 primers during the Delta variant surge likely led to an underrepresentation of the G142D substitution in publicly available early Delta genomes, creating a potentially misleading picture of its prevalence.
  • Metadata Matters: The absence of metadata detailing which primer scheme was used for sequencing can severely hinder the downstream interpretation and utility of publicly shared genomic data.

Key Results

  • Improved Sequencing Quality: The ARTIC V4 primer set resulted in "considerable improvement in sequence quality" compared to V3, with higher median read depths across the genome and at primer positions.
  • Correction of Coverage Gaps: A significant low-coverage region in the spike gene (nucleotide positions 22,320-22,530) that was problematic with V3 primers was corrected in V4.
  • Accurate G142D Detection: V4 primers were significantly better at detecting the G142D substitution. While V3 assemblies showed ambiguous bases at this position in 368 out of 663 samples, V4 assemblies had ambiguity in only 3 samples.
  • Lineage Reclassification: Differences in primer performance led to reclassification of some samples. For instance, three samples initially classified as AY.15 or AY.24 by V3 were correctly classified as B.1.617.2 by V4.
  • Artifactual "Uptick" of G142D: The apparent rapid increase in G142D prevalence observed in public repositories from June-August 2021 was largely an artifact of the widespread adoption of V4 primers, not a true evolutionary sweep. Analysis of samples collected before and after the V4 adoption clearly shows the G142D uptick coinciding with V4 usage.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Limitations: The study acknowledges that V4 also has a minor area of slightly lower coverage (nucleotide positions 26,950–27,180), though it was less problematic than V3's issues. The authors also note that the "ancestral glycine at spike position 142 is extremely rare in Delta variants collected in Houston," which is a finding rather than a limitation.
  • Future Work: The paper strongly implies the need for clear metadata reporting on primer schemes used in sequencing efforts. It also underscores the importance of ongoing primer set evaluation and updates as new SARS-CoV-2 variants emerge, ensuring that genomic surveillance remains accurate and informative for public health.

Summary updated

Abstract

ABSTRACT The ARTIC Network provides a common resource of PCR primer sequences and recommendations for amplifying SARS-CoV-2 genomes. The initial tiling strategy was developed with the reference genome Wuhan-01, and subsequent iterations have addressed areas of low amplification and sequence drop out. Recently, a new version (V4) was released, based on new variant genome sequences, in response to the realization that some V3 primers were located in regions with key mutations. Herein, we compare the performance of the ARTIC V3 and V4 primer sets with a matched set of 663 SARS-CoV-2 clinical samples sequenced with an Illumina NovaSeq 6000 instrument. We observe general improvements in sequencing depth and quality, and improved resolution of the SNP causing the D950N variation in the spike protein. Importantly, we also find nearly universal presence of spike protein substitution G142D in Delta-lineage samples. Due to the prior release and widespread use of the ARTIC V3 primers during the initial surge of the Delta variant, it is likely that the G142D amino acid substitution is substantially underrepresented among early Delta variant genomes deposited in public repositories. In addition to the improved performance of the ARTIC V4 primer set, this study also illustrates the importance of the primer scheme in downstream analyses. Importance ARTIC Network primers are commonly used by laboratories worldwide to amplify and sequence SARS-CoV-2 present in clinical samples. As new variants have evolved and spread, it was found that the V3 primer set poorly amplified several key mutations. In this report, we compare the results of sequencing a matched set of samples with the V3 and V4 primer sets. We find that adoption of the ARTIC V4 primer set is critical for accurate sequencing of the SARS-CoV-2 spike region. The absence of metadata describing the primer scheme used will negatively impact the downstream use of publicly available SARS-Cov-2 sequencing reads and assembled genomes.
BibTeX
@misc{davis2021analysis,
  author = {James J. Davis and S. Wesley Long and Paul A. Christensen and Randall J. Olsen and Robert Olson and Maulik Shukla and Sishir Subedi and Rick Stevens and James M. Musser},
  title = {{Analysis of the ARTIC version 3 and version 4 SARS-CoV-2 primers and their impact on the detection of the G142D amino acid substitution in the spike protein}},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.1101/2021.09.27.461949},
  howpublished = {bioRxiv},
}

Loading related content...

Figure