Analysis of students' cognitive structures concerning the topic of chemical bond based on word association test

Jiaqi Wang, Na Lu, Xinyang Hu, Wei ChenX-Disciplinarity 2025 · DOI

This study, published in X-Disciplinarity, explores how high school students mentally organize one of the most abstract topics in chemistry: the chemical bond. By using Word Association Tests (WAT), the researchers reveal a "forest for the trees" problem—students can identify specific bond types but struggle to grasp the underlying physical principles and energetic implications that tie them together.

TL;DR

Researchers used Word Association Tests to map the "cognitive structures" of 100+ high school students regarding chemical bonds. While students successfully link bond types to their respective compounds, they lack a holistic understanding of the electrostatic forces and energy changes that define bonding, often treating these fundamental principles as isolated facts.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

In chemistry education, "knowledge" isn't just a list of facts; it’s a web of interconnected concepts. Cognitive psychologists argue that the structure of this web determines how well a student can apply knowledge to new problems. However, chemical bonds are notoriously difficult to teach because they are abstract and microscopic.

Traditional ways to measure a student's mental map—like one-on-one interviews or complex concept mapping—are time-consuming and difficult to scale in a real-world classroom. This paper addresses the need for a quick, quantitative way to diagnose "gaps" in a group's collective understanding, specifically focusing on why students often fail to see the "big picture" of chemical interactions.

Methods

The researchers employed the Word Association Test (WAT), a technique where students are given a "stimulus" word (e.g., "Ionic Bond") and have 30 seconds to write down as many related chemical terms as possible.

The study involved 80 Grade 10 students in Shandong, China. The researchers analyzed the data using two primary lenses:

  1. Semantic Relevance Analysis: Using the Garskof and Houston formula, they calculated a Relatedness Coefficient (RC). This measures the overlap between response lists for different keywords. If two concepts (like "Covalent Bond" and "Covalent Compound") trigger almost identical word lists, they have a high RC.
  2. Cognitive Structure Mapping: Based on the frequency of responses, the researchers built visual maps. They used a "cutoff point" method to show how concepts cluster together at different levels of familiarity, effectively visualizing "islands" of knowledge that eventually merge as the association threshold is lowered.

Datasets

The study utilized a primary dataset generated from the 80 students' responses to eight key stimulus terms: ionic bond, covalent bond, ionic compound, covalent compound, bond energy, intermolecular force, electrostatic interaction, and bonding pair. The students had all used the same standardized 2019 edition textbooks from Shandong Science and Technology Press.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The Linguistic Trap: The strongest associations were between "Covalent Bond" and "Covalent Compound" (and their ionic counterparts). The researchers suggest this might be a superficial linguistic link—students associate them because they share the same name, not necessarily because they understand the structural relationship.
  • The "Why" is Missing: "Electrostatic interaction"—the actual physical force that creates a bond—was the weakest and most isolated concept in the students' minds. Many students associated the term with "sweaters" or "friction" (static electricity) rather than the attraction between subatomic particles.
  • Energy in a Silo: "Bond energy" was largely disconnected from the other concepts. In the curriculum, energy is often taught in the context of chemical reactions (thermodynamics) rather than as the driving force of bond formation. Consequently, students don't see energy as an intrinsic property of the bond itself.
  • Detail-Oriented but Holistic-Poor: Students were good at identifying subordinate concepts (e.g., associating "ionic bond" with "ions") but struggled with "upward" associations to the higher-level concept of a "chemical bond" as a unified theme.

Key Results

  • RC Range: Correlation coefficients ranged from a high of 0.905 (Covalent Bond/Covalent Compound) to a low of 0.177 (Bond Energy/Covalent Compound).
  • The "Island" Effect: At high association thresholds (0.85), students' knowledge exists in two isolated islands: the "Covalent Island" and the "Ionic Island."
  • Directional Imbalance: The mapping showed that students frequently associate "Bonding Pair" with "Covalent Bond," but rarely the other way around. This suggests a one-way street in their logic: they know a bonding pair exists in a covalent bond, but they don't use the concept of a bonding pair to define the bond.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge that while WAT is excellent for a "snapshot" of a group, it lacks the depth of an interview; it can tell you that a connection is weak, but not always why.

Future Directions: * Virtual Reality (VR): The authors suggest using VR to help students visualize the microscopic, dynamic process of bond formation, which might help bridge the gap between abstract terms and physical reality. * Curriculum Re-sequencing: They propose integrating "energy views" earlier and more consistently across chapters to prevent bond energy from becoming an isolated fact. * Mixed Methods: Combining WAT with follow-up interviews to gain a more nuanced understanding of individual student misconceptions.

Summary updated

Abstract

The cognitive structure of "chemical bond" among first-year high school students was examined using lexical association tests, combined with semantic relevance analysis and cognitive structure diagram analysis. The results showed that most of the learned concept of "chemical bond" was included in the students' cognitive structure, but there were few associations about "the principles and essence of chemical bond formation", and the understanding of "different ways of chemical bond formation" was rather confusing. At the same time, the energy perspective under the theme of "chemical bond" needed to be developed and improved.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{wang2025analysis,
  author = {Jiaqi Wang and Na Lu and Xinyang Hu and Wei Chen},
  title = {{Analysis of students' cognitive structures concerning the topic of chemical bond based on word association test}},
  booktitle = {X-Disciplinarity},
  year = {2025},
  doi = {10.63174/xdi.lurd6860},
}
Figure