Analysis of Speech Errors in the Impromptu Speech among English Majors: Taking Yantai Institute of Technology as an Example

Xiaochen ZhaoInternational Journal of Education and Humanities 2025 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigates the types and causes of speech errors made by Chinese English majors during high-pressure impromptu speaking contests. By analyzing a corpus of contest recordings, the researcher found that "filled pauses" (like "uh" or "um") are the most prevalent error, primarily driven by native language interference, limited linguistic proficiency, and topic-induced anxiety.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

While psycholinguistics has long explored how we produce speech, the specific niche of "speech errors"—deviations from grammatically or syntactically "normal" language—has seen a decline in recent research. This is particularly problematic for second-language (L2) learners. In high-stakes environments like impromptu speech competitions, these errors can lead to significant misunderstandings or a total breakdown in communication.

The author identifies a gap in existing literature: most domestic Chinese studies focus on medical applications (like Alzheimer’s) or general teaching methods, but few provide a systematic discourse analysis of English majors performing under the specific cognitive load of an impromptu competition. The paper seeks to categorize these errors and identify their root causes to help educators develop better intervention strategies.

Methods

The research utilizes a descriptive and qualitative approach grounded in Clark & Clark’s (1977) theory of speech errors. This framework categorizes errors into nine types: silent pauses, filled pauses, repeats, retraced false starts, un-retraced false starts, corrections, interjections, stutters, and slips of the tongue.

The workflow involved:

  1. Recording: Capturing 17 impromptu speeches from a regional public speaking contest.
  2. Transcription: Using the Xunfei AI platform for initial speech-to-text, followed by four rounds of manual calibration to ensure 100% accuracy of the disfluencies.
  3. Data Cleaning: Redacting personal info and removing extraneous noise while preserving all grammatical and pragmatic "errors" for analysis.
  4. Statistical Census: Calculating the frequency and percentage of each error type.

Datasets

The study used a specialized corpus derived from the 2024 “FLTRP·ETIC Cup” English Public Speaking Contest held at the Yantai Institute of Technology (YIT).

  • Size: 17 recordings, totaling approximately 1,800 seconds (30 minutes) of speech.
  • Participants: English majors aged 18–21, ranging from freshmen to juniors.
  • Context: High-pressure impromptu topics (e.g., "digital pickles," "cyber violence vs. freedom of speech") with only 25 minutes of preparation for a 3-minute delivery.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The Dominance of the "Hesitation" Error: Filled pauses (42.1%) and silent pauses (23.6%) account for over 65% of all errors. This suggests that the primary struggle for these students isn't necessarily "forgetting" English, but rather the cognitive load of processing a foreign language while simultaneously formulating an argument.
  • Negative L1 Transfer: The paper highlights how students' native Chinese (L1) logic bleeds into their English. A striking example is the use of "self-death" to mean suicide—a direct morphological translation from Chinese patterns—and the occasional use of Chinese filler phrases like "不是" (bù shì) when the speaker gets stuck.
  • The "Thinking Time" Strategy: The author argues that filled pauses like "um" aren't just mistakes; they are functional tools used by speakers to "buy time" to extend their thinking when faced with unfamiliar or complex topics.
  • The Absence of Interjections: Interestingly, interjections (like "oh" or "well") occurred 0% of the time. This suggests that in a formal, competitive setting, students may perceive interjections as too informal or simply lack the pragmatic competence to use them naturally.

Key Results

The statistical breakdown of speech errors was as follows:

  • Filled Pauses: 42.088% (125 instances)
  • Silent Pauses: 23.569% (70 instances)
  • Repeats: 14.141% (42 instances)
  • Retraced False Starts: 8.754% (26 instances)
  • Stutters & Un-retraced False Starts: Tied at 4.377% each.
  • Slips of the Tongue: 1.684% (e.g., mispronouncing "popular" as "pupilar").
  • Interjections: 0%

The qualitative analysis identified three main drivers: negative transfer of the mother tongue, inadequate comprehensive language skills (e.g., using "without clear" instead of "without clearing"), and anxiety stemming from time constraints and difficult topics.

Limitations and Future Work

The author acknowledges that the research object is relatively narrow, focusing on a single institution (Yantai Institute of Technology). The sample size (17 recordings) is small, which may limit the generalizability of the findings to all English majors in China.

Future work could involve a larger, multi-institutional corpus and a more longitudinal approach to see how these error patterns evolve as students progress from their freshman to senior years. Additionally, the paper suggests that future research should integrate speech error analysis with more advanced AI-driven recognition systems to provide real-time feedback to learners.

Summary updated

Abstract

Speech errors refer to the “abnormal” language, which is grammatically or syntactically incorrect, produced by learners during oral communication due to nervousness or pressure. These errors mainly involve pronunciation and sentence construction mistakes. In the context of globalization, where international communication is increasingly frequent, speech errors can lead to communication difficulties or misunderstandings. Although psycholinguistics research has been growing, the number of studies on its branch, speech errors, has been decreasing in recent years. Under the guidance of Clark & Clark’s theory of speech errors, this research takes the corpora of 2024 “FLTRP·ETIC Cup” English Public Speaking Contest held by Yantai Institute of Technology as the research object. It analyses the types, frequencies, and reasons of speech errors in impromptu speech contests of English majors, and attempts to put forward some corresponding solutions. The study found that currently most frequent types of speech errors include filled pauses, silent pauses, and repeats. Negative native language transfer, inadequate comprehensive foreign language abilities, and anxiety about unfamiliar topics are the main reasons for speech errors. Therefore, students should actively learn the culture of English-speaking countries and practice oral output. For teachers, it is essential to create a conducive English learning environment to improve the speaking and oral communication skills of English major students and enhance their language confidence.
BibTeX
@article{zhao2025analysis,
  author = {Xiaochen Zhao},
  title = {{Analysis of Speech Errors in the Impromptu Speech among English Majors: Taking Yantai Institute of Technology as an Example}},
  journal = {International Journal of Education and Humanities},
  year = {2025},
  doi = {10.54097/3pebx857},
}
Figure