Analysis of research status and trends on nano-agricultural application: a bibliometric study

Xing Luo, Jing Li, Song Guo, Hua Yu, Xiangzhong Zeng, Zijun Zhou, Yuxian Shangguan, Mingjiang He, Yiting Ouyang, Kun Chen, Zhimin Chen, Yusheng QinFrontiers in Plant Science 2025 · DOI

TL;DR

This study provides a comprehensive bibliometric analysis of nano-agricultural applications, revealing a rapid growth in research publications and citations. The field has evolved from early toxicological studies to a current focus on using nanomaterials (NMs) as nanofertilizers and nanoregulators for enhanced crop growth and resistance, with Europe and Asia leading in activity and the USA producing higher-quality research.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The global population is growing rapidly, placing immense pressure on food production. Traditional agricultural practices are facing limitations due to declining efficiency, reduced arable land, water scarcity, and climate change. This necessitates the development of innovative, sustainable, and efficient agricultural technologies. Nanotechnology, specifically nano-agricultural applications, offers promising solutions by enhancing crop growth, improving stress resistance, and potentially reducing environmental risks. However, understanding the landscape of this rapidly evolving research field – its key players, trends, and future directions – is crucial for guiding future efforts. This paper addresses this need by providing a bibliometric overview of the research status and trends in nano-agricultural applications.

Methods

The authors employed a bibliometric analysis approach. They utilized the Web of Science Core Collection database to retrieve publications related to nano-agricultural applications. The search terms used were "nano*" and "agriculture application," limited to English language articles and reviews published between January 1, 2000, and October 13, 2023. After initial retrieval of 2,633 articles, 6 retracted publications were removed, and 2,627 papers were selected. A further check by HistCite Pro 2.1 removed one duplicate, resulting in a final dataset of 2,626 publications. Various bibliometric analysis tools were used, including:

  • WOS Data Analysis System: For publication proportions and output of top disciplines.
  • VOSviewer: For creating collaborative network diagrams of authors, institutions, and countries, as well as keyword co-occurrence network diagrams.
  • CiteSpace: For analyzing intermediary centrality of top categories, burst detection of keywords, and co-citation analysis.
  • HistCite Pro 2.1: For analyzing total local citation score (TLCS) and total global citation score (TGCS).

Datasets

The study utilized the Web of Science Core Collection (SSCI and SCI-EXPANDED) as the literature search database. The dataset comprised 2,626 publications on nano-agricultural applications, collected from January 1, 2000, to October 13, 2023. No new benchmark datasets were introduced; the focus was on analyzing existing published literature.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Rapid Growth and Evolution: The field has experienced exponential growth in publications and citations since 2000, indicating its increasing importance.
  • Two Distinct Stages: The research has clearly evolved through two phases: an initial focus on the toxicology of nanomaterials (NMs) (2000-2016) and a subsequent shift towards their application as nanofertilizers and nanoregulators (2017-present). This transition highlights a move from understanding risks to harnessing benefits.
  • Geographic and Quality Divide: While European and Asian countries are highly active in research, the USA leads in producing high-quality, highly cited papers. This suggests a need for further collaboration and knowledge sharing to elevate the impact of research from other regions.
  • Interdisciplinary Nature: The top disciplines involved are Environmental Sciences, Chemistry, Materials Science, Nanoscience, and Plant Sciences, underscoring the inherently interdisciplinary nature of nano-agriculture.
  • Keyword Trends Reflect Progress: The evolution of keywords from "cytotoxicity" and "kinetics" to "foliar application," "green synthesis," and "plant growth" visually represents the field's progression from understanding risks to developing practical applications.

Key Results

  • Publication Volume: A total of 2,626 publications were analyzed.
  • Growth Trend: Publications and citations showed a rapid growth trend, especially after the initial decade (2000-2009).
  • Top Contributing Countries: China (727 papers), India (598 papers), and the USA (373 papers) are the leading countries in terms of publication volume. However, the USA leads in total citations (21,628) and average citations per paper (57.99).
  • Top Disciplines: Environmental Sciences (16.2%), Chemistry (15.7%), Materials Science (14.8%), Nanoscience Nanotechnology (13.7%), and Plant Sciences (7.8%) are the most prominent disciplines.
  • Leading Journals: "Nanomaterials," "Science of The Total Environment," and "Journal of Agricultural and Food Chemistry" are the top journals in this field.
  • Research Stages:
    • Stage 1 (2000-2016): Focused on the toxicology of NMs. Keywords like "Cytotoxicity," "Kinetics," and "Rapid detection" were prominent.
  • Stage 2 (2017-present): Emphasizes NMs as nanofertilizers for crop growth and nanoregulators/nanopesticides for crop resistance. Keywords like "Foliar application," "Green synthesis," and "Plant growth" have emerged as hotspots since 2021.
  • Co-cited Publications: Key co-cited papers highlight the importance of NMs for crop nutrition, protection, systemic acquired resistance, and controlled release.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Limitations:
    • The study is based on publications indexed in Web of Science, which might not capture all relevant research.
  • The analysis of keywords and co-citations provides insights into research trends but doesn't fully capture the nuances of experimental methodologies or specific findings within individual papers.
  • While the paper identifies leading countries and institutions, it acknowledges that the level of development is uneven globally.
  • Future Work: The authors propose several key areas for future research:
  • Optimization of NMs: Focus on improving the efficacy and bioavailability of NMs, including the use of green synthesis, hybrid NMs, and bioavailability enhancement strategies.
  • Rhizosphere and Phyllosphere Processes: Further investigate the behavior and bioavailability of NMs driven by rhizosphere (root-soil interactions) and phyllosphere (leaf-air interactions) processes, particularly through greenhouse and field experiments.
  • Interdisciplinary Collaboration: Enhance cooperation among institutions and authors across diverse fields (plant biology, phytopathology, materials science, microbiology, etc.) to comprehensively explore NM mechanisms in crop growth and resistance.
  • Field Applications and Long-Term Assessments: Transition NMs from laboratory settings to field trials, and conduct long-term environmental behavior and health risk assessments in diverse ecosystems. This includes evaluating potential risks to human health from direct and dietary exposure.

Summary updated

Abstract

European and Asian countries and institutions are more actively involved, although USA produces the highest-quality papers. Additionally, this field has evolved through two stages: the first stage (2000-2016) focused on the toxicology of nanomaterials (NMs), while the second stage (2017-present) emphasizes NMs as nanofertilizers to promote crop growth, and as nanoregulators or nanopesticides to enhance crop resistance against biotic stress and abiotic stress. Finally, future research perspectives were also proposed, including the optimalizations of NMs, the investigations of the behavior and bioavailability of NMs driven by rhizosphere and phyllosphere process, interdisciplinary collaboration across various fields, the application of NMs from laboratory to the field, and the long-term environmental behaviors and assessments of NMs in diverse ecosystems. Overall, this bibliometric study provides a valuable reference for understanding the development of this field and pinpointing research frontiers.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{luo2025analysis,
  author = {Xing Luo and Jing Li and Song Guo and Hua Yu and Xiangzhong Zeng and Zijun Zhou and Yuxian Shangguan and Mingjiang He and Yiting Ouyang and Kun Chen and Zhimin Chen and Yusheng Qin},
  title = {{Analysis of research status and trends on nano-agricultural application: a bibliometric study}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Plant Science},
  year = {2025},
  doi = {10.3389/fpls.2025.1530629},
}
Figure