Analysis of publications on HPV genotype co-infection: a bibliometric study on existing research

Tianyi Bi, Yingxin Gong, Jiayin Mo, Yan Wang, Wenjie Qu, Yaping Wang, Wenqian Shi, Feifei Zhang, Long Sui, Yanyun LiFrontiers in Oncology 2023 · DOI

Abstract: Over decades, epidemiological studies and mechanism investigation have been the central topics when it comes to HPV genotypes co-infection. Studies on HPV co-infection remained relatively insufficient, mainly staying at a qualitative level while detailed infection data and high-quality literature publications were still lacking valuable discussion.

Introduction

While the link between Human Papillomavirus (HPV) and cervical cancer is well-established, clinical focus has historically centered on single-genotype infections. However, patients are frequently infected with multiple HPV types simultaneously, known as co-infection. The clinical implications of these "mixed infections"—whether they act synergistically to accelerate disease or compete with one another—remain a subject of intense debate. This bibliometric study, published in Frontiers in Oncology, provides a comprehensive map of the research landscape surrounding HPV genotype co-infection over nearly 30 years.

Methodology

The researchers conducted a systematic search of the Web of Science (WOS) Core Collection for articles published between 1994 and 2022. The dataset consisted of 463 peer-reviewed articles extracted from 200 different journals, representing contributions from 78 countries.

To process the data, the authors employed:

  • VOSviewer: For constructing and visualizing bibliometric networks, such as keyword co-occurrence and citation maps.
  • Statistical Analysis: Using Excel and Originlab to track publication trends, citation counts, and geographic distribution.
  • Inclusion/Exclusion Criteria: Only original research and reviews in English or Chinese were included to ensure a focus on primary scientific contributions.

The analysis reveals a field that has grown steadily but remains a specialized niche. The United States led global contributions with 73 publications, followed by China (65) and Italy (50). PLOS ONE emerged as the most prolific publisher in this niche (29 articles), while the Journal of Medical Virology held the highest impact factor among the top five most frequent journals.

Figure 1: Annual trends in publication volume and citation counts for HPV co-infection research (1994–2022).

As shown in Figure 1, citations in this field experienced a significant surge around 2006. The authors attribute this "Vaccine Peak" to the global interest generated by the first FDA approval of an HPV vaccine that year, which spurred extensive research into genotype distribution. The most influential work identified was a 2004 study by Cuschieri et al., which investigated the diversity of multiple HPV types in routine screening and has since accumulated over 225 citations.

Thematic Evolution and Key Insights

The research landscape has undergone a significant transition in depth:

  • 1990s: Co-infection was largely a descriptive observation in epidemiological reports.
  • Post-2010: The literature shifted toward exploring the molecular mechanisms of interaction between genotypes and utilizing mathematical models to understand transmission dynamics.
  • The Synergy Debate: A recurring theme is whether co-infection increases the risk of high-grade lesions (CIN). While some studies suggest co-infection stimulates early lesions, others find no evidence that it increases the risk of progression to invasive cancer compared to single-type infections.

Keyword clustering via VOSviewer identified "Prevalence," "Population," "Genotype," and "PCR" as the most frequent terms, indicating that epidemiological distribution remains the foundational bedrock of the field.

Limitations and Future Directions

The study acknowledges limitations regarding database scope, as relying solely on Web of Science may omit relevant studies in PubMed or Scopus. Additionally, citation metrics naturally skew toward older studies, potentially under-representing the impact of recent high-quality research.

Moving forward, the authors call for a shift from qualitative observations to high-quality literature featuring detailed infection data. Future research should focus on establishing more sophisticated co-infection models to yield actionable clinical insights for vaccine development and cancer prognosis.

Summary updated

Abstract

Over decades, epidemiological studies and mechanism investigationhas been the central topics when it comes to HPV genotypes co-infection. Studies on HPV co-infection remained relatively insufficient, mainly stays in qualitative level while detailed infection data and high quality literature publications were still lack of valuable discussion.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{bi2023analysis,
  author = {Tianyi Bi and Yingxin Gong and Jiayin Mo and Yan Wang and Wenjie Qu and Yaping Wang and Wenqian Shi and Feifei Zhang and Long Sui and Yanyun Li},
  title = {{Analysis of publications on HPV genotype co-infection: a bibliometric study on existing research}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Oncology},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.3389/fonc.2023.1218744},
}
Figure