TL;DR
This paper dissects the intricate conformational change in lactate dehydrogenase (LDH) upon ligand binding, revealing a sophisticated two-hinge mechanism for a critical surface loop's closure. By employing novel fitting procedures and detailed analysis of main-chain and side-chain interactions, the authors elucidate how this loop movement propagates throughout the protein, creating concentric shells of increasing mobility.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
Proteins are not static structures; they undergo dynamic conformational changes essential for their function. A key example is the "loop closure" phenomenon, where a flexible loop moves to cover the active site after substrate binding, a crucial step in the catalytic mechanism of many enzymes. While this general principle is known, the precise molecular mechanisms driving these large-scale movements, especially the interplay of different structural elements and the distribution of deformation, remain poorly understood. This paper specifically investigates this question in lactate dehydrogenase (LDH), a well-studied enzyme, aiming to provide a detailed mechanistic explanation for its loop closure.
Methods
The authors introduce a novel "fit-all" procedure to precisely locate hinge regions within loops. This method involves systematically fitting all possible contiguous subregions of a loop between two conformations (apo and holo forms of LDH) and analyzing the resulting deviations. They also utilize established "sieve-fit" and "fit-refit" procedures to categorize structural differences at various scales, from overall protein movement to individual secondary structure elements. Beyond fitting, the analysis delves into:
- Main-chain torsion angle analysis: Examining changes in dihedral angles to understand how the protein backbone deforms.
- Side-chain analysis: Investigating packing interactions, hydrogen bonding patterns, and sequence conservation to understand how side-chains contribute to and stabilize the conformational change.
- Contact analysis: Mapping VDW contacts and hydrogen bonds to understand how the loop's motion is transmitted to other parts of the protein.
Datasets
The study utilizes crystallographic data for two forms of dogfish muscle lactate dehydrogenase:
- Apo form: The enzyme without any bound ligands.
- Ternary complex: The enzyme bound to lactate and NAD.
The coordinates for these structures were obtained from the Brookhaven Protein Data Bank. The analysis also incorporates sequence data from 17 different LDH sequences to assess evolutionary conservation.
Key Insights and Ideas
- Double-Hinge Mechanism: The critical surface loop (referred to as "the Loop") closure is not a simple bending motion but is driven by two distinct hinge regions.
- Rigid Type II Turn: A relatively rigid type II turn connects the two hinges, acting as a pivot point for the overall loop movement.
- Differential Hinge Flexibility: The first hinge exhibits fewer steric constraints and can be well-described by changes in just two torsion angles, akin to a classic hinge motion. The second hinge, however, is more constrained, involving helix stretching and splitting into α-helical and 3₁₀-helical components, with side-chain repacking playing a significant role.
- Helix Deformation: The helix (αD) connected to the second hinge undergoes significant deformation, splitting into distinct helical conformations in the two states.
- Propagated Motion: Ligand binding initiates a cascade of conformational changes. The Loop's movement, through a network of VDW contacts, propagates to other parts of the protein, creating concentric shells of increasing mobility radiating from a static core.
- Conserved Transverse Hydrogen Bonds: Transverse hydrogen bonds within the loop are remarkably conserved both within the loop's closure and across different LDH sequences, suggesting their crucial role in stabilizing the structure.
- "Cog-Hopping" Repacking: The second hinge's interaction with the adjacent helix (αH) involves a unique "cog-hopping-between-grooves" mechanism of side-chain repacking, highlighting the importance of steric interactions.
Key Results
- The Loop moves approximately 10 Å to cover the active site.
- The "fit-all" procedure identified two primary hinge regions within the Loop.
- The first hinge motion can be approximated by changing three main-chain torsion angles.
- The second hinge involves significant deformation of the αD helix, splitting into α-helical and 3₁₀-helical components.
- The protein can be divided into four concentric shells of increasing mobility, with the static core comprising helices and sheets, and the outermost shell containing major movers like the Loop and αD.
- The Loop is one of the most highly conserved substructures in LDH, with a significant proportion of its residues being totally or highly conserved.
- Five transverse hydrogen bonds within the Loop are preserved in both conformations and across various LDH sequences.
Limitations and Future Work
- Resolution Limitations: While the structures are refined, the analysis acknowledges that the resolution of the crystallographic data imposes certain limitations on the precision of the atomic positions and the interpretation of minor movements.
- Artifactual Motion: The study suggests that the motion of the βJ-α1G segment might be an artifact due to its high temperature factors and poor definition in the crystal structure.
- Focus on LDH: The detailed mechanistic insights are specific to lactate dehydrogenase. While general principles of loop closure are discussed, direct comparison to other enzymes like triose phosphate isomerase (TIM) highlights both similarities (double-hinged structure) and differences (complexity of the second hinge in LDH, more localized motion in TIM).
- Future Directions: The authors implicitly suggest that further investigations into the role of specific side-chain interactions and the propagation of motion through contact networks in other proteins would be valuable. The detailed understanding of hinge mechanisms could also inform protein engineering efforts.
Summary updated