Analysis of Parameter Matching on the Steady-State Characteristics of Permanent Magnet-Assisted Synchronous Reluctance Motors under Vector Control

Yu-Hua Lan, Wen-Jie Wan, Jin WangActuators 2024 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper delves into the critical interplay between motor design parameters – specifically back-EMF and saliency ratio – and the steady-state performance of Permanent Magnet-Assisted Synchronous Reluctance Motors (PMaSynRMs) under vector control. By developing an optimal parameter matching curve, the researchers designed and tested a 45 kW PMaSynRM that achieves IE5 efficiency, demonstrating a path towards high-performance, cost-effective electric motors without relying heavily on rare-earth magnets.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Permanent Magnet Synchronous Motors (PMSMs) offer high efficiency and power density but come with a significant cost due to rare-earth magnets. Permanent Magnet-Assisted Synchronous Reluctance Motors (PMaSynRMs) offer a compelling alternative by incorporating a smaller number of magnets to enhance the power factor and torque, while primarily relying on reluctance torque. However, the complex rotor structure of PMaSynRMs leads to a rich parameter space, making it challenging to achieve optimal performance. Specifically, understanding how the back-electromotive force (back-EMF) and the rotor's saliency ratio (the difference between d-axis and q-axis inductances) interact to influence motor characteristics like voltage, current, and power factor under different control strategies (MTPA and MTPV) is crucial for efficient design and operation. This paper aims to bridge this gap by providing a systematic analysis and an optimal parameter matching strategy.

Methods

The authors employ a multi-pronged approach:

  • Mathematical Modeling: They start with the fundamental voltage, flux linkage, and torque equations for PMaSynRMs under vector control. This forms the basis for deriving steady-state motor equations.
  • Control Strategy Analysis: The paper analyzes motor behavior under two key control strategies:
  • Maximum Torque Per Ampere (MTPA): This strategy aims to maximize torque output for a given current. The analysis focuses on how back-EMF and saliency ratio affect operating states, voltage, and current.
  • Maximum Torque Per Voltage (MTPV): This strategy is explored in the overvoltage region of MTPA, aiming to understand performance when voltage is a limiting factor.
  • Parametric Analysis: Extensive simulations are conducted by varying the back-EMF (represented by $E_0/U$) and saliency ratio ($\rho$) to generate surface and contour plots. These plots visualize the impact of these parameters on various motor characteristics like current phase angle, power angle, stator current, and voltages.
  • Optimal Parameter Matching Curve: Based on the simulation results and analysis of operating regions (low-cost-effective, low-performance, etc.), an optimal parameter matching curve is derived. This curve guides the selection of back-EMF and saliency ratio for desired performance.
  • Prototyping and Testing: A 45 kW PMaSynRM is designed, manufactured, and experimentally tested to validate the theoretical findings and the proposed optimal matching strategy.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The analysis relies on mathematical models and simulations based on motor parameters, and the experimental validation uses a custom-designed prototype.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Back-EMF and Saliency Ratio are Key: The study unequivocally demonstrates that the interplay between back-EMF and saliency ratio is paramount in determining PMaSynRM performance under vector control. These two parameters, rather than individual design choices, dictate the operating characteristics.
  • MTPA vs. MTPV Trade-offs: While MTPA is excellent for torque maximization, it can lead to overvoltage issues. MTPV offers a way to operate in higher voltage regions but might not be as torque-efficient. The paper highlights the "sweet spot" between these two strategies.
  • Optimal Operating Regions Exist: The analysis reveals distinct operating regions based on back-EMF and saliency ratio. The "low-cost-effective region" (higher back-EMF, lower saliency ratio) is identified as the target for PMaSynRMs, balancing performance with reduced magnet cost.
  • Saliency Ratio's Dual Role: A higher saliency ratio generally contributes to higher reluctance torque, but it also imposes stricter structural requirements and can lead to higher operating voltages.
  • Cost Reduction Potential: By optimizing the parameter matching, the paper shows a clear path to reducing the reliance on expensive permanent magnets, making PMaSynRMs more economically viable.

Key Results

  • The paper provides detailed contour and surface plots illustrating how back-EMF and saliency ratio influence current phase angle, power angle, stator current, d-axis and q-axis currents, and voltages under MTPA control.
  • An optimal parameter matching curve is proposed, guiding designers towards a balance of performance and cost.
  • A 45 kW PMaSynRM prototype was successfully designed and manufactured.
  • The prototype achieved an impressive IE5 energy efficiency level, reaching 96.5% efficiency.
  • The designed motor relies primarily on reluctance torque (83%), with permanent magnet torque contributing 17%, confirming its PMaSynRM nature.
  • The motor's saliency ratio was found to reach above 9 under full load conditions.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Manufacturing Constraints: The paper acknowledges that not all theoretically possible operating states can be realized in actual prototypes due to manufacturing limitations.
  • Inverter Limit: The paper discusses the challenge of high operating voltage in certain regions and suggests increasing inverter limit voltage as a solution, noting this might not be feasible for general industrial motors.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest that further research could explore the application of ferrite magnets for even greater cost reduction, particularly when the saliency ratio is above 9. The paper also implicitly points towards further optimization of rotor structures to maximize saliency ratio while maintaining structural integrity.

Summary updated

Abstract

In this paper, the impact of parameter matching on the steady-state performance of permanent magnet-assisted synchronous reluctance motors (PMaSynRM) under vector control is analyzed and discussed. First, based on the mathematical model of motors under the maximum torque per ampere (MTPA) control strategy, an analysis is conducted concerning two main parameters, i.e., the matching relationship between the back electromotive force (back-EMF) and the saliency ratio. The impact of these two parameters on the operational status of the motor is investigated. Then, the motor’s voltage operating conditions are examined, and the operating curve under minimum voltage is derived. Furthermore, in the overvoltage region under the MTPA control strategy, the operation of the motor under the maximum torque per voltage (MTPV) control strategy is explored. This analysis illuminated the patterns of influence exerted by the back-EMF and the saliency ratio on the motor’s voltage operating condition. Between these two control strategies, there remains scope for the motor to operate at its limits. An enhanced understanding of the effects of the back-EMF and saliency ratio within this range on motor performance was achieved, resulting in the optimal matching curve for the back-EMF and saliency ratio. Finally, a 45 kW PMaSynRM was designed, prototyped, and tested to validate the correctness of the design techniques, with the motor achieving IE5 efficiency.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{lan2024analysis,
  author = {Yu-Hua Lan and Wen-Jie Wan and Jin Wang},
  title = {{Analysis of Parameter Matching on the Steady-State Characteristics of Permanent Magnet-Assisted Synchronous Reluctance Motors under Vector Control}},
  booktitle = {Actuators},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.3390/act13060198},
}
Figure