Analysis of Location Selection of Public Service Facilities Based on Urban Land Accessibility

Wei Wang, Zihao Zhou, Jun Chen, Wen Cheng, Jian ChenInternational Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health 2021 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces "urban land accessibility" as a crucial metric for selecting optimal locations for public service facilities, moving beyond traditional population and GDP-based planning. By analyzing educational and medical facilities in four Chinese counties, the study demonstrates that facility type significantly influences accessibility needs and that strategically locating facilities can help reduce carbon emissions from related travel.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Rapid urbanization, particularly in developing countries, presents a significant challenge in planning and locating public service facilities like schools and hospitals. Current planning methods often rely on broad indicators such as population density and GDP, neglecting the critical role of transportation conditions and actual accessibility for residents. This oversight can lead to facilities being inconveniently located, impacting service quality and potentially increasing travel-related environmental burdens. The paper aims to bridge this gap by quantifying urban land accessibility and its correlation with different types of public service facilities.

Methods

The study employs a multi-faceted approach:

  • Urban Land Accessibility Calculation: A novel method is used to calculate urban land accessibility. This involves rasterizing urban land into grid cells and considering both internal accessibility (road network density) and external accessibility (travel time and importance of connected grids). The resulting accessibility is normalized to a 0-1 scale.
  • Spatial Connection and Data Integration: Geographic Information System (GIS) tools are used to link the locations of public service facilities with their calculated urban land accessibility values. Facility categories are assigned numerical attributes for analysis.
  • Statistical Analysis: Variance analysis (ANOVA) is the primary statistical tool used to determine the correlation between the category of public service facilities and their urban land accessibility. Normality and homogeneity of variance tests are conducted to ensure the validity of the ANOVA results.
  • Carbon Emission Correlation: A micro carbon emission model is applied to estimate emissions from facility-related trips. This model is then used to analyze the correlation between carbon emissions and urban land accessibility for different facility types.

Datasets

The study utilizes data collected from four typical counties in China, representing different climate zones: Jintang County (southwest mountainous), Qingcheng County (Loess Plateau), Changxing County (eastern coastal), and Wu'an City (North China Plain). Data collection involved:

  • Travel Surveys: 3600 facility-related travel data points were collected.
  • Questionnaire Surveys: 10,800 stated preference questionnaires from households were gathered.
  • Facility Location Data: GIS data on the locations of public service facilities.

No new benchmarks were introduced; rather, existing classification standards for urban public facilities in China were used.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Urban Land Accessibility as a Key Metric: The paper strongly advocates for urban land accessibility as a more nuanced and effective metric for facility location planning than traditional macroscopic indicators.
  • Facility-Specific Accessibility Needs: Different types of public service facilities have distinct urban land accessibility requirements. For instance, primary schools and kindergartens show a correlation between higher accessibility and higher carbon emissions, suggesting a preference for convenience.
  • Normal Distribution of Accessibility: The study found that urban land accessibility for public service facilities generally follows a normal distribution, allowing for the definition of optimal accessibility intervals.
  • Carbon Emission Reduction Potential: By strategically locating facilities within appropriate urban land accessibility ranges, carbon emissions from associated travel can be significantly reduced.

Key Results

  • Normal Distribution: The urban land accessibility of public service facility locations generally follows a normal distribution.
  • Significant Differences by Category: The study found significant differences in urban land accessibility across various categories of educational facilities (p < 0.05).
  • Town Influence Varies: The influence of county-level towns on accessibility varied. For educational facilities, towns did not significantly affect accessibility. For primary medical facilities, towns had a significant effect, while for hospitals and professional medical institutions, the effect was not significant.
  • Carbon Emission Trends:
    • Kindergartens and primary schools showed a positive correlation between accessibility and single-trip carbon emissions, suggesting convenience is prioritized.
  • Middle schools, high schools, and other education facilities, as well as hospitals and primary medical institutions, showed a negative correlation between accessibility and single-trip carbon emissions, indicating that higher accessibility leads to lower emissions, likely due to broader service areas and less frequent, more efficient travel.
  • Optimal Accessibility Ranges: Tables 18 and 19 provide corresponding ranges of comprehensive accessibility for different carbon emission levels for education and medical facilities, offering practical guidance for planners.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Sample Size Limitations: The authors acknowledge that the number of samples, particularly for certain facility types (e.g., specialist hospitals, colleges, universities), was limited, which could affect the reliability of statistical significance.
  • Generalizability: While four diverse counties were studied, the authors suggest that more data from counties in different developmental stages would strengthen the findings and improve generalizability.
  • Future Research Directions:
    • Exploring more applications of urban land accessibility in public service facility planning.
  • Investigating how transportation infrastructure improvements can enhance accessibility for specific facility types.
  • Developing more refined carbon emission models for facility-related trips.

Summary updated

Abstract

Urbanization has been a flourishing process in a wide range of developing countries. The planning and construction of public service facilities is a crucial component of this process. Existing planning methods of public service facilities focused on macroscopic indicators like population and GDP. In this way, accessibility and transportation conditions were neglected. Four typical counties in China were selected as samples where travel surveys and questionnaire surveys on public service facilities were conducted. Taking education and medical care as representative public service facilities, this study used geographic information processing to connect the locations of public service facilities at all levels with the urban land accessibility. Then, analysis of variance was used to obtain correlations between the level of public service facilities and the urban land accessibility. The results showed that the urban land accessibility of locations of public service facilities follows a normal distribution. Categories of facilities showed significant difference on urban land accessibility. Therefore, intervals of urban land accessibility of locations of public service facilities within one standard deviation from the mean were constructed by category. These intervals built a connection between transportation conditions with locations of public service facilities. Corresponding relation of carbon emission of facility-related trips and urban land accessibility was established as an example of an application. Carbon emissions caused by facility-related trips can be reduced by locating facilities at locations with appropriate urban land accessibility.
BibTeX
@article{wang2021analysis,
  author = {Wei Wang and Zihao Zhou and Jun Chen and Wen Cheng and Jian Chen},
  title = {{Analysis of Location Selection of Public Service Facilities Based on Urban Land Accessibility}},
  journal = {International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.3390/ijerph18020516},
}
Figure