Analysis of lactose metabolism in E.coli using reachability analysis of hybrid systems

Ádám Halász, Vijay Kumar, Marcin Imieliński, Călin Belta, Oleg Sokolsky, S. Pathak, Harvey RubinIET 2007 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper presents a novel method for analyzing complex biological systems, like the E.coli lactose metabolism, by approximating their continuous dynamics with simpler "hybrid systems." This approach allows for efficient analysis of system behavior and parameter robustness, particularly for understanding critical qualitative features like bistability and switching.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Modeling biological systems, especially at the molecular level, is incredibly challenging. Full dynamical descriptions using differential equations become computationally prohibitive, and many kinetic parameters are difficult to measure directly. This makes it hard to understand high-level behaviors like how a cell "switches" between different metabolic states, which are crucial for its function. The authors aim to bridge this gap by developing a method to create simplified, yet accurate, models of these complex systems that retain essential qualitative properties and allow for robust analysis, even with uncertain parameters.

Methods

The core of the paper's contribution lies in its hybrid systems approach. They take a detailed ordinary differential equation (ODE) model of the E.coli lac operon and approximate its nonlinear rate laws with continuous piecewise linear functions. This transforms the system into a hybrid system, which combines continuous dynamics within defined regions (hyper-rectangles in the state space) with discrete transitions between these regions.

The key novelty is the use of multi-affine functions for these approximations, which naturally arise from the piecewise linear functions and allow for continuous dynamics across region boundaries. This enables the application of an efficient reachability analysis algorithm. This algorithm determines which states or regions of the system are reachable from a given initial set of conditions, providing insights into system behavior and parameter dependencies.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The paper focuses on modeling and analyzing an existing biological system (E.coli lactose metabolism) using established experimental data for validation.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Hybrid Systems as a Natural Abstraction: Biological systems often exhibit both continuous (e.g., molecule concentrations) and discrete (e.g., gene "on" or "off") behaviors. Hybrid systems provide a natural framework to capture this duality.
  • Piecewise Linear Approximation for Tractability: Approximating complex nonlinear rate laws with simpler piecewise linear functions is a powerful technique to make otherwise intractable models computationally manageable.
  • Multi-affine Functions for Smoothness: Using multi-affine functions ensures continuity of dynamics across the boundaries of the approximated regions, avoiding artificial discontinuities that could lead to spurious behaviors.
  • Reachability Analysis for Qualitative Properties: Reachability analysis is a powerful tool for understanding the potential outcomes of a system and how these outcomes depend on initial conditions and parameters, especially for qualitative behaviors like bistability and switching.
  • Basal Rate's Critical Role in Induction: The paper highlights that the basal transcription rate of mRNA is not just a minor parameter but is critical for the possibility of induction in the lac operon system. Without a sufficient basal rate, the cell may not be able to switch to a high metabolism state, even with sufficient lactose.

Key Results

  • The proposed hybrid system model accurately reproduces the qualitative predictions of the original, more complex ODE model for the lac operon, including its bistability and switching behavior.
  • The hybrid model's quantitative predictions (e.g., steady-state values, time evolution) are comparable to those of the original model and experimental data, with discrepancies often within the range of experimental uncertainty (around 5%).
  • The reachability analysis successfully identified parameter ranges for which the system exhibits bistability and switching, and importantly, demonstrated that the basal transcription rate plays a crucial role in enabling induction.
  • The computational cost of reachability analysis using this method is significantly lower than performing numerous ODE simulations, making it a more efficient tool for exploring parameter spaces and system behaviors.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Conservative Approximations: Reachability analysis, as implemented, provides a conservative approximation of the reachable set. This means it might overestimate the set of reachable states, leading to "false positives" (states identified as reachable that are not). The authors acknowledge this and suggest that further refinements to the algorithm and partition choices can mitigate this.
  • Parameter Uncertainty: While the method is designed to handle parameter uncertainty, the analysis of parameter variations is still an active area. The paper demonstrates robustness to small parameter changes but notes that more rigorous analytical guarantees are needed.
  • High Dimensionality: The computational cost of the method scales exponentially with the number of variables, posing a challenge for very large biological networks.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest further research into refining the reachability algorithm for better precision and efficiency, exploring its application to other biological systems, and integrating it more closely with experimental validation. They also highlight the need for automated model analysis tools to aid in understanding complex biological networks.

Summary updated

Abstract

We propose an abstraction method for medium-scale biomolecular networks, based on hybrid dynamical systems with continuous multi-affine dynamics. This abstraction method follows naturally from the notion of approximating nonlinear rate laws with continuous piecewise linear functions and can be easily automated. An efficient reachability algorithm is possible for the resulting class of hybrid systems. An efficient reachability algorithm is possible for the resulting class of hybrid systems. An approximation for an ordinary differential equation model of the lac operon is constructed, and it is shown that the abstraction passes the same experimental tests as were used to validate the original model. The well studied biological system exhibits bistability and switching behaviour, arising from positive feedback in the expression mechanism of the lac operon. The switching property of the lac system is an example of the major qualitative features that are the building blocks of higher level, more coarse-grained descriptions. The present approach is useful in helping to correctly identify such properties and in connecting them to the underlying molecular dynamical details. Reachability analysis together with the knowledge of the steady-state structure are used to identify ranges of parameter values for which the system maintains the bistable switching property.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{halasz2007analysis,
  author = {Ádám Halász and Vijay Kumar and Marcin Imieliński and Călin Belta and Oleg Sokolsky and S. Pathak and Harvey Rubin},
  title = {{Analysis of lactose metabolism in E.coli using reachability analysis of hybrid systems}},
  booktitle = {IET},
  year = {2007},
  doi = {10.1049/iet-syb:20060035},
}
Figure