Analysis of interturn short circuit in regulating winding of power transformer based on field-circuit coupling

Liangchang Fei, Zhiqin Ma, Linglong Cai, Dan Zhou, Xiang Shu, Zihao Liao, Chunyao Lin, Xianqiang LiFrontiers in Energy Research 2024 · DOI

This study, recently published in Frontiers in Energy Research, provides a deep dive into a specific and often overlooked vulnerability in power grid infrastructure: interturn short circuits in the "untapped" portions of transformer regulating windings.

TL;DR

Researchers developed a validated 3D field-circuit coupled model to show that interturn short circuits in unconnected regulating windings can still generate currents tens of times higher than rated values. These faults cause massive spikes in leakage magnetic flux and electromagnetic forces, providing a new roadmap for diagnosing "invisible" internal transformer failures.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Power transformers use regulating windings to adjust voltage levels by "tapping" into different sections of the coil. While most research focuses on faults in the active (connected) windings, very little is known about what happens when a short circuit occurs in the portion of the winding that is currently not connected to the circuit.

Because these sections are "dead" (unconnected), engineers might assume they are less risky. However, they still reside within the transformer's intense magnetic circuit. This paper addresses the lack of data on the transient electromagnetic processes and mechanical stresses that occur during a fault in these untapped sections, which can lead to catastrophic transformer failure without warning.

Methods

The authors employed a field-circuit coupled 3D finite element model.

  • The "Field" side: A high-fidelity 3D geometric model of a 220kV three-phase five-column transformer was built to simulate magnetic flux density and electromagnetic force distribution.
  • The "Circuit" side: An external circuit model was linked to the 3D model to simulate the real-world electrical environment of a substation.
  • Validation: Unlike many purely theoretical papers, the authors validated their model against actual fault recording data from a real-world transformer trip-off event caused by moisture infiltration in a high-voltage bushing.

Datasets

The study uses the electrical and dimensional parameters of a specific SFSZ9-240000/220 power transformer. The primary "dataset" for validation consists of the transient voltage and current waveforms recorded by substation monitoring equipment during an actual phase-B regulating winding fault.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Induction is a Powerful Force: The most striking insight is that even though the shorted turns are not electrically connected to the high-voltage source, they form a low-impedance loop. Through electromagnetic induction, this "dead" loop can draw massive amounts of energy, resulting in a fault current (up to 61.1 kA in this case) that is tens of times the rated current.
  • The Force Migration: Under normal operation, the highest electromagnetic force density usually resides in the medium-voltage windings. During this specific fault, the "hot spot" for mechanical stress shifts entirely to the short-circuited turns in the regulating winding.
  • The Short-Circuit Ratio Paradox: The researchers found that as the number of shorted turns increases, the peak current in the shorted ring actually decreases (due to increased impedance). However, the total radial and axial forces acting on the winding continue to rise, increasing the risk of physical deformation or "winding collapse."
  • Leakage Flux as a Diagnostic Fingerprint: The fault causes the highest radial leakage magnetic flux density to shift and increase by nearly 8 times (from 30.5 mT to 240 mT). This suggests that internal magnetic sensors could potentially detect these faults before they lead to total failure.

Key Results

  • Model Accuracy: The simulated voltage and current waveforms showed high consistency with actual fault records, with average voltage errors ($U_o$) staying within manageable ranges (4–6.5 kV on the HV side).
  • Current Spikes: In the simulated fault, the short-circuited ring reached a peak current of 61.1 kA.
  • Mechanical Stress: The maximum electromagnetic force density reached 47.4 MN/m³, significantly higher than any other location in the transformer.
  • Flux Intensity: Axial leakage magnetic flux in the middle of the regulating winding reached a maximum of 857 mT during the fault, compared to much lower values during normal operation.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge that this study is primarily a simulation-based analysis of a single, specific fault scenario. While the model is validated against real-world data, the physical complexity of spiral windings—where parallel wires undergo permutation—is simplified in the 3D model to make it computationally feasible.

Future Work: The researchers suggest that future studies should combine these simulations with controlled physical experiments on scaled-down transformers to further refine the "diagnostic fingerprints" of these faults. This could eventually lead to real-time AI-driven monitoring systems that can identify insulation degradation in regulating windings before a short circuit occurs.

Summary updated

Abstract

The interturn short circuit fault is one of the common faults in power transformers. At present, research on interturn short circuit faults focuses on high, medium, and low voltage windings, while there is relatively little research on interturn short circuit in regulating windings. Specifically, there is a lack of reported studies on the transient electromagnetic processes, magnetic field distribution, and electromagnetic force characteristics of interturn short circuits in regulating windings unconnected to the circuit. This study presents an actual fault scenario involving interturn short circuits occurring in the untapped portion of the regulating windings of a specific power transformer. A field-circuit coupled model was established to analyze the transient electromagnetic processes during the fault, and the model’s effectiveness was validated by comparing its results with actual fault recording data. Additionally, the magnetic field distribution and electromagnetic force characteristics during the fault were analyzed, and discussions were carried out regarding various ratios of short-circuit turns in the regulating windings. The results indicate that even when an interturn short circuit occurs in the portion of the regulating winding that is not connected to the circuit, the current in the short-circuited turns can reach several tens of times the rated value. Additionally, the leakage magnetic field and the electromagnetic force experienced by the short-circuited ring also increase significantly. The short-circuit ratio has a significant impact on the current of the short-circuited ring, leakage magnetic field intensity, and electromagnetic force. This study contributes to a better understanding of the impact of interturn short-circuit faults in the untapped portion of the regulating windings, offering crucial technical support for fault diagnosis and prevention of power transformers.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{fei2024analysis,
  author = {Liangchang Fei and Zhiqin Ma and Linglong Cai and Dan Zhou and Xiang Shu and Zihao Liao and Chunyao Lin and Xianqiang Li},
  title = {{Analysis of interturn short circuit in regulating winding of power transformer based on field-circuit coupling}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Energy Research},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.3389/fenrg.2024.1393436},
}
Figure