TL;DR
This paper develops a comprehensive evaluation system for hazardous waste management in China's oil and gas industry, applying a life-cycle management concept and a combined AHP-entropy weight method. The goal is to help enterprises improve their hazardous waste management capabilities and promote sustainable development.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
The oil and gas industry in China generates a significant amount of hazardous waste, posing substantial environmental risks. Existing hazardous waste management policies and practices in this sector are criticized for lacking a long-term, systematic mechanism, immature treatment technologies, and insufficient inter-industry coordination. Furthermore, the current management often focuses on the end-of-pipe treatment rather than a holistic, life-cycle approach. This paper aims to address these shortcomings by identifying key management elements and proposing a robust evaluation framework to assess and improve the hazardous waste management capacity of oil and gas enterprises.
Methods
The study employs a multi-faceted approach:
- Policy Analysis: A textual analysis of Chinese hazardous waste management policies (2000-2021) was conducted to identify core subject terms and understand the policy landscape. This involved extracting high-frequency words and analyzing their co-occurrence to map the relationships between different policy elements.
- Literature Review: Existing literature on hazardous waste management and life-cycle management was reviewed to inform the development of the evaluation framework.
- Life-Cycle Management Concept: The paper integrates the principles of life-cycle management, considering hazardous waste from generation through to disposal, to ensure a comprehensive view.
- AHP-Entropy Weight Method: A novel evaluation index system was constructed using a combination of the Analytic Hierarchy Process (AHP) and the entropy weight method.
- AHP was used to incorporate expert judgment and determine subjective weights for different indicators.
- The entropy weight method was applied to objectively determine indicator weights based on the information content of the data, thus balancing subjective and objective weighting.
- Index System Construction: A three-level hierarchical index system was developed, comprising first-level indicators (Coherence, Institutional, Adequacy, Energy Use, Production Technique, Emission Disposal, Environmental Benefit), second-level indicators, and third-level indicators, to systematically evaluate management capabilities.
Datasets
The study utilized the following data sources:
- Chinese Hazardous Waste Management Policy Texts: A collection of 58 policy documents issued by the central government between 2000 and 2021.
- Corporate Reports: Oil and gas corporate social responsibility reports, environmental, social, and governance reports, sustainable development reports, and corporate annual reports were consulted.
- Empirical Data: Data from the annual reports of four selected oil and gas enterprises for the year 2021 were used for empirical analysis.
- Expert Judgments: Ten professional oil and gas industry practitioners and scientific researchers provided scores for the importance of indicators.
Key Insights and Ideas
- Holistic Life-Cycle Approach is Crucial: The paper strongly advocates for moving beyond end-of-pipe solutions and embracing a life-cycle perspective for hazardous waste management, emphasizing that focusing solely on disposal is insufficient.
- Integrated Policy Analysis Reveals Key Themes: The co-term network analysis of policy texts highlights the interconnectedness of concepts like "treatment," "facility," "management," "standard," and "utilization" in China's hazardous waste policy.
- AHP-Entropy Weight Method Balances Subjectivity and Objectivity: Combining expert opinion (AHP) with data-driven insights (entropy weight) provides a more robust and reliable evaluation of complex management systems.
- Specific Challenges in Oil and Gas: The paper identifies unique challenges in the oil and gas sector, such as the particularity of waste types (e.g., oil sludge) and the need for specialized treatment technologies.
- Need for Enhanced Supervision and Information Sharing: The analysis points to the necessity of strengthening supervision mechanisms, improving information sharing among enterprises and departments, and developing better hazardous waste tracking platforms.
Key Results
- A three-level evaluation index system for hazardous waste management capacity in oil and gas enterprises was successfully constructed.
- The AHP-entropy weight method was applied to evaluate four sample oil and gas enterprises.
- Enterprise E2 demonstrated the highest hazardous waste management capability among the four, exhibiting a leading comprehensive disposal capacity and advanced production technology.
- The ranking of the four enterprises was E2 > E4 > E3 > E1, indicating varying levels of management effectiveness.
Limitations and Future Work
- Potential Impact of Economic and Technical Factors: The authors acknowledge that economic and technical factors should be more thoroughly considered in future research, particularly regarding the cost-effectiveness of hazardous waste disposal projects.
- Need for Field Investigation: Future work could benefit from field investigations to gather more direct and contextualized data.
- Dynamic Evaluation System: The authors suggest that the evaluation index system should be continuously revised and adapted to real-world situations to enhance its applicability.
- Data Availability: The paper notes that the data used for empirical analysis are not publicly available due to privacy or ethical restrictions.
- Future Research Directions: Future research should explore the integration of "reduction, resourcefulness, and harmlessness" principles into oil and gas development, and investigate the potential of intelligent environmental protection construction management patterns.
Summary updated