Analysis of Genetic Diversity in Coilia nasus Based on 2b-RAD Simplified Genome Sequencing

Yu Li, Jianhua Chen, Guangpeng Feng, Qingyun Wang, Rulong Xia, Chao Song, Haihua Wang, Yanping ZhangWater 2023 · DOI

TL;DR

This study uses 2b-RAD sequencing to analyze the genetic diversity of the critically important migratory fish, Coilia nasus, across four key locations in China. The findings reveal high genetic diversity but concerningly low genetic purity, suggesting potential hybridization and the urgent need for targeted conservation efforts to restore the species' genetic integrity.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Coilia nasus, a valuable migratory fish species, faces significant resource decline due to overfishing, pollution, and habitat degradation. Understanding its genetic diversity is crucial for effective conservation and resource management. However, previous studies on C. nasus genetic diversity have been limited, often relying on less comprehensive markers like mitochondrial DNA or microsatellites, and have lacked detailed analysis of populations across its wide migratory range, particularly in offshore areas. This paper aims to fill this gap by employing a more powerful genomic approach to assess genetic variation and differentiation among key populations, providing a scientific basis for conservation strategies.

Methods

The researchers utilized 2b-RAD (two bipartite-recognition restriction-site associated DNA sequencing), a simplified genome sequencing technology. This method involves:

  • Library Preparation: DNA from C. nasus muscle tissue was fragmented using restriction enzymes (BsaXI) and ligated with adapters.
  • Sequencing: Paired-end sequencing was performed on a HiSeq X-Ten platform.
  • Data Filtering: Low-quality sequences and those without restriction sites were removed.
  • SNP Discovery and Genotyping: High-quality reads were aligned to a reference genome (or constructed reference sequences) to identify Single Nucleotide Polymorphisms (SNPs). The BWA (Burrows–Wheeler Aligner) mem program was used for alignment, and SNP genotyping was performed using maximum likelihood.
  • Data Analysis: Standard population genetics parameters were calculated using software like GATK, Vcftools, and Genepop. These included expected heterozygosity (He), observed heterozygosity (Ho), nucleotide diversity (Pi), and the inbreeding coefficient (FIS). Genetic differentiation was assessed using the FST index. Phylogenetic relationships were explored using Principal Component Analysis (PCA) and a phylogenetic tree reconstruction.

The 2b-RAD approach is highlighted as being particularly suitable for species without a reference genome and as a cost-effective method for SNP development in non-model organisms.

Datasets

The study collected samples from four distinct locations:

  • Shengsi Sea area
  • Yangtze River estuary
  • Taizhou section of the Yangtze River
  • Poyang Lake

A total of 40 C. nasus individuals were collected from each location, with morphological measurements (body length, body weight) and sex recorded. Genomic DNA was extracted from muscle tissue. Two samples from the Taizhou location were excluded due to poor preservation.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • High Genetic Diversity, Low Purity: The study found that while C. nasus populations exhibit high genetic diversity, indicating adaptability, their genetic purity is low. This suggests a significant degree of hybridization or admixture with other populations, potentially including cultured or settled individuals.
  • Implications of Admixture: The low purity raises concerns about the long-term viability of distinct C. nasus lineages and the potential dilution of unique genetic adaptations. This highlights the need to distinguish between wild migratory populations and other genetic sources.
  • Moderate Genetic Differentiation: The FST values indicate moderate genetic differentiation among the four sampled populations. This suggests some level of isolation but also ongoing gene flow, preventing the formation of completely independent populations.
  • Potential for Shared Spawning Grounds: The observed genetic patterns, combined with existing knowledge of C. nasus ecology, lead to the speculation that these populations may share common spawning grounds, despite temporal and spatial differences in their migratory breeding.
  • "Transition Bias" in SNPs: The analysis revealed a "transition bias" in SNP mutation types (TS/TV ratio of 1.237), which is higher than the theoretical expectation. This bias is attributed to differences in habitats, evolutionary history, and selection pressures across populations.

Key Results

  • SNP Identification: 63,110 SNP sites were successfully screened across the four populations.
  • Genetic Diversity Metrics:
    • Expected heterozygosity (He) ranged from 0.146 to 0.273.
  • Observed heterozygosity (Ho) ranged from 0.727 to 0.854.
  • Nucleotide diversity (Pi) ranged from 0.177 to 0.332.
  • Inbreeding coefficient (FIS) was positive across all populations (0.204–0.271), with the Shengsi Sea area population showing the highest degree of inbreeding.
  • Genetic Differentiation: FST values ranged from 0.112 to 0.142, indicating moderate genetic differentiation among the populations.
  • Population Structure: PCA and phylogenetic analyses showed that while there was some clustering, individuals from different populations largely overlapped, with only one individual from Poyang Lake appearing somewhat isolated. This supports the notion of moderate differentiation and gene exchange.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Genetic Purity: The paper explicitly states that the genetic purity of the four populations is not high, necessitating further efforts to increase it. This is a significant limitation for conservation if distinct genetic resources are being diluted.
  • Limited Geographic Scope: While four key locations were sampled, the study acknowledges that C. nasus has a wide distribution, and further sampling across its entire range would provide a more complete picture.
  • Speculative Spawning Grounds: The conclusion about shared spawning grounds is based on genetic data and existing knowledge, but direct confirmation is lacking.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest that future research could employ stable isotope studies on fish otoliths to more definitively explore spawning grounds, complementing the genetic findings. They also emphasize the need for conservation measures to protect water areas and reduce gene exchange between migratory and cultured individuals to restore the purity of C. nasus resources.

Summary updated

Abstract

In the protection of migratory species, Coilia nasus has always been a research topic of very high interest in various countries because of the high economic value and the serious decline of resources. In this study, C. nasus were collected from the Shengsi Sea area, the Yangtze River estuary, the Taizhou section of the Yangtze River and Poyang Lake. By using 2b-RAD simplified genome sequencing technology, 63,110 SNP sites were screened, and the genetic diversity of each population was analyzed with SNP markers. The results showed that (1) the genetic purity of the four groups of populations was not high, with the need to further increase levels of genetic purity; (2) the genetic diversity in the four populations was high, indicating that they had strong adaptability to environmental changes and could easily expand their distribution and resource growth; (3) the FST values (0.112–0.142) of the four populations were higher, indicating that there was moderate genetic differentiation, but no independent population was formed. This study speculated that these migratory species may have the same spawning grounds and pointed out that the gene purity of C. nasus may have been polluted, and it is urgent to improve the purity in the protection of migratory C. nasus.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{li2023analysis,
  author = {Yu Li and Jianhua Chen and Guangpeng Feng and Qingyun Wang and Rulong Xia and Chao Song and Haihua Wang and Yanping Zhang},
  title = {{Analysis of Genetic Diversity in Coilia nasus Based on 2b-RAD Simplified Genome Sequencing}},
  booktitle = {Water},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.3390/w15061173},
}
Figure