Abstract
The international regional economic integration is developing to a broader and higher standard. The BRICS countries have been cooperating for a long time. As the representatives of the emerging economies of the world, the establishment of a free trade zone by the BRICS can not only promote economic and trade growth among the BRICS members, but also help the developing countries to speak in the new round of international economic and trade rules reshaping. Based on the above background, this paper uses the GTAP-E model to simulate the economic effects of the BRICS free trade area with the zero tariff and exception sectors scenarios to simulate the expected economic effects of the BRICS free trade area. The construction of the BRICS free trade zone has brought different impacts on different industries of member countries, and the overall optimization and adjustment in the direction of their respective comparative advantages. Resource integration in the industrial sector can increase productivity in BRICS countries.
Introduction: The Strategic Necessity of a BRICS FTZ
As developed nations establish high-standard international trade rules (such as the TPP or US-EU agreements), emerging economies risk being marginalized in the global trade landscape. The BRICS nations—Brazil, Russia, India, China, and South Africa—represent 40% of the world's population and 20% of its GDP. Despite their collective weight, they currently lack a substantive, unified economic cooperation mechanism. This study investigates the potential outcomes of removing trade barriers among these five diverse economies, quantifying shifts in GDP, social welfare, and industrial output to evaluate the viability of a BRICS Free Trade Zone (FTZ).
Methodology and Data Aggregation
The research utilizes the GTAP-E (Global Trade Analysis Project - Energy) model, a multi-country, multi-sector Computable General Equilibrium (CGE) model. The "E" variant is particularly significant as it incorporates energy-substitution data, providing a more robust analysis of trade in energy-intensive sectors.
The study employs the GTAP 10.0 database (base year 2014), aggregating 141 countries into 10 major groups and 65 industrial sectors into 5 primary product categories: Agriculture, Processed Food, Manufacturing, Energy Intensive, and Services.
Two policy scenarios are simulated:
- Scenario 1 (Idealistic): 100% removal of all import tariffs on goods traded between BRICS members.
- Scenario 2 (Realistic): Retaining "sensitive industries" with only a 50% tariff reduction in those sectors (e.g., Brazilian agriculture, Russian manufacturing), while others are eliminated.
Macroeconomic Results: Growth and Welfare
The simulation reveals that a BRICS FTZ would act as a catalyst for specialization based on comparative advantage. However, the benefits are not uniform across all member states.
Under Scenario 1, Brazil (+0.53%), China (+0.47%), and South Africa (+0.53%) experience notable GDP growth. Conversely, Russia (-0.18%) and India (-0.2%) see slight contractions. For Russia, this is attributed to an over-reliance on resource industries where pricing power remains concentrated in developed nations. For India, intense competition from other BRICS members leads to a deterioration in terms of trade.
Despite these GDP fluctuations, "social welfare" (measured by Equivalent Variation) generally increases for all members. China emerges as the primary beneficiary, with a welfare increase of $16.7 billion in Scenario 2. This suggests that consumers across the bloc benefit from lower-priced imports even when domestic production in specific sectors faces competitive pressure.
Sectoral Impacts and the Specialization Shift
The FTZ encourages resources to re-allocate toward each country's strengths. Brazil leans further into agriculture and food processing, while China consolidates its manufacturing dominance.
As shown in the sectoral data, the establishment of the FTZ generally leads to output growth in key sectors for BRICS nations while causing slight declines in the same sectors for non-member developed economies like the USA, UK, and EU-27. This highlights the potential for the BRICS bloc to reshape global supply chains.
Strategic Implications and Limitations
The study suggests that Scenario 2—retaining some protection for sensitive sectors—is more aligned with the actual interests of member states, providing a necessary buffer for industrial adjustment.
However, several limitations remain. The 2014 base year does not account for recent global shocks like the COVID-19 pandemic or the expansion to "BRICS+". Furthermore, developing countries still face challenges in forming complete industrial chains to compete with Western supply networks. Future cooperation should focus on upgrading industrial structures and building high-tech collaborative networks rather than merely trading raw materials for finished goods.
Summary updated