Analysis of deletion breakpoints from 1,092 humans reveals details of mutation mechanisms

Alexej Abyzov, Shantao Li, Daniel Kim, Marghoob Mohiyuddin, Adrian M. Stütz, Nicholas F. Parrish, Xinmeng Jasmine Mu, Wyatt T. Clark, Ken Chen, Matthew E. Hurles, Jan O. Korbel, Hugo Y. K. Lam, Charles Lee, Mark GersteinNature Communications 2015 · DOI

Abstract

Investigating genomic structural variants at basepair resolution is crucial for understanding their formation mechanisms. We identify and analyse 8,943 deletion breakpoints in 1,092 samples from the 1000 Genomes Project. We find breakpoints have more nearby SNPs and indels than the genomic average, likely a consequence of relaxed selection. By investigating the correlation of breakpoints with DNA methylation, Hi-C interactions, and histone marks and the substitution patterns of nucleotides near them, we find that breakpoints with the signature of non-allelic homologous recombination (NAHR) are associated with open chromatin. We hypothesize that some NAHR deletions occur without DNA replication and cell division, in embryonic and germline cells. In contrast, breakpoints associated with non-homologous (NH) mechanisms often have sequence microinsertions, templated from later replicating genomic sites, spaced at two characteristic distances from the breakpoint. These microinsertions are consistent with template-switching events and suggest a particular spatiotemporal configuration for DNA during the events.

Introduction

While single-nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs) are well-studied, structural variants (SVs)—large-scale deletions, insertions, and rearrangements—affect a larger fraction of the human genome. However, SVs are notoriously difficult to map at basepair resolution using standard short-read sequencing. This study addresses the lack of a high-precision, large-scale map of these breakpoints. Without knowing exactly where a deletion starts and ends, it is impossible to determine the underlying biological mechanism that caused it. Understanding these mechanisms is critical for studying evolution, phenotypic variation, and the origins of genetic diseases.

Methodology and Data Integration

The researchers developed a sophisticated pipeline to move from "noisy" structural variant calls to high-confidence breakpoints. Central to this was BreakSeq2, an updated junction-mapping algorithm that uses a library of known and predicted breakpoints to genotype SVs rapidly. To ensure biological accuracy, they implemented an empirical null model using simulated "null junctions" to filter out false positives.

Figure 1: The breakpoint identification pipeline (a, b) and the resulting distribution of deletion sizes and mechanisms across different datasets (c).

The study integrated genomic data from 1,092 individuals (1000 Genomes Project Phase 1) with multi-omics data from the ENCODE project and the Roadmap Epigenomics Mapping Consortium. This allowed the team to correlate physical breakpoint locations with DNA methylation, 3D chromatin structure (Hi-C), and histone marks.

Characterizing Deletion Mechanisms

The analysis identified 8,943 high-confidence deletion breakpoints, classified into three primary origins: Non-Homologous (NH, 61%), Transposable Element Insertions (TEI, 25%), and Non-Allelic Homologous Recombination (NAHR, 13%).

Relaxed Selection and Molecular Fingerprints

A key finding was that breakpoints tend to have a higher density of nearby SNPs and indels compared to the genomic average. This suggests these regions are under "relaxed selection," meaning these parts of the genome can tolerate more mutations without harming the organism, effectively becoming hotspots for structural change.

Figure 2: Analysis of SNP density and conservation scores (a) alongside specific nucleotide substitution patterns (b) near breakpoints for different mutation mechanisms.

Mechanism-Specific Insights

  • NAHR and Open Chromatin: Contrary to the belief that NAHR occurs primarily during meiosis, these breakpoints were enriched in open chromatin and active histone marks. This suggests some NAHR deletions may occur in embryonic or germline cells triggered by transcriptional activity rather than standard replication.
  • NH and Template-Switching: Non-homologous deletions often featured "microinsertions" copied from later-replicating genomic regions. The specific distances of these jumps (often 20–60 bp or 2–6 kb) suggest a 3D DNA configuration, such as a loop, where replication machinery "trips" and grabs a sequence from a nearby strand.

Conclusion and Future Directions

This high-resolution map provides a precision rate of over 98% and reveals that over half of the identified deletions intersect known genes. While short-read sequencing limits the visibility of highly repetitive regions, this work establishes a framework for using "molecular fingerprints" to understand genomic instability. Future research using long-read technology will likely expand this map to even more complex variants like duplications and inversions.

Summary updated

Abstract

Investigating genomic structural variants at basepair resolution is crucial for understanding their formation mechanisms. We identify and analyse 8,943 deletion breakpoints in 1,092 samples from the 1000 Genomes Project. We find breakpoints have more nearby SNPs and indels than the genomic average, likely a consequence of relaxed selection. By investigating the correlation of breakpoints with DNA methylation, Hi-C interactions, and histone marks and the substitution patterns of nucleotides near them, we find that breakpoints with the signature of non-allelic homologous recombination (NAHR) are associated with open chromatin. We hypothesize that some NAHR deletions occur without DNA replication and cell division, in embryonic and germline cells. In contrast, breakpoints associated with non-homologous (NH) mechanisms often have sequence microinsertions, templated from later replicating genomic sites, spaced at two characteristic distances from the breakpoint. These microinsertions are consistent with template-switching events and suggest a particular spatiotemporal configuration for DNA during the events.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{abyzov2015analysis,
  author = {Alexej Abyzov and Shantao Li and Daniel Kim and Marghoob Mohiyuddin and Adrian M. Stütz and Nicholas F. Parrish and Xinmeng Jasmine Mu and Wyatt T. Clark and Ken Chen and Matthew E. Hurles and Jan O. Korbel and Hugo Y. K. Lam and Charles Lee and Mark Gerstein},
  title = {{Analysis of deletion breakpoints from 1,092 humans reveals details of mutation mechanisms}},
  booktitle = {Nature Communications},
  year = {2015},
  doi = {10.1038/ncomms8256},
}
Figure