Analysis of 22-year Drought Characteristics in Heilongjiang Province Based on Temperature Vegetation Drought Index

Li Wu, Youzhi Zhang, Limin Wang, Wenhuan Xie, Lijuan Song, Haifeng Zhang, Hongwen Bi, Yanyan Zheng, Yu Zhang, Xiaofei Zhang, Yan Li, Zhiqun LvComputational 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This study analyzes 22 years of drought characteristics in Heilongjiang Province, China, a major grain-producing region, using the Temperature Vegetation Drought Index (TVDI) derived from MODIS data. The findings reveal that medium drought is prevalent, with significant regional variations and seasonal patterns, highlighting the need for targeted drought management strategies to ensure food security and ecosystem health.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Heilongjiang Province, a critical component of China's food security, is increasingly vulnerable to agricultural drought due to rising temperatures and uneven precipitation, exacerbated by climate change. Previous drought monitoring efforts often relied on limited meteorological station data, which struggled to capture the full spatial and temporal complexity of drought across diverse agricultural regions. This paper addresses the need for a comprehensive, high-resolution analysis of drought characteristics in Heilongjiang Province, focusing on its cultivated lands, to inform better agricultural practices, early warning systems, and land management strategies.

Methods

The core of this research lies in the application and analysis of the Temperature Vegetation Drought Index (TVDI). TVDI is a drought monitoring index that leverages the relationship between vegetation health (measured by NDVI) and land surface temperature (LST). The authors utilized MODIS Terra NDVI (MOD13A2) and LST (MOD11A2) products from 2000 to 2021.

Key methodological steps included:

  • TVDI Calculation: The TVDI was calculated by establishing a triangular feature space between NDVI and LST. The "dry edge" and "wet edge" of this space were determined to represent the maximum and minimum LST for a given NDVI value, respectively. These edges were then used to derive the TVDI formula, which quantifies drought severity on a scale from 0 to 1.
  • Drought Classification: The TVDI values were categorized into five drought levels: normal, light drought, medium drought, severe drought, and extreme drought, with specific thresholds adapted for Heilongjiang Province.
  • Spatial and Temporal Analysis: The study analyzed the average TVDI and TVDI range (interannual variation) across the province and its four defined agricultural regions (Daxing'an Mountain and Xiaoxing'an Mountain, Sanjiang Plain, Zhangguangcai Mountains, and Songnen Plain). Monthly and annual drought characteristics were investigated.
  • Drought Frequency Analysis: The occurrence frequency of drought events was calculated over the 22-year period to identify areas with persistent drought conditions.
  • Comparison with SPEI: The TVDI method was compared with the Standardized Precipitation Evapotranspiration Index (SPEI) to validate its effectiveness and highlight its advantages in capturing spatial drought dynamics.

Datasets

  • MODIS Terra NDVI (MOD13A2): Global 1 km 16-day vegetation index data from 2000-2021.
  • MODIS Terra Surface Temperature (MOD11A2): Global 1 km 8-day surface temperature/emissivity data from 2000-2021.
  • MODIS Collection 5.1 Land Use/Land Cover (MCD12Q1): Used to identify cultivated land areas.
  • Meteorological Data: Monthly average temperature and precipitation data from weather stations (2000-2019) obtained from the China Meteorological Data Sharing Network.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • TVDI's Superiority for Regional Drought: The study strongly advocates for TVDI over traditional meteorological indices like SPEI for regional drought monitoring. TVDI's ability to provide full spatial coverage, unlike point-based meteorological data, is crucial for understanding drought across diverse landscapes.
  • Prevalence of Medium Drought: Medium drought is the dominant drought category in Heilongjiang Province, affecting approximately 70% of cultivated land over the 22-year period. This suggests a persistent, moderate level of water stress across the region.
  • Seasonal Drought Patterns are Critical: Spring (May-June) emerges as a particularly vulnerable period, especially in Region IV (Songnen Plain), where drought intensity and frequency are highest, significantly impacting crop germination and early growth. Autumn (September) also sees widespread drought, though generally less severe, which can aid crop maturity. Summer is relatively humid.
  • Regional Disparities in Drought Vulnerability: Songnen Plain (Region IV) stands out as a typical arid area with high drought intensity and frequency year-round, particularly in its western parts. Sanjiang Plain (Region II) also exhibits significant drought occurrences, especially in its central areas. Regions I and III experience less severe and less frequent drought.
  • Drought Severity Shift: The period from 2000-2009 experienced more severe drought conditions compared to 2010-2021, which saw an alleviation, likely due to increased rainfall despite rising temperatures.

Key Results

  • Medium Drought Dominance: Medium drought accounted for approximately 70% of the total cultivated land in Heilongjiang Province from 2000-2021.
  • High Drought Frequency: About 63.84% of the cultivated land experienced more than 60 drought occurrences over the 110 months of the crop growing season (May-September) between 2000 and 2021.
  • Regional Drought Hotspots: The western part of Region IV and the middle of Region II experienced over 80 drought occurrences.
  • Seasonal Drought Intensity: In spring (May), severe and extreme drought areas accounted for 25% of the province, decreasing to 22% in June.
  • TVDI vs. SPEI Correlation: A significant negative correlation (R = -0.6, P < 0.01) was found between monthly TVDI and SPEI, validating TVDI's ability to reflect drought conditions.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Data Limitations: The study acknowledges that the analysis is limited by the available remote sensing data, particularly its age. Future work could involve incorporating newer, higher-resolution data.
  • Crop-Specific Analysis: The current study focuses on cultivated land broadly. Future research could delve into analyzing drought impacts on different crop types and their specific responses to varying drought conditions.
  • Artificial Intelligence Integration: The authors suggest exploring artificial intelligence and machine learning methods to extract more detailed information from remote sensing data and to better understand the response of crops and ecosystems to drought.
  • Broader Influencing Factors: While the study highlights climate and precipitation, future work could incorporate social, human, and other environmental factors to provide a more holistic understanding of drought dynamics.
  • Precision Irrigation Guidance: The findings are intended to guide high-standard farmland precision irrigation, improve crop yield, and ensure national food security, indicating a direct application for agricultural management.

Summary updated

Abstract

Heilongjiang Province is the main grain producing region in China and an important part of Northeast China Plain, which is one of the three black soil belts in the world. The cultivated region of black soil accounts for 50.6% of the black soil region in Northeast China. Due to the obvious rise of temperature and uneven distribution of precipitation in the 20th century, it has been considered to be one of the important reasons for agricultural drought and aridity. Under the background of climate change, understanding the multiyear changes and occurrence characteristics of cultivated land drought in different agricultural regions in Heilongjiang Province is of great significance for the establishment of agricultural drought prediction and early warning system in the future, guiding agricultural high-standard farmland irrigation in different regions, promoting black soil protection, and then improving grain yield. This paper calculates the temperature vegetation drought index (TVDI) based on the normalized difference vegetation index (NDVI) and surface temperature (TS) product data of MODIS from 2000 to 2021. Taking TVDI as the drought evaluation index, this paper studies the temporal and spatial variation distribution characteristics and occurrence frequency of drought in the whole region and four agricultural regions of Heilongjiang Province: Daxing an Mountain and Xiaoxing an Mountain (region I), Sanjiang Plain (region II), Zhangguangcai Mountains (region III), and Songnen Plain (region IV). The results show that medium drought generally occurred in Heilongjiang Province from 2000 to 2021, accounting for about 70% of the total cultivated land. The drought was severe from 2000 to 2009 and weakened from 2010 to 2021. In the 110 months of the crop growing season from 2000 to 2021, about 63.84% of the region suffered more than 60 droughts. It is found that the frequency of drought varies from region to region. More than 80 droughts occurred in the west of region IV and the middle of region II. The characteristics of region IV are large sandstorm, less precipitation, and lack of water conservancy facilities, resulting in frequent and strong drought. It is also found that the occurrence frequency, degree grade and regional distribution of drought are closely related to seasonal changes. In spring, the occurrence grade and frequency of drought in region IV are the strongest and the drought phenomenon is serious. In autumn, drought is frequent and distributed in all regions, but the grade is not strong (mainly medium drought), and the drought phenomenon is medium. It is humid in summer. Crops in Heilongjiang Province are one crop per annual. Spring drought seriously restricts the water content of crops. Long-term drought will lead to poor crop development and reduce yield. Therefore, only by clarifying the characteristics of regional time drought, monitoring accurate drought events and accurately predicting the occurrence of drought, can we guide high-standard farmland precision irrigation, improve crop yield and ensure national food security. At the same time, severe drought will affect the terrestrial ecosystem, resulting in the distribution of crops and microorganisms, and the transformation between carbon sink and carbon source.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{wu2022analysis,
  author = {Li Wu and Youzhi Zhang and Limin Wang and Wenhuan Xie and Lijuan Song and Haifeng Zhang and Hongwen Bi and Yanyan Zheng and Yu Zhang and Xiaofei Zhang and Yan Li and Zhiqun Lv},
  title = {{Analysis of 22-year Drought Characteristics in Heilongjiang Province Based on Temperature Vegetation Drought Index}},
  booktitle = {Computational},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.1155/2022/1003243},
}
Figure