Analysis and Research on Island Development Model and Experience

Kun Zhang, Jia Zhu, Zhuang Li, Haifeng Wang, Wentao Zhang, Xu Chang2020 · DOI

Abstract

In recent years, regardless of whether it is in China or abroad, the popularity of island tours has remained high, and many successful cases have emerged, which have reference significance for the recreational development of Jiajing Island. However, each island has its own particularities and cannot be generalized. It is not advisable to copy the development model of other islands in its entirety. The article summarizes some successful island development cases at home and abroad. By analyzing the characteristics of its development and development process, it hopes to play a role in the development of Jiajing Island.

Introduction: The Challenge of Island Development

As island tourism surges in popularity, developers face a significant "copy-paste" problem: attempting to replicate successful models without considering an island's specific ecological and geographical constraints. For emerging sites like Jiajing Island in China, the challenge is twofold: how to achieve economic success without exceeding the "ecological carrying capacity" and how to differentiate the destination in a crowded market. This paper extracts transferable strategies from established global and domestic leaders to guide this development.

Methodology

The researchers employ a comparative case study analysis, evaluating three distinct development models:

  1. The Maldives' "Four Ones" Model: A centralized approach focusing on strict approval processes and singular developer responsibility.
  2. Wuzhizhou Island’s Whole-Lease Model: A domestic example of high-end positioning and integrated ecological restoration (marine pastures).
  3. Xiamen’s "String Island Tour": A government-led initiative that treats a cluster of uninhabited islands as a single, diversified ecosystem with specialized themes for each node.
The Maldives' strict island development approval process.

Key Insights from Global Models

The Maldives: The "Four Ones" Strategy

The Maldives' success is attributed to a model where one island has one developer, one resort, and one distinct style. This prevents "homogenization"—the tendency for all resorts to look and feel the same—and makes environmental protection the legal responsibility of a single entity. Additionally, the Maldives uses high-end cruise routes to shift tourist venues, maintaining revenue while reducing land-based ecological pressure.

Aerial view of a high-end 'one island, one resort' development model.

Wuzhizhou Island: Ecological Offensive as Defense

Wuzhizhou Island pioneered the "Ocean Ranch" concept. By restoring offshore fishery resources and creating tropical marine pastures, they turned ecological restoration into a tourism draw, proving that conservation and commercialization can be synergistic. This whole-island leasing model allows for holistic environmental management, resulting in seawater visibility reaching 27 meters.

Xiamen: Government as the Architect

The Xiamen case highlights that for uninhabited islands, the government must lead with a "protection first" mandate. Their "one island, one policy" approach assigns specific themes (e.g., science education for Dalipu Island, leisure for Jiyu Island) to ensure the islands complement rather than compete with each other.

Key Results and Performance

  • Market Performance: Wuzhizhou Island, through high-end positioning and "private customization" marketing, saw a 15.78% year-on-year increase in tourists during the 2017 Spring Festival.
  • Investment Scale: Xiamen’s "string island tour" project involves an investment of 4.1 billion yuan across eight uninhabited islands, demonstrating the massive capital required for integrated, sustainable development.
  • Ecological Visibility: Wuzhizhou Island achieved a "national 5A-level" status, largely due to its integrated management model.

Conclusion and Future Directions

While these models provide a strategic framework, Jiajing Island cannot perfectly mirror Wuzhizhou Island due to differences in resource endowments. Future research and planning must focus on determining the specific ecological carrying capacity of Jiajing Island to set hard limits on tourist numbers and developing a unique "scene" that avoids direct competition with nearby established islands. Navigating the high policy and planning requirements necessary to implement a Maldives-style model remains a critical hurdle for future implementation.

Summary updated

Abstract

In recent years, regardless of whether it is in China or abroad, the popularity of island tours has remained high, and many successful cases have emerged, which have reference significance for the recreational development of Jiajing Island. However, each island has its own particularities and cannot be generalized. It is not advisable to copy the development model of other islands in its entirety. The article summarizes some successful island development cases at home and abroad. By analyzing the characteristics of its development and development process, it hopes to play a role in the development of Jiajing Island.
BibTeX
@misc{zhang2020analysis,
  author = {Kun Zhang and Jia Zhu and Zhuang Li and Haifeng Wang and Wentao Zhang and Xu Chang},
  title = {{Analysis and Research on Island Development Model and Experience}},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.2991/assehr.k.200801.051},
}
Figure