TL;DR
This study uses eye-tracking technology to objectively measure how people perceive and prefer different types of rural public spaces in China. By combining this objective data with subjective satisfaction scores, the research provides valuable insights for optimizing rural landscape design and management to better serve user needs and promote sustainable development.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
Rapid urbanization in China has led to significant changes in rural areas, often resulting in the loss of public space character, homogenization, and a disconnect between the built environment and local needs. While urban landscape preference studies are common, research on rural public spaces, particularly from the user's perspective, is less developed. This paper addresses this gap by investigating the subconscious visual preferences of both local residents and visitors for different rural public space typologies, aiming to provide data-driven strategies for landscape optimization and sustainable rural development.
Methods
The core of this research lies in the application of eye-tracking technology to objectively measure visual attention and preference. The study involved 20 participants (local residents and tourists) who were exposed to four distinct types of rural public spaces in Huangshandian Village: square space, street space, waterfront space, and public green space.
Key methodological components include:
- Eye-Movement Experiment: Participants viewed real-world scenes of these public spaces. Eye movements were recorded using a portable head-mounted eye-tracking device at 120 Hz.
- Eye-Movement Indicators: The analysis focused on four key metrics:
- Average Fixation Duration: Indicates the time spent looking at a specific area, suggesting interest and cognitive processing.
- Fixation Count: Reflects the number of fixations per unit of time, indicating the importance or processing efficiency of an area.
- Average Saccade Amplitude: Measures the average eye jump size, suggesting the distinctiveness of features and the range of visual search.
- Saccade Count: Represents the number of eye jumps per unit time, indicating search behavior and the clarity of image characteristics.
- Subjective Satisfaction Evaluation: After the eye-tracking experiment, participants completed a questionnaire to rate their satisfaction with each space on a scale of 1-5.
- Data Analysis: Statistical analysis was performed using Excel and SPSS to compare eye-movement data across different space types and user groups, and to analyze the correlation between objective eye-tracking data and subjective satisfaction scores.
Datasets
The study utilized real-world public space scenes from Huangshandian Village, Beijing, China. No specific datasets were created or introduced beyond the photographic and visual stimuli derived from these locations. The research focused on analyzing participant responses to these existing environments.
Key Insights and Ideas
- Objective vs. Subjective Alignment: The study found a significant correlation between objective eye-tracking data and subjective satisfaction ratings, validating eye-tracking as a robust tool for understanding landscape preferences.
- Divergent User Needs: While both locals and visitors showed interest in public green spaces and waterfront areas, their specific attention patterns and preferences differed, highlighting the importance of considering distinct user groups in design.
- Feature Distinctness Matters: The distinctiveness of landscape features strongly influences visual attention. Spaces with more prominent or unique elements (like streetscapes with characteristic architecture) tend to capture more attention.
- "Subjective Space" Revealed: Eye-tracking helps uncover the subconscious "subjective space" users create, revealing what elements truly capture their attention and contribute to their perception of quality.
Key Results
- Preference Ranking: Across all participants, the street space received the highest subjective satisfaction score (3.98), while the square space received the lowest (2.69). Objectively, participants showed the most interest in public green spaces, followed by waterfront, street, and then square spaces, based on fixation duration and count.
- User Group Differences: Visitors generally exhibited longer fixation durations and larger saccade amplitudes, suggesting they engaged more actively in exploring new environments. Local residents, however, showed higher fixation counts for waterfront and public green spaces, possibly due to familiarity and emotional attachment.
- Space-Specific Attention:
- Square spaces attracted attention to height differences and architectural elements, but were perceived as less distinctive.
- Street spaces drew focus to the vanishing point, building details, and greenery, leading to higher satisfaction.
- Waterfront spaces captured attention on landscape facilities, greenery, and distant views, with less focus on the immediate water scene.
- Public green spaces attracted attention to vegetation, buildings, and overall atmosphere.
- Correlation Findings: Subjective satisfaction was positively correlated with average fixation duration across all space types. Street and waterfront spaces showed a negative correlation with fixation and saccade counts, suggesting their clear characteristics led to less searching and higher satisfaction.
Limitations and Future Work
- Limited Scope: The study focused on four specific types of public spaces in one village. The authors acknowledge that this may not cover all rural public space typologies and suggest further research to broaden the scope.
- Sample Size: The study involved a relatively small sample size (20 participants), which limits the generalizability of the findings. The authors recommend expanding the sample size and population background in future studies.
- Future Design Interventions: The authors suggest future work could involve testing new design schemes and comparing eye-tracking data and subjective evaluations before and after landscape transformation to assess the effectiveness of optimization strategies.
Summary updated